Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

news.ycombinator.com

181–190 of 325 posts

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Extra knowledge can't possibly be a weakness.

If you frame it as just "extra knowledge" then, sure, it's not a weakness. The problem is when extra knowledge is acquired at the expense of deeper focus (knowledge) in another area.

>> The problem is when extra knowledge is acquired at the expense of deeper focus (knowledge) in another area.

How it this a problem? It is just another way.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#182

Don't quit your day job - ya gotta pay the rent. And in the meantime, if you gain satisfaction from satisfying your curiosity about myriad things, go with that. It doesn't have to have an end or a greater purpose. Everybody you know has a head filled with things they'll never "usefully apply" to the greater world around them: it's a fact of life. So if you end up on your deathbed with nothing having really clicked fo…

Seconded. As you grow older you may find that you actually did lift some of the subjects to a "marketable level". For example, I'm now 40, studied molecular biology but my dedication to my home server, HN and tech podcasts is now paying dividends because I can talk with the big boys about infra-as-code, higher level system architecture and software development. This is really nice as the healthcare company I work for…

So you're working in bio but yearning for IT? I'm almost the opposite. IT pays the bills, but I wish I was in evolutionary biology.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#183
post #38
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I might have to check this out. Im skeptical of it being a strength in today's world. So far, it seems to only be a weakness for me.

I fall into this group. I've so far found it to be a strength (mostly). R&D/prototype style work benefits highly from having generalists around. Most normal people just don't have a lot of breadth in terms of knowing what else is out there or what's been done outside of a narrowly defined field. 95% of the time you'll be greeted with a "huh...interesting" and no follow up, but in my experience that remaining 5% can b…

"R&D/prototype style work"

That sounds great, but it also sounds rare and potentially low paid.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#184
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I might have to check this out. Im skeptical of it being a strength in today's world. So far, it seems to only be a weakness for me.

I think it works best if you have a core field. The cross discipline knowledge would prevent group think and result in more original ideas.

Yeah, and in my experience management only wants people who think the same way they do.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#185
Do this enough and you get a superpower (or at least a neat party trick): you can translate ideas across field boundaries and find really interesting links between subjects. Even just observing that some idea X has been discovered by fields A and B is, I think, really valuable, because so few people cross subject boundaries, and there are often wide terminology gaps that prevent ideas from cross pollinating.

> I like writing and can imagine having some sort of blog, but that's seems so cliche?

Writing on blogs might be commonplace. Good writing is not. Spend a little time thinking about writing well and you'll be ahead of the crowd.

That said, I don't think you should worry too much about how other people will see your writing. I treat my blog as a sort of public notebook. The articles are primarily for me; they are what I'd want to have read if I hadn't done the research myself, and/or a year later when I've forgotten everything. That takes off the pressure to be perfectly original or polished.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#186
Embracing the fact that you are a lifelong learner (LLL), perhaps just the silly fact that it has a name and a cool acronym, might go some way toward helping you feel less anxious about it. I am a LLL myself, and this seems like an excellent way of living one's life.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#187
post #3

Read a couple of books by Barbara sher: Refuse to choose [0] She calls people like us "Scanners" and claims that our diversity of interests is not a weakness, but a strength. Then goes on techniques to make this skill work for us. [0] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1594863032/

I hope OP (and other "scanners") sees this - it might be worth knowing that you may have ADHD, especially if you also heavily procrastinate, are messy/disorganized and always run late. There is much more than I can type in a single comment but if someone wants more info I can try and help.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#188

I'm very similar and would just give you two pieces of advice: (1) buy books compulsively and don't do your research predominantly online, and (2) make sure you write often, whether or not you publish your work or keep it to yourself. I think the latter is the most important advice for those trying to pursue an intellectual path outside of academia -- if you don't develop a habit of writing, you aren't really synthes…

Agree with all said here, but a small caveat with PhDs in the UK – from my understanding, admissions can be very difficult for those not living in the UK (purposefully biased towards UK citizens). However, getting into a one year Master's program in the UK or Netherlands seems pretty feasible, and might get you a taste of what getting a PhD is like without too much commitment.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#190
post #164

Investing might be an area where you can profit from being the way you are. I am very similar, having read way over 1k books in the last ten years or so, on a perversely wide array of subjects. I’ve also done everything from tinkering with Arduinos all the way to marriage counseling. But I quickly get bored and move on to the next field. An early disciple of CG Jung, Marie Louise von Franz, wrote that the life of our…

>what you do reap is a very interconnected, multidisciplinary way of understanding the world, which comes to you not so much in the form of explicit knowledge but in the form of a very special “intuition”.

What is the value of that, though? When it comes to social sciences, everyone believes they have a special intuition or a sense about how the world works. It's impossible to distinguish who actually does, and who is self-delusional. You cannot even be certain for yourself.

In tech, in contrast, you can build a product that can prove you are valuable, despite being an un-credentialed autodidact.

I can think of only a few paths that can really realize the value of genuine brilliance of this type:

1) With your special intuition of how the world works, predict the course of society and make money off of that. That can be difficult, though, since nobody is going to bankroll you, and this would also require knowledge of finance.

1.1) Gamble on the nascent event markets instead. Not sure if they are going to exist in the long term, though.

2) Write compelling fiction. However, if your conclusions about society are true, but unintuitive to the general public, it's going to be tricky to convince them you're right, and they're wrong.

3) Become political analyst/pundit/substack writer. Same downsides as above.

4) Identify key trends in society and start a business in a field that is likely to dramatically explode. This strategy requires tech or business skills, and is high variability.

Post reply on HN