Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 36 posts

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#22
You don't have to jump. Not all progress goes forwards. As anyone who's familiar with web frameworks and crypto knows, most of the paths lead to dead ends.

Play with things. Treat them as a toy, not as homework. Eventually you'll get a feel for what is useful and what is someone trying to sell you something.

The first time I actually got something from a MCP was when I just asked claude to check my emails for anything I need to act on. I had 8 emails in the inbox, didn't expect it to find anything. But it found an important request from accounting that was cc-ed and forwarded multiple times to the point I didn't see the actual ask. It was also some tedious bureaucratic stuff so Claude write the response to it in 2 minutes and I didn't have to procrastinate on it the whole morning.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#23
Leaning how to use AI in the upcoming years will be equivalent to knowing how to use the internet and microsoft office in the 2010s. You don't need to absolutely know it, but

The thing with AI is that its pretty easy to use - 80% of it is just prompt engineering. For example, agents are nothing more than a big system prompt to really any LLM, with instructions like "if you want to create a code file, surround the code with tags", and then the wrapper program that runs the chat detects those tags and actually does the thing.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#24
Perhaps it'll be interesting to see where AI and crypto intersect.

People are getting dumber, sicker and poorer, are they not? There'll be a need to change that. Make me healthy, wealthy and wise. And Vibing means more apps and ideas can be tested. Deployed is another story. Voice recognition will be more important I suspect as people stop reading and writing. How do people avoid the robots overall?

With AI, you can take an old app, and update it and modernize it, right? I was using this web app a long time ago. Would be cool to get it right for 2025. https://uipublish.sourceforge.net/ - who else would want to do that?

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#25
Probably, but not for the reasons you think.

There are segments of the software industry where competence matters: security, finance, healthcare, games, and some more. But most of the rest of software is bodies filling seats mashing buttons.

One way to be a rising star as a button masher, framework junky, or other benchwarmer is merchandising your most valuable product, yourself. At this time nothing screams hot trend as loudly as AI. Like all hot air this bubble will eventually pop. You can choose to hop on the AI fashion train while people are throwing money to the wind or you can go back to mindless button mashing.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#26
Depends on what your goal is.

Every few months LLM's get markedly better. In days GPT-5 will come out which by early reports (and anecdotal evidence on LMarena) is substantively better than the best current coding models. Will it surpass humans? It is a possibility, unless there is some yet unforeseen impassable intelligence gap below human intelligence and above SOTA AI intelligence.

Coding as a hobby seems to be more fun for people without AI tools. You get the experience of more completely holding the system in your head, your interaction with the codebase is more intuitive and connected deeply to your natural reasoning faculties. However, I believe the purism of eschewing AI tools is a trap that had few consequences in 2023, or even 2024, but by the end of 2025, the standard for what a "productive software developer" can accomplish in a week will be set by the boon AI tools give to mid and senior developers.

That's it, there's no getting around the reality of technological progress. Soon after that, there will be few if any humans in the loop at all for all except the highest level executive decisions. Coding will be an artisan task done for personal enjoyment, like knitting or cooking.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#27
> And now I fear that if I don’t try out or even start using AI tools that I’ll get overrun.

You can do this quite easily. Ask ChatGPT to come up with a nice cooking recipe and just take it from there. Ask it all kinds of questions and ask yourself what you find useful.

> Do I even need to know what is MCP?

No. And this comes from someone that uses it as I'm a developer. You might want a high level understanding of what tool-use is and what different LLMs are capable of doing. If you find LLMs useful then you might even want to equip Claude desktop with some tools that have been created for everyone to use.

For your perspective: MCP enables tool-use. Well, there are other ways, but MCP standardizes it.

> Do I need to start creating apps and sites using Vibe coding (I’m not a developer)?

At best, vibe coded apps allow you to create high fidelity prototypes, which is amazing but you can't create a fully functional product with just vibe coding. There may be the odd exception that made it work, but I suspect that would take a lot of effort with the current state of the art. I'd recommend lovable.dev if you want to create a prototype.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#28
Next time you’re trying to do something a little outside your comfort zone ask Claude to make a plan of execution. You’ll probably be pleasantly surprised. And the fact that it can do that is all you need to know (and that it can do that for anyone doing basically anything)

But keep in mind that it goes spectacularly wrong sometimes because: It doesn’t have a way to verify facts. It doesn’t always follow best practices (like a junior employee eager to please forgetting his training) And sometimes it is very convincingly incorrect.

If you keep in mind those abilities and limitations you’ll know everything you need to know.

Oh also that maybe it’s becoming the largest consumer of energy in the world and may automate some or all of some or all jobs. (sometime in the next five years or never depending on which predictions you listen to)

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#30

If you’re not a developer you might as well use AI to become one? Back in my day we used learn x in y minutes to get up to speed on a new language and then a week to get comfortable. Now I can do that for anything in like 15 minutes. Of course, coding is the easy part and anyone can do it. Software engineering (key word: engineering) is the hard part and requires that you understand the computer, design patterns, and…

Why should they want to become a developer? There is no need for everyone to become one.
Post reply on HN