Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 133 posts

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#21

Justifying lower pay with "we just want people who truly believe in the mission"

I had a recruiter trying to convince me to take an offer lower than my current salary, telling me it’s not all about the money. I told him I’d do it if he made up the difference by giving me some of his salary. He told me he’s not giving me his salary to which I replied “it’s not all about the money”

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#22

I've walked out of an interview when the employee doing it took a phone call in the middle of it. It was so rude and disrespectful. I once got a whiteboarding problem and proposed a solution, and the interviewer gave me a flat out "that's not the one I had in mind". I'd already asked clarifying questions and thought my proposal was reasonable in light of the constraints as I understood them. After a few minutes of tr…

So many interviewers fall into the old xkcd “communicating poorly then acting smug when you’re misunderstood is not cleverness”.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#23
All of these have happened to me:

- The interviewer is wearing a suit.

- The interviewer asks "you've worked with [person who now works at our company] before, what do you think about them?". Bonus points if they insist after I give a diplomatic answer.

- "Why are you using microservices?" "Because everyone is doing it"

- Not following up. For weeks.

- "Can you send us your high school diploma?"

- Take home assignment with a time limit.

- No feedback on take home assignment except "we didn't like your approach".

- Developers use separate laptops for coding and for internet access.

- There are three architects on a single project.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#24
Back when in-person interviews were a thing, I’d use the opportunity to just look at the office space.

Specific red flag signals:

1. Dominated by Windows

2. Too many people in formals

3. Nobody wears badges (and other indicators of a lax security policy)

4. Old/worn out office furniture

5. Low resolution displays

6. Old laptops

7. No evidence of people collaborating or chatting at a microkitchen etc.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#25
When they start describing the dysfunction in their team or the org as a whole. One interviewer talks about a "legacy team" that needs help "modernizing" and "migrating to the cloud", and then you talk to the "legacy team" and they don't think they need any help. Or they're just a collection of acquisitions with no standardization. Or they try to avoid talking to corporate IT about anything. Or they regularly get woken up at 3am on-call. Or they deploy less than once a week, or need someone to manually validate it and schedule it and have all-hands-on-deck. Or you ask about test coverage and they laugh. Or they have one database for 100 services. I don't find a ton of huge deal breakers, but a lot of "ehhhhhh......." things. The biggest deal breakers are attitude and culture, whether the business creates abusive demands on employees, signs of poor leadership, disorganization. And pay. The business shows you what they really think of you in their offers.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#27

Back when in-person interviews were a thing, I’d use the opportunity to just look at the office space. Specific red flag signals: 1. Dominated by Windows 2. Too many people in formals 3. Nobody wears badges (and other indicators of a lax security policy) 4. Old/worn out office furniture 5. Low resolution displays 6. Old laptops 7. No evidence of people collaborating or chatting at a microkitchen etc.

I like working at places small enough that we don't need badges because everyone just knows each other. I remember way back at an old company (that was quite large by the time I joined) learning that someone had quit rather than wear a badge as the company "grew up". I thought it was nuts back then, and I still would be willing to make that compromise myself, but I get it a lot more these days.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#28
If they have the company values written on the wall, it probably means they don't actually live them.

Engineering leadership doesn't understand (or care about) the business side.

Trying to shoehorn you into a role obviously you're overqualified for.

A focus more on time spent and dedication rather than achievements and outcomes.

No clear business model. Maybe it isn't an issue today, but for 99% of businesses it will be an issue soon.

A pattern of getting interns or juniors to do an initial chunk of work, and then getting seniors to clean up after them, rather than letting seniors lay a foundation and the juniors/interns filling in the gaps.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#29
post #23

All of these have happened to me: - The interviewer is wearing a suit. - The interviewer asks "you've worked with [person who now works at our company] before, what do you think about them?". Bonus points if they insist after I give a diplomatic answer. - "Why are you using microservices?" "Because everyone is doing it" - Not following up. For weeks. - "Can you send us your high school diploma?" - Take home assignmen…

"Take home assignment with a time limit."

What's your concern there? (Honest question!) I feel terrible about asking for home assignments but I feel like it's good for people like myself who are terrible about coding live. (I usually have a choice of live or homework.) I put a "limit" as a guideline about what kind of quality to expect, usually with language about things not to worry about. I don't expect/want folks to burn a bunch of time on things.

Re: Ask HN: What are your personal red flags when you're interviewing at a company?

#30
The ones that come to mind:

* If they are a small company who outsources any step of their interview process to another company. If you're only interviewing for a couple positions—people you will work with every single day—take the time to do it yourself.

* If they are a startup that says they are looking for people who are interested in solving exciting problems. For some people, this is going to be an enticement, but based on my experience, what I hear is "we're going to work you like a dog and pay you in equity, and at the end neither your work nor your equity will matter because we're definitely going to go out of business". I recognize this is a bias, but it's happened to me a couple times, and I'm in my 40s now and just not having it anymore. Plus, the problems are never that exciting, they're usually "how to sell a SaaS product that is basically a CRUD app, in a crowded marketplace with lots of competitors".

* If the interview is composed of like 10 rounds of 30 minute interviews, each with different groups in the company, that to me is an indicator that Conway's Law is at the helm of that organization: lots of groups that want input into everything, nobody empowered to make a decision on their own. Plus, it's just not a very good format. Give me a smaller number of hour long sessions where we can actually get into it, rather than racing through pro forma questions.

Post reply on HN