Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What are your thoughts on ChatGPT as a professional?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 65 posts

Re: Ask HN: What are your thoughts on ChatGPT as a professional?

#21
I see plenty of people at work use it. I don't, because I feel like understanding a topic takes time. However, this applies to the work I do. Having an instant boilerplate generator is nice, I guess.

I think if anything, you'll be spending a lot of time code reviewing AI output. Reading code and thinking about if its failure cases is a good thing. Having to constantly do this could make you sharper at that. (EDIT:) Also to clarify that you are still the one that has to see the forest from the trees with the problems you are working, so the "how things fit together" is still a skill to develop.

Re: Ask HN: What are your thoughts on ChatGPT as a professional?

#22
I use ChatGPT everyday and I am sure it is a great, novel, and revolutionary tool. I said I am sure because I can measure how ChatGPT inproves my daily work. I don't use it for software development because I am in a management role now.

The first insight is that an article that I need to publish could be proofread immediately while before I used an incredible professional content editor that could take hours for reviewing and improving the article. The editor continues to work for us though ;-). In general, the ChatGPT answers should not be copy and pasted but be merged with your content.

Another insight is that ChatGPT is gradually replacing or being a complement to Google Search. Google Search is terrible nowadays and simple questions in ChatGPT are a good way to start a search in a domain that you are not expert at. It needs a dialectic approach but works.

I would say garbage-in / garbage-out: if you interact with original questions the tool could be more insightful but be always critical of the output.

Re: Ask HN: What are your thoughts on ChatGPT as a professional?

#24
It's really still too early to say. Everyone has widely different opinions about it. You'll find plenty of people advocating for it and plenty against it. I say that if you're able to explain it to people in a similar way to how you've explained here, most will be understanding.

Re: Ask HN: What are your thoughts on ChatGPT as a professional?

#25
I jump around languages and solutions a fair bit so I use it in place of Google + API docs. "I need to do X with this language, in this stack, what APIs are available?". I find I get better results than Google and some of the more wordy, dispersed docs (.net, anything Apple).

I have tried copilot in my IDE, but I just don't see the value. About 50% of the time the suggestions are not useful or correct, 50% of the time the suggestions are what I was typing which is exactly what code completion does.

Re: Ask HN: What are your thoughts on ChatGPT as a professional?

#26

It makes mistakes all the time even for simple tasks.

Whenever someone says this, I always wonder whether we're talking about the same tool. GPT-3.5 scores at the bottom 10% in a lot of tasks where GPT-4 scores in the top 10%.

Re: Ask HN: What are your thoughts on ChatGPT as a professional?

#28
Use it. It's going to sometimes accelerate your understanding hugely because you can interrogate it about a new area. It's also going to lie to you, quite often, and give you rubbish code / suggestions. Learn to figure out where it's good and where it's rubbish.

Ask it to explain every line of something, after the fact. Ask it for better ways of doing things. Ask it how you can make code more robust, what and how you can test it. Be better than your peers at using it. The world will only increase usage of this new thing so why not just be really good at it.

In the grand scheme of things it's about the value that you add, and some of that will be getting into a new problem fast and sometimes it'll be your understanding of fundamentals. Do both, use whatever tools you need. Buy books, read open source code, read blogs, use AI.

Re: Ask HN: What are your thoughts on ChatGPT as a professional?

#29
I think it's relatively useful when you don't take the approach of blindly trusting it or expecting it to be able to do stuff it can't do.

I'm getting the most out of it when I'm doing stuff so new to me that I don't have the right words to even search on google, there it's very useful to try and ask it questions the same way I'd ask a (non-asshole) human, and rather than (intentionally misunderstanding my by taking every word literally and assuming I know what it means), it will try and explain what it understood form what I said..

Non-technical example where I found it easier to just ask chatgpt is "What's that spice that some people really hate and says tastes like soap, and others don't really mind?"

"exactly, what's it called in danish"

very natural exchange and gave the right answer

Re: Ask HN: What are your thoughts on ChatGPT as a professional?

#30
I use ChatGPT all the time at work.

I find it particularly useful when I'm responding to a client with something technical. ChatGPT can sharpen up the message, clarify points in a client-friendly way, and hit the right tone.

Great for throwing around ideas and getting some feedback before diving into the code too.

I find it's easy to go wrong if you're too trusting of the output though. For important questions, I'll get some initial guidance from ChatGPT to refine my research rather than outright accept any answer it gives.

Post reply on HN