I have a reputation for being a bit harsh about design critiques, so before I say anything: * Great work on taking the time to build something cool. * Awesome work at keeping the functionality simple, intuitive and easy to use. Most people fail at pulling that off. * Much props for asking for feedback. ...as for the design... * Some boxes have sharp corners, some have round. Pick just one for a uniform look. You can…
Ask HN: Please review my webapp.
21–24 of 24 posts
Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp.
#22This looks interesting. Awesome name. First things first: when you get so much "feedback" on design and almost nothing on the actual function of the app, your alarm bells should start ringing. You are either asking the wrong people for feedback (highly likely considering most people here don't know cricket) or you are not really offering anything interesting. Get rid of the name fields on the registration form. Add T…
Thanks for the feedback. You don't have to register to join the contest. The idea was to show a preview of the contest before joining, hence those extra clicks. On your "Start a Contest" page, why don't you add Flags of countries which one can drag and drop to make a match. I think you meant "Start a Private Contest". This feature will help you create only instance of the current contest for your private network. You…
Sorry I misunderstood the contest thing.
Maybe you should add a slideshow or video demo to the site.
Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp.
#23Earlier quoted context omitted.
Thanks for the feedback. You don't have to register to join the contest. The idea was to show a preview of the contest before joining, hence those extra clicks. On your "Start a Contest" page, why don't you add Flags of countries which one can drag and drop to make a match. I think you meant "Start a Private Contest". This feature will help you create only instance of the current contest for your private network. You…
I didn't mind registering. In fact, I wanted to check out your registration process. Sorry I misunderstood the contest thing. Maybe you should add a slideshow or video demo to the site.
Re: Ask HN: Please review my webapp.
#24Could use a designers touch. Lots of little things, mostly. Does anyone else see Facebook api stuff as a blight on pages? As soon as I see that stale light blue...
Thanks. Agreed on the design that it needs improvement. Could you please elaborate little more. Might be able to fix few. Will replace the Facebook box with a button.