Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Review my MVP - Scenic Motorcycle Routes from Three Rides

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 36 posts

Re: Ask HN: Review my MVP - Scenic Motorcycle Routes from Three Rides

#21
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You beat me to it! That's exactly what I was thinking... I would love to have a site just show me great rides for cyclists.

Check our site out - http://ridewithgps.com

That's exactly what I was looking for... I already found a route I had no idea existed right near my house. Thanks!

Re: Ask HN: Review my MVP - Scenic Motorcycle Routes from Three Rides

#22

I like the idea, and I hope you focus your efforts on a mobile application. Having a good ride database is definitely cool, but there are existing ride databases out there (EveryTrail, RideWithGPS). What there isn't though, is an adhoc notification system for going on rides. What would be really cool to have is a mobile app that notified me when someone was going to start a ride in my area. As a motorcycle rider myse…

Some more specific feedback to the actual site, not the concept. The routes need more content - maps are important, but without ideas of what I am going to encounter, descriptions, titles, categories, it's not too helpful. Categories are important as well, because there are so many different styles of riding. Out on my dualsport, I don't care if I hit bad pavement (I might actually WANT bad or no pavement). On my R6,…

I agree about the content. I even have the content available. Right now roads are rated on:

1) How much variation they have (i.e. twistyness)

2) Do they go past a body of water

3) Do they go through a state park

All of this data is available to show to the user, I just haven't added any UI elements to display them. It'll be particularly nice once I add more scoring criteria for roads (like elevation changes, view sheds (i.e. seeing a mountain range out in the distance), land coverage surrounding road, historical landmarks, drive past old awesome buildings, etc).

I don't know of any data source for pavement quality, outside of roads being marked as paved or unpaved :(

Re: Ask HN: Review my MVP - Scenic Motorcycle Routes from Three Rides

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some more specific feedback to the actual site, not the concept. The routes need more content - maps are important, but without ideas of what I am going to encounter, descriptions, titles, categories, it's not too helpful. Categories are important as well, because there are so many different styles of riding. Out on my dualsport, I don't care if I hit bad pavement (I might actually WANT bad or no pavement). On my R6,…

I agree about the content. I even have the content available. Right now roads are rated on: 1) How much variation they have (i.e. twistyness) 2) Do they go past a body of water 3) Do they go through a state park All of this data is available to show to the user, I just haven't added any UI elements to display them. It'll be particularly nice once I add more scoring criteria for roads (like elevation changes, view she…

We ask users for pavement quality when they create a route on ridewithgps, and allow people to search using it. ArcGIS allows searching for gravel/pavement, but nothing as fine grained as being properly banked, chipseal vs blacktop vs potholed etc etc

Re: Ask HN: Review my MVP - Scenic Motorcycle Routes from Three Rides

#28
I agree with the comments about more content. Overall the idea is great and I'd use the site often. Currently the way the route is provided it feels like a "push" to take the route, there's nothing "pulling me down the road". It would be fantastic if the route results would offer categories of information such as: - Bike friendly stops - Sites to see - Grub (ie - unusual places to eat) - Things to find (a little geocaching anyone?) - Join (or start) a group ride for this route

and so on.

Looking forward to using this tool frequently!

Thanks!

Re: Ask HN: Review my MVP - Scenic Motorcycle Routes from Three Rides

#30
post #28

I agree with the comments about more content. Overall the idea is great and I'd use the site often. Currently the way the route is provided it feels like a "push" to take the route, there's nothing "pulling me down the road". It would be fantastic if the route results would offer categories of information such as: - Bike friendly stops - Sites to see - Grub (ie - unusual places to eat) - Things to find (a little geoc…

I agree too. That's a really good point too about needing things to "pull you down the road". Really great ideas and feedback, thanks!
Post reply on HN