Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 270 posts

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#21
Hiring freezes are not really freezes. It is more like, "try extra hard to justify more headcount." Companies will always have some need for specialized skills and knowledge.

Since you are a high achiever in an in-demand field, you should still have good leverage during the job search. I would hold out for a role or company which you believe will suit your skill set.

I would not, under any circumstances, hold out for a "perfect" fit. It is unlikely to exist and if the company/recruiter is making it seem perfect they are almost certainly lying to you. A former colleague of mine was burned by this not long ago.

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#22
I've been through the dotcom slaughter of 2000-2002 as a new grad (undergrad) and the comparatively small slowdown of 2008 (grad school new grad). Get ready to hit the Submit button... a lot. The stories of "getting three job offers after four interviews at five companies" are no longer reality. My application:interview:offer ratio has always varied from 50:5:1 to 100:10:1, and I would expect something like that or worse for the next ~12 months or however long it takes for tech CEOs to stop cargo culting each other's panic. Unlike some advice you're likely going to get in this thread, I'd highly recommend shotgunning your resume to as many viable tech companies as you can, and even looking at line-of-business programming at non-tech companies. Now is not really the time to be picky, especially if you're on your own and have rent/bills to pay or support your family.

I ended up close to insolvent during the 2008 recession, and I bit the bullet and took a terrible job just to get by. Be willing to swallow your pride and do the same if that's what it takes. That little voice in the back of your head that says "Well I just graduated from Stanford! Surely I can do better than this!" Ignore it for now.

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#23
As a 20 year vet and someone who entered the market during the first crash in 2001. Apply everywhere, give a little extra in interviews and be prepared to work in a language you didn't expect.

To get my first position involved applying everywhere no matter the skillset asked. When I finally landed an interview we had to create an application. I created an application an hour after the interview was complete emailed it over and that sold me. They didn't believe I did this myself so quickly I had to provide some of my db scripts. The other candidates were stronger on paper (finished a 4 year computer science degree) but none could finish or finish as completely as I did.

It turned a little rough. One of the other candidates came in for lunch a week after I was hired. The founder and this person became friends during the interview process. She literally brokedown and cried that day because she wanted the job so badly. I'm surprised they didn't hire her just based on culture fit but this was a nonprofit with one 6 month contract available and tons of challenging problems to tackle.

My advice is to grind it out and pry that first job out however you can.

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#24
I graduated in 2001, the dot com bust, took a year and a half to get a job, and that was partially based on a previous degree in biology. This advice is based on my experience from 20 years ago, so I hope it is still relevant.

I was sending out a lot of CVs treating it more or less as a full time job. In the UK at the time the job center would pay for postage for applications, though these days paper applications are a lot less common.

Places that accepted CVs got a lot lower responses than big corporations with their long winded online forms that took a couple of hours or more to fill out, with the usual crappy questions of "give an example e of when you displayed leadership qualities" and the likes. Keep a note of your responses, as after a few, it becomes a lot less effort, as you have probably answered a similar question in a previous one, and can just copy paste with a little adjustment.

Get some interview practice and get good at that. Looking back I was pretty down after a while saying things like "I'll take anything at this point" when I asked why I wanted the job. True, but not what potential employers want to hear. Think of it from the employers point of view and what they want to hear. Again, practice helps and you get better with time.

I got a couple of temporary jobs one for pretty minimal wage but that made a huge difference actually having some real world experience on my CV in terms of getting invited for interviews.

Have some code that you can show people. Build some example projects. I would advise spending some time building a more comprehensive project one time to show that rather than doing a crappy throwaway project from scratch for each interview - something I still seem expected to do after 20 years of experience. The hiring process in this industry sucks and is very exploitative in this way, happy to waste candidates time like this.

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#25
Oh, new grads are golden, they have almost nothing worry about. The companies laying off workers are pushing out the senior, highly-paid, most expensive employees. They will quickly and eagerly replace with them with naive, low-paid (relatively), eager-to-drink-the-koolaid fresh grads. The only thing the new grads might have to worry about is that they probably won't get as much money as they would have prior to the layoff waves. Well, that and the fact that as entry-level grunts they will be treated like garbage and employers will take advantage of their lack of experience in identifying and fighting unfair working conditions, wage theft, discriminatory hiring and advancement, and so on.

So, go out and grab the best job you can. Just be prepared for the life at the bottom of the hill.

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#26

> Is it better to get any job than keep searching for the job I'd be most suited for? In general I'd say no although I'm not sure it applies to you. I know some people who graduated into the Internet apocalypse of 2002. They picked up crappy jobs and then got pigeon-holed into that crappy job for a very long time. It's a lot easier to get a job in a cool field as a new grad than it is as someone with experience doing…

You can always take a crappy job to pay the bills while looking for something better. You can decide later if you want to put it on your resume or not.

But you're out of the new grad hiring pipeline. It's probably different in 2022 than it was in 2002, but in 2002 when companies wanted to hire new grads they posted jobs at Universities and did job fairs at Universities. So if you weren't at a University it was harder to get a new grad job.

And you have a hole in your resume you have to explain.

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#27

Don't see layoffs as an indicator of industry health. These are corrections, not melt downs. Go apply and do interviews, there are plenty of companies looking for talent.

I like the optimism but I suspect we're still in the early stages of this process. There's lots of bubble to unwind here, and this mess hasn't even started to untangle. I recently came across this quote from PG in one of his earlier essays [0] describing the early days of the dotcom bust regarding yahoo. Sounds very similar to the situation we're in now: > It was not just our price to earnings ratio that was bogus. H…

We are nothing like that situation. This was a common problem in the .com bust days in that the money was often just being passed around. Double Click had a similar situation where they had a good business but many of their customers didn't. But they (and other solid business) did make it through the purge and went on to be big successes.

Today we have an ecosystem that is far more diverse and what I'd call "real". Yes, there's probably quite a few over valued dogs out there but there are a lot of businesses that are legit creating revenue streams and growing well past 20%, 30%, etc. This is why I believe the parent is right in that we are in a harsh correction and not a meltdown.

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#28
I would give different advice to someone getting a Bachelors vs someone getting a PhD.

For BS CS/EE (or any engineering field): do not overthink the "recession is coming" news. US employers always want young engineers, as they consider them energetic, willing to learn and work for less salary than late career staff. Look up and polish the in demand skills. Brush up on the basics (Python, databases, git) at least to the extent of being able to solve "one step up from fizzbuzz" problems. And apply. You might get less generous terms and no sign-up bonus, but you are almost certain to still land something that you can use as a springboard 2-3 years later.

For PhD in AI: I would apply to good companies only and consider deferring graduation for a year if your fishing turns up nothing. This requires both your mental readiness and your advisor's physical/financial one, but in general your advisor should be thrilled to have you work for him another year for a relative pittance of a graduate stipend. It should not come to this (the market is not dead), but I would personally take it easy and focus on the job search for another year in grad school over taking some soul-sucking job at a company no one has heard of.

My 2c. And good luck!

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#29
Lots of great advice here already.

The one thing I'd add is look beyond "tech sector" companies. Your skill set can be translated and refocused for any number of industries that will thrive in the coming years (e.g. food producers, energy, natural resources, healthcare, etc).

One way to do this is if your institute has a co-op program, reach out to the head and express interest in industries that could be interesting to get into. They'll likely be happy to help and connect a Top AI Expert with companies the university already works with. Of course you'll be doing more applicative work than theoretical

Re: Ask HN: With recent layoffs, how would you advise new grads entering the market?

#30

I've been through the dotcom slaughter of 2000-2002 as a new grad (undergrad) and the comparatively small slowdown of 2008 (grad school new grad). Get ready to hit the Submit button... a lot. The stories of "getting three job offers after four interviews at five companies" are no longer reality. My application:interview:offer ratio has always varied from 50:5:1 to 100:10:1, and I would expect something like that or w…

You must have been in the industry for the same time as me. Your ratio of interviews to offers is kind of encouraging, and at the same time depressing - I have just changed jobs and got a number of rejections. What bothers me most is the time wasted on throwaway "technical challenges" where the reasons for rejection are mostly outside of the specification, and a perfect solution would be in the order of a weeks work, not the few hours that they said it should take. I have a full time job and limited free time to put into these things.
Post reply on HN