Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What do you expect or hate to see in a job offer decription?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 67 posts

Re: Ask HN: What do you expect or hate to see in a job offer decription?

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If you are trying to hide the company name, I dislike this but understand you are likely a recruiter working on commission. Why is it bad?

Because you don't know what company you're applying for?

Yeah. I once had a recruiter tell me to show up at a company that made sewing machines. Mechanical sewing machines. I don't think there was a single computer on the premises. The recruiter and I had a good laugh, then I fired him.

Re: Ask HN: What do you expect or hate to see in a job offer decription?

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If you are trying to hide the company name, I dislike this but understand you are likely a recruiter working on commission. Why is it bad?

Because you don't know what company you're applying for?

I'd settle for information about the industry the company is in, sometimes I see job adverts that lack even this basic information (I'm picky about the industries I work in, so perhaps this isn't a big deal for others).

Re: Ask HN: What do you expect or hate to see in a job offer decription?

#25
Pros: What the actual job is, the industry sector and the pay

Cons: Guru, Ninja, Rock Star and Passion. I am 55 with a shit pension and your 'Uber for salads' is not something I am passionate about. Never will be.

Complete put off: Other than the cons is reading the ad and not knowing what the job or company is about. If you can't spell it out your are either incompetent or deceitful.

Re: Ask HN: What do you expect or hate to see in a job offer decription?

#26

"Remote" positions where you can work from home every other Friday. If a position is under a butts-in-seats management style, the word "remote" should not be found anywhere in the description. Some remote positions have geographical limitations, which can be understandable from a tax perspective, but I also don't like to see "remote" positions open only to people in a specific timezone.

>"I also don't like to see "remote" positions open only to people in a specific timezone"

Isn't this also to do with working hours? If you want synchronous communication with remote employees you'd probably want them to work similar hours to local employees (unless you were a multinational company).

Re: Ask HN: What do you expect or hate to see in a job offer decription?

#28
Pro: a description of not only what work you expect me to do, but also who I'll be doing it with. Team size, experience level of other team members, my role in the team.

Con: Anything about fun company events and free drinks. I'm looking for work, not booking a cruise.

Re: Ask HN: What do you expect or hate to see in a job offer decription?

#29
post #2

Sometimes in Dutch vacancies for freelance roles, I see the following remark with regards to hourly rate: "scherp aanbieden" (=> "offer sharply"?) I see this reasonably often in mailings of recruitment agencies. I hate this and I wouldn't be very tempted to apply.

Don't forget "we will offer you a laptop and phone" as if those are privileges in IT.

Annoys the hell out of me.

Re: Ask HN: What do you expect or hate to see in a job offer decription?

#30
Con: a Bachelor, Masters or PhD in {a specific field}.

Consider rephrasing to "PhD with publication record, or MSc with 3 years of work experience, or BSc with 7 years of work experience, 3 of which at {a specific advanced level}".

I understand if the job requires a certain minimum education background, but how can you possibly consider holders of all three of the above degrees, without stating the specifications for each degree? Can I still apply if I'm just about to get a BSc, or would you require some amount of work experience? Am I competing directly with PhDs? Confuses the hell out of me. I once applied for a SWE I position that had that kind of degree requirement during my senior year. Passed two phone screens, even handled questions about computer vision and deep learning well during the on site round (answered beginner and intermediate level questions well, was honest to admit my limits when asked about advanced topics). Two days after the interview I went back to check the job posting, and it was somehow changed to say Principle Computer Vision Scientist then I was like "oh there goes my chance". Needless to say I wasn't selected. It makes sense for them to select candidates with advanced degrees if they are really looking for a Prin. Scientist. But please, spell out the requirements so that candidates make informed decisions about whether to apply. It saves both parties valuable time.

Post reply on HN