Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?

news.ycombinator.com

151–160 of 1001 posts

Re: Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?

#151
jedi academy 4

I cut my teeth writing mods in quake-c for jedi outcast (jk2) and jedi academy (jk3). I was never hugely into starwars but playing what is essentially quake 2/3 with force powers on the quake engine was always an excellent game. I wish raven and lucasfilm had continued with the series.

Re: Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?

#152
Most of mine are modernizations/remakes/stealing-the-mechanics of older games with unusual genre mashups or mechanics, that no longer exist. Examples:

- Hunter Hunted (asymmetric multiplayer platformer-shooter with vs. and co-op modes)

- Perfect Dark (FPS with lots of multiplayer modes, including co-op campaign, campaign versus mode[!], and of course endlessly configurable plain ol' arena versus, including highly-configurable bots—the closest I've seen something come to this is Call of Duty: Black Ops 2, of all games, but it still wasn't that close. Most elements/modes exist somewhere, but rarely in one package. The way difficulty levels didn't just make the enemies bullet sponges and better shots [though it did also do that] but also changed objectives and sometimes starting location, was also excellent and isn't as common as I wish it were)

- Return Fire (vehicle-based CTF multiplayer, with elaborate pre-built defensive base structures for both sides—this game's not quite all there, but make it more than 2 player and add a little base-building and it'd be amazing)

- Battletanx (Actually a little similar to Return Fire, now that I think about it, but with a lot more of a traditional multiplayer-shooter feel, different camera perspective, and the vehicles are all kinds of tanks. AFAIK nothing like this or Return Fire has been released since the N64/Playstation era)

- Dominus (The single genre it's closest to is probably tower defense, but it's got a whole lot more going on than most of those)

Also, edutainment disappoints me these days. Drill-type games (as in, drilling math problems) seem to have gotten much better, but sheer knowledge games (Explorers of the New World, Microsoft's Dinosaurs) seem to have all but disappeared, aside from adult-targeted trivia games, which don't have a learning focus and aren't very good at teaching you things. The Trail series (yeah, it's still around, by why aren't there similarly-clever and well-made games for 1,000 other historical situations, too?). I actually think this category would get a lot better, fast, if we had decent, accessible multi-media authoring tools for the web. The closest thing we had was Flash, and it's gone.

Re: Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?

#153
post #21

A true "MMORPG". Back in the day when the genre was new, people were fascinated by the potential of virtual worlds and virtual societies. Social scientists did online studies on player behavior and the interactions people had online, on spontaneous self-governance coming into existence, on how communities formed and developed, and many other similar topics. That potential was never fulfilled. Today - some twenty year…

Look for the Ryzom Core Discord or IRC chat. There's a couple of us in the open source community hoping to build such a thing, based on an existing MMO codebase and assets.

The key point is that all missions should be impactful on the world, and not merely reward oriented.

We have the tech for an MMORPG. We've been working on simplifying the onboarding curve for new contributors first. In a few months we can start exploring game mission mechanics. :)

Re: Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?

#154
post #21

A true "MMORPG". Back in the day when the genre was new, people were fascinated by the potential of virtual worlds and virtual societies. Social scientists did online studies on player behavior and the interactions people had online, on spontaneous self-governance coming into existence, on how communities formed and developed, and many other similar topics. That potential was never fulfilled. Today - some twenty year…

It's never gonna be a AAA game. The broader market just doesn't want this, and you'll need the broader market if its a AAA game.

New World hit on some of these points at one point, but they backed down pretty fast.

Ashes of Creation may or may not hit some of these points. But that game is... overly ambitious, to say the least. They're trying to go full tilt on everything and I'm skeptical as to whether it's gonna work out well in the end.

Re: Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?

#159

I want a sort of civilization-but-for-countries. E.g. you are the newly elected president of Afghanistan/North Korea/Iraq/Other etc - now go rebuild infrastructure etc, set policies, see how the country develops as a result. E.g. do you invest in universal healthcare, or transport infrastructure? Is transport infra required while your country is still largely subsistence farming?. What about education - save money th…

I'm really enjoying Workers and Resources: Soviet Republic

It lets you control a small country and build basically everything from scratch, factories, railways, housing.

Honestly it hits most of the points you describe above.

Re: Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?

#160
FPS where you are an animal or an insect in an urban environment. Like a game where you are a cat surviving on a neighborhood, looking for food, avoiding dangers, even fighting with other cats. Or a game where you are a spider in a garden, catching other insects, hiding from predators. Or a game where you are a bird, flying in the city, making a nest in the trees, looking for food.
Post reply on HN