Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is Stack Overflow Dead?

news.ycombinator.com

21–29 of 29 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is Stack Overflow Dead?

#21
They started deleting questions that aren't generic enough to be applicable beyond the person that answered. Fair enough. But I put a decent amount of time into the answers I provided and when they do this it removes the "karma" from the person that answered.

I don't answer for SO points but dropping below a certain threshold removes features.

I'm done with the place.

Re: Ask HN: Is Stack Overflow Dead?

#24
It has been dying way before AI Tools. Their approach to moderation has IMO killed it, what used to feel like a community started to feel like a dictatorship w. mods deciding how people should behave, what's a valid question etc.

Re: Ask HN: Is Stack Overflow Dead?

#25
I deleted my account, and stopped visiting it at least five years ago.

Too often old answers would be frozen in time, not being updated for new software and better solutions. Similarly most questions got closed as "duplicate" even when they were not.

You can find questions such as "My DNS isn't working", with answers like "Have you tried disabling your firewall?" and it's feels like the blind leading the blind, like PHP developers fixing installations via "chmod 777".

LLMs are terrible, but stackoverflow is definitely worse.

Re: Ask HN: Is Stack Overflow Dead?

#26
The entire Stack Exchange network is collapsing: [The number of questions has decreased 10-fold: where did users go and what can be done to prevent that?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/408728/178179)

As for Stack Overflow, the number of questions has decreased 25-fold (!) since 2018. A single person could now answer all new questions if they had nothing else to do.

Re: Ask HN: Is Stack Overflow Dead?

#27

I'm a Stack Overflow elected moderator (one of these users: https://stackoverflow.com/users?tab=moderators ) First, a disclaimer: I do not speak for other elected moderators, nor for Stack Exchange Inc. My views are my own. Site traffic has been declining for a long time and that's not a mystery. Empirically, the rise of Large Language Models has sped up the decline or at least did not reverse the trend. This is both…

> In fact, SO has a great opportunity to specialize in answering questions that LLMs cannot answer (bleeding edge technology, complex debugging problems, emerging issues, you name it.)

But they are missing that opportunity because such questions typically get no answer and no votes (or sometimes even downvoted as some users tend to downvote questions they don't understand), which caused them to be automatically deleted later. And some of these questions will be closed e.g. as too niche (complex debugging problems). I've posted over 7000 questions across Stack Exchange and that's my experience.

> quick and confident-sounding answers to whatever problem you throw at them.

Just like an answer on Stack Overflow.

Re: Ask HN: Is Stack Overflow Dead?

#28

I deleted my account, and stopped visiting it at least five years ago. Too often old answers would be frozen in time, not being updated for new software and better solutions. Similarly most questions got closed as "duplicate" even when they were not. You can find questions such as "My DNS isn't working", with answers like "Have you tried disabling your firewall?" and it's feels like the blind leading the blind, like…

> LLMs are terrible, but stackoverflow is definitely worse.

Exactly. Some stackoverflow users keep complaining about AI slop but they fail to realize that human slop is much more rampant.

Re: Ask HN: Is Stack Overflow Dead?

#29
post #8

It will be used to answer the harder questions that AI models can't answer.

But harder questions will typically get no replies and/or get closed for being too niche and/or get downvoted because someone got upset they didn't understand the question. That's my experience.
Post reply on HN