Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do you lose weight?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 54 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do you lose weight?

#21

Record every calorie you eat. Set a goal ~500-700 calories under your base metabolic rate. Once you record everything it becomes clear where the extra calories are coming from and where to improve your diet. Diligence in log keeping is key.

Prefer counting as well. At the end of the day weight loss is bound by thermodynamics. All diets are just hacks to help subconsciously tip the balance. May as well cut directly to the root and just count.

Health is a different story and more subject to what is actually consumed.

Re: Ask HN: How do you lose weight?

#22
Lots of good advice here regarding diet and meal tracking with MyFitnessPal.

One thing I'd like to add which doesn't get nearly enough attention is _periodization_. If you go on an extended caloric deficit your body will adapt and lower your metabolic rate which result is a small deficit for a given intake and commensurately lower energy levels and activity.

So, my advice is to go on a caloric deficit for _at most_ 3 months then do 3 months of maintenance where you're in caloric balance, then go back to a deficit.

Also, weigh yourself every day, ideally at the same time (for me, its right after I go to the bathroom when I wake up). There's a lot of interday and intraday variance (i've have 7# swings in a single day) so any single measurement isn't important but the moving average is critical.

Furthermore, if you are in a deconditioned state (not having exercised in a while) and you pick up weight training or crossfit, you will likely gain weight in the beginning. Thats OK! Gaining muscle will significant improve everything you want to improve (looks, energy, mood, etc) but not be reflected on the scale.

Re: Ask HN: How do you lose weight?

#24
post #20

Step on a scale daily at the same time in your routine, preferably one that tracks your weight. I have a year of daily data now, which I think is helpful for me to see progress.

I prefer once a week. Once a day is... somewhat noisy. (Of course, if you do so once a week, you still have noise in the datapoints, it's just less obvious.)

Re: Ask HN: How do you lose weight?

#25
If you drink soda or other sugary drinks, stop that first (or switch to diet).

Then, the only thing that has really worked for me: pick either lunch or dinner, and take 1/2 of the meal (before you start eating), and box it up for tomorrow. Don't get seconds.

I was eating out for lunch a lot, and when I started eating just 1/2 of the meal, I started to lose weight (surprise surprise).

It's not fun or easy to stop eating at 1/2 a meal, but it's a simple rule to remember. After you're used to eating less, you can start worrying about eating healthy foods, etc., but to start with that was too overwhelming. The simpler the rules you set for yourself - the easier it will be to stick to it.

Re: Ask HN: How do you lose weight?

#26
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Keto is interesting though it seems like it could be hard with social activities. Have you had any difficulty? Best of luck!

I don't do keto but I do a similarly "limits social activities" sort of dieting. I just don't follow a diet "strictly at all times". If you're (truly) following your diet 95% of the time and go out every-other Friday (or hell, even if it is every Friday) for a social dinner, 1 meal of 21 or 42 meals isn't going to completely ruin your dieting any more than forgetting to brush and floss after lunch on Thursdays is goi…

Keto relies on being in ketogenesis, which is affected by intake.

You can certainly have a "cheat" meal of higher-than-normal carb intake, but you might get knocked out of keto for a few days. If you cheat every week, you could be screwing yourself out of progress.

Re: Ask HN: How do you lose weight?

#27
Eat more plants, especially green ones. Drink a ton of water. Don't eat anything that comes in a box.

Some less conventional tips:

* no calories from liquid! Water and tea (or black coffee) only. No milk, juice, alcoholic beverages, etc.

* skip breakfast. This is a form of intermittent fasting called time-restricted eating. Hard to implement at first (you will be hungry during the morning), but gets easier over time.

* learn about ketosis and how eat a modified Atkins diet that is mostly plants, meat, and healthy fats.

Food list for plant-based diet here: https://github.com/DeBraid/medicine/blob/master/plant-based-...

Re: Ask HN: How do you lose weight?

#28
Each day:

* Get 80% of your calories from fat.

* Eat less than 25 grams of net carbs (total carbs - fiber content).

Last 4 years experimenting with sustainable weight loss diets, this (ketosis) has been the most effortless and enjoyable method I've found. I feel satieted, I don't have after-meal drowsiness and most importantly, after a few months it's become part my lifestyle, so maintaining it is a breeze.

Happy side effect: I prefer home-cooked food to eating out because restaurant food isn't usually fat heavy.

One resource: http://eatingacademy.com

Re: Ask HN: How do you lose weight?

#30
Eat the same thing every day and just stick to it. No deviations. You should construct a healthy meal that contains everything you need and adjust the amount so you're on a calorie deficit.

Not for everyone but has worked wonders for me. Really easy as well.

Post reply on HN