Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What movies changed your perception of reality or life?

news.ycombinator.com

191–200 of 237 posts

Re: Ask HN: What movies changed your perception of reality or life?

#191
post #46
post #3

Fight Club and The Matrix, but I only understood the latter several years later.

The whole matrix being a trans metaphor didn't even register for me until I heard about it in an interview on YouTube.

It's like people thinking the X-Men is about being gay, but given Bryan Singer's proclivities it's more likely to be about being a MAP.

Re: Ask HN: What movies changed your perception of reality or life?

#192

The Man From Earth Can't describe this without giving it away.

I constantly think about this film. The amount of moments that must have been lost to time. Vague memories that must me merged into innate feelings and instinct that shape John into the person that he is.

Does he actually learn from his experiences, and chooses to be the man that he is? Or did his experiences literally whittle him down to the person that he has become.

In essence: Is he the embodiment of a mankind that witnesses the consequences of its actions, or is he the very antithesis of it (telling in the way that he distinguishes himself from others, whilst being extremely humane in every interaction).

On a lighter note: I also wonder if he can juggle and do a backflip, or if he could and these skills were lost to time.

In the same way that many of us are defined by a childhood that we barely remember, I wonder if his generosity and kindness is born from a blur of unconscious experiences he barely remembers.

Re: Ask HN: What movies changed your perception of reality or life?

#195

Recently, Midsommer. I think if you go into it with an open mind (and not get too weirded out by the gore) it asks some really fascinating anthropological and social questions. By the end of the movie, I was almost entirely on the side of the culture and their behavior made complete sense to me. During the course of the movie I experienced a shift of position and perspective and continues to affect me 4 years later.…

fwiw, Midsommer also has the best approximation of psylocibin visual come-up in video format that I’ve found

Haven't seen it since the first time I watched it, but I remember thinking the same thing - this is what it feels like to come up on mushrooms. Most movies just settle for some visual distortions, accurate or otherwise. The whole headspace and visual effect they created in this scene was eerily accurate.

Re: Ask HN: What movies changed your perception of reality or life?

#196

District 9 How would we treat aliens if they arrived?

Turning that around, how would aliens treat Jesus? https://www.smbc-comics.com/comics/20081124.gif

Oh but what if Jesus WAS an alien ? slash astronaut slash cosmonaut slash taikonaut

Re: Ask HN: What movies changed your perception of reality or life?

#197
Lately it’s been The Lobster.

I’ve always been one to recognize a lot of absurdities in life, but this movie got me asking: “What if the absurd false dichotomies are the feature that influential people use over their supporters to test their power and loyalty?”

I’ve also been asking myself, what other absurdities do I still not see and how can I systematically detect those absurdities?

Re: Ask HN: What movies changed your perception of reality or life?

#199
Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure

Helped me not take life so seriously. And that being super smart isn't the end-all-be-all. You can have a totally excellent time just being kind to others. In fact, kindness is probably the most important thing to be.

Re: Ask HN: What movies changed your perception of reality or life?

#200
post #161

Groundhog Day. It's such a subtle movie, that it works on multiple levels at the same time. I got to level 2 on the first viewing, but only years later assimilated level 3. At level 1 it's a simple Romcom movie - boy stuck in a time loop needs to earn girl's love. Level 2 is that we are all stuck in a time loop. Everyone is functionally living the same day over and over. Same job, same relationships, same everything.…

Virtually all films follow that pattern. Read any textbook about screenwriting, and they'll tell you that 1 any movie has an overarching theme (here is routine life), and 2 all characters need to follow some kind of evolution arc (Phil goes from being the worst cynist to actually becoming a good guy). It's quite hardwired in how hollywood makes movies.

True. The genius here is in how it hides the complexity under the Hollywood shallowness.

It's easy to dismiss it, as a simple story. Discovering the underlying insights takes thought.

Incidentally it also pioneered the "time loop" genre. As far as I know, certainly for mainstream-me, it was the first to use this plot device.

Post reply on HN