Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

news.ycombinator.com

191–200 of 239 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#191
It depends on what you define as a startup. In my opinion it is, but as I’d read in another place: I think features will turn into products. So build a feature and do it the best for a segment and it should give you at least a small business.

And sure, maybe someone will try to copy what you build, but that’s a good problem to have because by then you’re probably somewhat successful.

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#192

Big companies are not your worry in most cases. They have so much bureaucracy and internal politics that it's often cheaper for them to buy out the up-and-coming startups than it is to build in-house. Instead, if you achieve success without much of a moat, you will be cloned by one of the "App Store mills". These are companies who employ multiple small teams (think 3-4 people), and each team is charged with cloning o…

Rocket Internet Is one of these copycat business style.

I worked for them: Its quuuiiiittteee different what they do from this "app-cloning-approach": Rocket Internet copies business models and adapts them other countries. They are bringing in own people if they invest if required for the startup, but usually the companies are mainly built be the original founders with support from Rocket Internet on different layers (like legal). Also Rocket invests Money. Sometimes .. a lot!

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#193
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don’t worry big companies still can’t copy anything quickly, even with AI. Why? Because before they can ship a single feature, they’ll need to schedule 42 alignment meetings, debate AI-generated slide decks, and log their “strategic pivots” into an AI-curated Jira board. The real moat isn’t just code it’s speed, focus, user trust, and the ability to actually ship. Those are things bloated orgs struggle with, with or…

The real moat is not being forced to use Jira then.

a) THe only problem with Jira is that its soooo slow :-)

b) give Linear.App a chance - its great

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#194
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Teams is still nowhere near Slack's features and usefulness. I wouldn't say it's a direct competitor, it's like store brand vs a mid-luxury item

Nobody really likes Teams, but it does seem to have more features than Slack in terms of integration with the rest of Microsoft's office software ecosystem. It's nice to be able to open up and edit Word/PowerPoint/Excel documents directly, view the Outlook calendar directly, etc. It is also integrated with SharePoint and OneDrive for file storage. Teams had video calls before Slack as well IIRC. Teams, Slack and Disc…

the thing is: TEAMS just works, even for all office drones who cant use a computer without accidents

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#195
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The real moat is not being forced to use Jira then.

a) THe only problem with Jira is that its soooo slow :-) b) give Linear.App a chance - its great

Or you can just vibe code Rectilinear app.

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#196

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You’re talking about VC startups. I disagree with the sour mindset, as I don’t feel those games were necessary for my startup, although I admit mine was bootstrapped (0$), and didn’t grow as far as the others, it still made me millionaire, has paid my employees a high-than-average salary and has the potential of adding them a few hundred thousands each. I admit the old market (do web apps to manage records! or notes!…

How do you find users? Organic? SEO is useless as all the projects with any meaningful pagerank are all pointing to each other. Social media advertising is useless; nobody even sees your tweets or posts. Advertising? How do you get a return on CPC? All the big competitors seem to be running negative margins. Also, small volume social media ads tends to attract only bots... Are you operating in a niche? How do you get…

It all crashed when Sundar Pichai took over:

In hist first speech/announcement he said: "...everything is AI now..." - from this day on, Google was dead for customer acquisition.

From now on, every search query with same terms served always an individual page at different times. The good old SEO days were dead, this user-acqui channel died.

Then they increased & enlarged the space for ads at top of page; and these days finally they introduced this AI panel - most people wont scroll anymore on Google.

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#197

This is the problem with big concentration of wealth and power. The big tech mega corps can copy your idea easily because they don’t have any budget, they can undercut you or sell at a loss, and they can distribute it to all their current customers with anti competitive bundling. It has happened over and over many times and American antitrust law is useless. The largest corporations must be broken up, taxed heavily,…

SAP comes to my mind here :-)

If they have at least one tiny step/foot in the door, they are good at upselling nearly everything. And they are continuously buying up other companies and integrating them (somehow questionable very often) and then selling this as new SAP product after replacing the former logo

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#198
post #156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't care what they told you last year, I didn't say jack shit. I'm saying it now. Cope or pretend it's not happening, I don't care, this is the year.

I just keep hearing all these people that preach this, but I don't see anything substantial (that isn't something stupid or a tutorial they followed from medium) that anyone responds with. e.g. of a meh: give me top 10 HN articles for today and summarize the contents, add tags and build a website. I know AI can do that, but it's not impressive. Not to pick on you, be mean or anything, but your github profile says no…

This.

AI is already more or less ultimately powerful with nearly endless ressources - though, no one built a big software company in the last 3 - 4 years solely with AI to replace one of the behemoths.

The fact that you own a car which could bring you everywhere does not mean that you actually will go eveywhere.

On a conference 2 month ago, one speaker claimed that AI will be so powerful that within 3 years there will be guys who replace microsoft because they have a better coding AI than today.

I do not see this happen

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't care what they told you last year, I didn't say jack shit. I'm saying it now. Cope or pretend it's not happening, I don't care, this is the year.

Have you actually had it do anything substantial and then tried to work with the code it produces afterwards? It may "work" but it's a horrific mess. Good luck bug fixing that.

Yes.

Im working productive with it every day (Claude Opus). If you provide enough context, the code usually works veeeery well on first shot.

(For sure, I do not tell it "build me a facebook", instead Im telling it precisely which single function I want to have, how it should work, what the output should be.

Its just a boon.

Re: Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

#200

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, Opus 4.5 is not business as normal. If you haven't tried it, you really need to, to update your opinion.

I am talking about opus 4.5. It made a complete mess out of my project.

Do not throw your project in there as a whole.

Chunk it into single parts/components/building blocks. Then do each of these a dedicated project/workspace. In each of these workspaces, you put in only the source code relevant for this module. You are working in each project/workspace separately.

Try this

Post reply on HN