Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 42 posts

Re: Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

#21
post #8

I'm in my mid-40's, and have yet to have any desire for children. My reasoning essentially has been that if I have children, they will either be like me, or not be like me. Neither of these outcomes encourages me. If they are not like me --- well, I don't think there is any shortage of people in the world that are not like me. Further, I think that lowering the human population is the best thing we can do to prevent…

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe if you read the other thread you'll have a more informed opinion on the issue.

You mean the one where the first line of the top comment says "Notice that most of the comments here are describing post-hoc how having children has been fulfilling/great/worth it. Which isn't really the question - it's not asking if having children was a good move in retrospect."? Yeah. I read that thread. Did you?

I'm really getting mixed signals regarding your opinions on reading past the first line of a text.

Re: Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

#23

You should be asking the opposite question. Why does anyone choose to have children? The answer as far as I can tell for most people is that they didn't actually choose after careful consideration of merits. They either just kinda felt like they wanted kids or were told that they needed to have kids or kids just kinda happened, or some combination of the three. But so much of the terrible part of having kids is hidde…

The look you're seeing is fatigue, not misery. There's a class of things that make you tired but happy, and small children are one of them.

When I need to smile because I'm having my picture taken, I just think of my kids.

Re: Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

#24

You should be asking the opposite question. Why does anyone choose to have children? The answer as far as I can tell for most people is that they didn't actually choose after careful consideration of merits. They either just kinda felt like they wanted kids or were told that they needed to have kids or kids just kinda happened, or some combination of the three. But so much of the terrible part of having kids is hidde…

> You should be asking the opposite question. Why does anyone choose to have children?

I would think that the opposite question does not need much explanation because we have some DNA programming to spread our genes and to "make offsprings". Assuming a healthy person and all the social/cultural/economical/philosophical influences aside if one decided not to have children, they must fight their own hormones in the first place. And to do that successfully they must have a strong reason and be able to stick to it because that signal is pretty strong. That's why the question "why not" is more interesting for me.

Re: Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

#25
post #24

You should be asking the opposite question. Why does anyone choose to have children? The answer as far as I can tell for most people is that they didn't actually choose after careful consideration of merits. They either just kinda felt like they wanted kids or were told that they needed to have kids or kids just kinda happened, or some combination of the three. But so much of the terrible part of having kids is hidde…

> You should be asking the opposite question. Why does anyone choose to have children? I would think that the opposite question does not need much explanation because we have some DNA programming to spread our genes and to "make offsprings". Assuming a healthy person and all the social/cultural/economical/philosophical influences aside if one decided not to have children, they must fight their own hormones in the fir…

Everything you've said is right, but giving in to biological imperative isn't really the same as choosing, is it?

Re: Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

#26
post #7

I'm 30 and I have no regrets yet but the pressure is quite annoying...I guess that some people just want kinds, some don't and some want when it's too late. I hope I won't change my mind...

Pressure from family? Friends? Is this more keenly felt by women v men do you think?

First is the pressure from my partner(she is very much into having children), then the family and then there is the fact that most of my friends have kinds or at least are looking to have kids. When I meet old friends I find that most of them married and have kids too...you are told now it's the time to have kinds and later you will regret it. You won't be able to have kinds anymore(due biological issues) or you will be more like an grandpa than a father to them. I can understand their arguments but I have no desire to have children(yet).

Re: Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

#27
I'm in my mid thirties. My partner and I have been together for 16 years. At no point in that time have either of us felt strongly that we wanted children. However, there are very good health reasons for us not to have biological children. So rather than risk future-us deciding we wanted biological children despite the issues, we made the choice permanent. Should that change we can always adopt. It's not like there's a shortage of children in the world.

Re: Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You’re lucky your parents didn’t share your thoughts. As a father of a two year old boy, what you’re saying is bullshit. It may satisfy your need to rationalize your decision to not have children, but it’s still bullshit.

[flagged]

Bullshitters make me angry.

Re: Ask HN: Why did you choose not to have children?

#29
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You’re lucky your parents didn’t share your thoughts. As a father of a two year old boy, what you’re saying is bullshit. It may satisfy your need to rationalize your decision to not have children, but it’s still bullshit.

Nothing except denial in your words. Sounds like you confirm what the parent said then... We are here at HN to argue, not to deny.

Yes, denial. Having a child is unbelievable, it’s the most amazing thing I could have experienced in my life.

The parent weights that against... having time for duolingo. Go figure.

Post reply on HN