Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What are some common traps that smart people fall into?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 44 posts

Re: Ask HN: What are some common traps that smart people fall into?

#21

This is less software-related, but one trap smart folks can fall into is being afraid to seem not smart. Like let's say an authority figure is trying to do something that doesn't feel right to you, and you say something about it. And then Mr. Authority Figure says, "Come now, be reasonable or be rational ." The fear of being perceived as "irrational" may stop you from standing up for yourself or someone else.

On a similar note, "fear of not looking smart" can make it hard to ask a question. Often when I'm in a meeting and they're going deep into some technical thing I don't understand, I (nowadays) assume that everybody else is confused, too, and I ask the question. And then once I do, everyone else relaxes and follows up. But until that ice is broken, we're all sweating bullets trying to look like we get something we literally do not understand at all.

Re: Ask HN: What are some common traps that smart people fall into?

#23
Conflating negativity/criticism/pessimism with intelligence.

Making a declaration about viability of software based on its present state (youtube will never work they'll get sued), (bitcoin will never work because it can't scale), instead of predicting the viability of a future iteration of it.

Nitpicking someone's communication/word choice/edge case instead of focusing out what they were trying to convey

Re: Ask HN: What are some common traps that smart people fall into?

#25

Not using systems when starting out.

Not using what kind of systems, when starting out doing what? I'm afraid I have no idea what you mean.

Systems thinking versus goal thinking, I'm guessing.

Re: Ask HN: What are some common traps that smart people fall into?

#27
post #18

Smart people can be impatient and can be short on virtues other people have, like persistence. They often expect things to come easily and will give up quickly if they don't. They can be prone to thinking that if someone disagrees with them, the person is just stupid or doesn't know enough. It can be very challenging to get smart people from very different domains to collaborate effectively because both sides may thr…

"...that if someone disagrees with them, the person is just stupid or doesn't know enough."

Believing that smart = right, thus, less smart = less right.

Re: Ask HN: What are some common traps that smart people fall into?

#28
Procrastinating on an assigned task because you think you can do things faster than everyone else. It's a trap that I fell into often. Nearing the shipping date, I found myself scrambling to finish the task wishing I had started earlier. The learning: Even if you're faster at doing things, underestimating unknown unknowns is going to be detrimental in the end. It's better to start sooner. There's a good article that covers this hazard[1]

[1]: http://bookofhook.blogspot.in/2013/03/smart-guy-productivity...

Re: Ask HN: What are some common traps that smart people fall into?

#29
post #18

Smart people can be impatient and can be short on virtues other people have, like persistence. They often expect things to come easily and will give up quickly if they don't. They can be prone to thinking that if someone disagrees with them, the person is just stupid or doesn't know enough. It can be very challenging to get smart people from very different domains to collaborate effectively because both sides may thr…

"...that if someone disagrees with them, the person is just stupid or doesn't know enough." Believing that smart = right, thus, less smart = less right.

No. They believe they have an informed opinion, so anyone who sees it differently must have an uninformed opinion rooted in prejudice, partial information etc.

This is partly a product of the culture and it is part of why I turned down my scholarship and spent two decades as a homemaker. I was one of the top students at my high school and it was an incredibly poisonous experience.

Raising kids was a wonderful antidote to this shit. It helped me develop mental models concerning the superior density and value of local information, even in cases where a person has substantially less formal education.

In other words, my inarticulate 2 year old knew more about his situation than I did, never mind his lack of education and challenges in communicating it. Disrespecting his knowledge was guaranteed to go bad places. The challenge was in serving as an effective resource for him instead of simply trying to lord it over him.

Post reply on HN