Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What new laptop would you get?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 32 posts

Re: Ask HN: What new laptop would you get?

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same. I kept using laptops for many years after moving to home office but last year decided to go back to a desktop (micro-ATX build). I get 4-5x the performance of my last work laptop (Dell XPS i9) for the same price. It's dead silent and has a ton of ports.

Can you share specs and places from where you sourced the parts.

Sourced at local companies in my country and not latest gen (Intel 14th gen was too new when I bought it and was overpriced. Same for DDR5).

- Thermaltake Silencio S400

- PSU MSI MAG A850GL

- ASUS B760M-PLUS WIFI D4

- Intel i5 13600K

- 4x16GB Corsair DDR4 3600MHz

- NVME WD Black SN770 2TB

- ASUS TUF Gaming RTX 4070 Ti Super (16GB)

Re: Ask HN: What new laptop would you get?

#24
My company uses MacBooks and I hate it. Second time Mac hardware stopped working the week after warranty ended.

I believe Macs are great if you have sensitive data inside or proprietary source code inside; if your company locks them nobody can get the files that are inside.

Re: Ask HN: What new laptop would you get?

#25

I grew up with Asus and Acer and then Dells and Alienwares and Surface Books and ThinkPads and Razers, comfortably in the Wintel world. But the Apple Silicon laptops are so far ahead it's not even a comparison. Especially if you want to be able to run Photoshop natively (ie not emulated in Linux). Forget the metal dings. The new ones have smoother edges, I think. Run an automatic backup to somewhere else. The hardwar…

> Sorry, probably not the answer you wanted to hear It's validation. Windows has gone downhill, Apple locks you in, you use Linux on principle.

I admire your dedication to the cause!

Re: Ask HN: What new laptop would you get?

#26
Question: Do you like to work unplugged with the laptop on your lap?

Answer-Yes: get a macbook. The apple M chips are the best (only?) way to get desktop power in a battery efficient package.

Answer-No: don't get a laptop at all. Get a big fat juicy desktop, AMD chip, linux.

Re: Ask HN: What new laptop would you get?

#27
post #19

I disagree that 2024 is not the year of Linux on the desktop. You will probably have some trouble with Photoshop, since Adobe seems to hate Linux, but otherwise you will find that Linux is a very smooth experience. If you are happy with your current Thinkpad apart from Windows, maybe get a new Thinkpad and give Linux a whirl. You can always revert to Windows if Linux doesn't work. My personal hardware recommendation…

Asking honestly, not to troll, but is everything still an ordeal? Last time I tried, I remember having issues with my printer, hidpi display, external USB-C display, configuring the thinkpad trackpoint, not to mention UI inconsistencies worse than than 6 generations of Windows UIs.

Re: Ask HN: What new laptop would you get?

#29
post #19

I disagree that 2024 is not the year of Linux on the desktop. You will probably have some trouble with Photoshop, since Adobe seems to hate Linux, but otherwise you will find that Linux is a very smooth experience. If you are happy with your current Thinkpad apart from Windows, maybe get a new Thinkpad and give Linux a whirl. You can always revert to Windows if Linux doesn't work. My personal hardware recommendation…

Asking honestly, not to troll, but is everything still an ordeal? Last time I tried, I remember having issues with my printer, hidpi display, external USB-C display, configuring the thinkpad trackpoint, not to mention UI inconsistencies worse than than 6 generations of Windows UIs.

In my experience, hardware-related issues mostly happens with stuff that was just released. If you don't mind waiting a few months before ordering, there are usually few problems.

As for UI inconsistencies, I believe they depend a lot on your GUI of choice.

Re: Ask HN: What new laptop would you get?

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same. I kept using laptops for many years after moving to home office but last year decided to go back to a desktop (micro-ATX build). I get 4-5x the performance of my last work laptop (Dell XPS i9) for the same price. It's dead silent and has a ton of ports.

Can you share specs and places from where you sourced the parts.

- AMD 3900x

- 32gb DDR4 3400

- Nvidia 2080TI

- Gigabyte Aorus Master

- WD_BLACK SN850

Post reply on HN