Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How is your mental health?

news.ycombinator.com

151–160 of 162 posts

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#151

It’s a continuous effort in paying attention to my mood, physical exercise, good sleep, journaling, meditation, a healthy diet, and quality time with friends. And even with all of that sometimes things break down. I’ve written a post about my habits here, perhaps someone might find it helpful. https://jborichevskiy.com/posts/healthy-living/

I like this idea, but I'm far too afraid that this information can be leaked out, or that companies and .govs will try to buy it from the software company.

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#152

> How and how well do you keep track of your mental health Mentally. Not very well. This is an area in need of improvement for me. I'm mid-30s and mental health is getting to be pretty important as of late. > , particularly for those with a history of mental health issues, and those with a family history of mental issues. TBQH I think that means everyone . I live in America. In America, mental health takes a backseat…

I live in America, too, and it sucks, from a healthcare perspective. I've seen about 6-7 therapists in my life, and I would see two of them again, and one of those I definitely can't afford to. I think you should try it once and "normalize" the act to yourself. Give yourself 3-4 sessions with someone and if it feels weird, cancel or switch. It can be expensive, but you should really try it, because it can be highly effective for many people. I haven't seen a therapist in about a year, and don't have healthcare, but I would if it were easier and more affordable.

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#153
I feel psychology has way many ways to help us. If you happen to open to new things:

- Personality psychology is insanely powerful and useful when it comes to understanding people / situations. An introduction to theories of personality Book by Robert B Ewen is gold.

Have you ever had gut instinct about how someone acts/a phenomena but lacked the words to express it? A distrust/discomfort, déjà vu, or feeling someone is being motivated by dredging up an issue from their past and trying to recreate it with you, to "try it on" you like a Cinderella slipper? (Could be in a good or bad way)

When you grasp the concepts, it can go well into looking at your family / upbringing, yourself, selecting a partner, personalities to distrust/avoid, etc.

Also you may find yourself liking concepts from Freud / Jung / Adler / Horney / Bowlby+Ainsworth and so on. That alone can give you a more informed perspective on behavior.

- Here's an example of professor using the above tools to dissect Twilight (haven't saw the movie or read it yet): Deconstructing Twilight: Psychological and Feminist Perspectives on the Series New edition Edition by Donna M. Ashcraft. She also written a personality theories workbook.

- Object relations stuff is absolutely awesome. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Myk352wMSs. IMO it's far easier to digest if you grasp psychodynamic theories above.

- Projective identification: https://youtu.be/cBnZiP3W3ao?t=1215

- You can then take it into individual (like schema therapy https://www.guilford.com/excerpts/young.pdf) and family therapy methods (e.g. Bowenian https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLQOWoom2d0) where the concepts on the stuff above occur

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#154
Today I learned 4 people suicided because of lack of money. All of them were over 40, I am sad the people of this country couldn't see them. I am sad I know some people will have it in future for just same reason. I am sad it could be me I am sad I can be one of my family member.

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#155
post #35

I'm supposed to use a document template my therapist emailed me, most likely I will search for an app that does the same (too paranoid about printing and filling a document about my mood) -- so I don't track it yet. I was diagnosed 5 years ago with BPD, has gotten better over the years(mostly by just life exposure I guess), I still get huge situational flare-ups, stuff about work or family, but I no longer react like…

Is the template something you could share? I'd be interested in seeing it, and I'm sure I'm not the only one. In the paste I've created text expansions for journaling forms I've wanted to use, then just dump them into the app I was using. Unfortunately I don't have those anymore.

The template is in romanian so I'll try and describe it, the columns are days of week, the lines are:

"Daily disposition" -5 Maximum Depression .. +5 full blown Mania

Wakeup hour

Breakfast hour

Lunch hour

Active hours per day (work, school or other)

Number of people you interacted with that day

Physical activity in hours

Dinner hour

Sleep hour

Substance consumption(alcohool, tobacco, coffee, other)

Special events/ conflicts

Treatment

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#156
post #31

Therapy is more effective than it has any business being. If you can make it happen, try it. I’m going to start by saying I have a mood disorder, and I don’t understand anxiety disorders because they’re part of a completely different world from mine. Conversations I’ve had with people that have anxiety disorders have reinforced this idea that I really don’t understand anxiety disorders or relate to them. The worst pa…

I have a mood disorder and generalized anxiety disorder. This is the most accurate answer in the thread. > Having strong relationships, having a therapist, and keeping a regular schedule. These are the things I'm actively working on. I'm only 6 months into working full time. It's monumentally difficult just to achieve those 3 things. I haven't worked an 8 hour day since training because I often feel drained and unpro…

Have you noticed anything from doing CBT? Or what has your experience been like so far?

I've done it before, but have been thinking about trying it again, but wanted to talk to others that have tried it.

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#157
post #100
post #3

Use the following strategies: 1. Meditate daily for 15 minutes. Try vedic indian meditations. 2. Keep track of your mood using some app. 3. If your mood is bad for consistently 3 days, then open pastebin and write down about everything you are feeling and going in your head. Most small problems with mental health can be dealt by bringing in consciousness. Simple example, whenever you are feeling nervous, force you br…

Every single meditation expert I know has given a warning with it. For some people, even 5 minutes is harsh. I've been in groups where people just break down and cry at that point. One meditation coach once told me a story of one of his clients who did a 20 minute guided session, and he went out of it with vomiting, diarrhea, and was really angry at the guy. But a few days later, he felt something clear up and asked…

Why would meditation lead to vomiting and/or diarrhea? I suppose I can understand where the sobbing might come from if you're in a tough space and dwelling on sad thoughts, but the other two?

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#158
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there something wrong with the way I jog? Because I don't find it to be making much of a difference. Same for cycling, walking, etc.

where do you jog? do you jog with someone? sometimes that makes a huge difference. I try to jog outside in the morning or during lunch.

Here, alone: https://www.google.com/maps/dir/62.2298738,25.7369546/62.229...

I'm really not a morning person, and my lunch breaks are stretching long enough as it is.. that really leaves after work as the only passable time.

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#159
Its not easy to live openly as a survivor and I still struggle with it: I was repeatedly abused sexually as a child, my adopted mother had sex me when I was 6... but that is nothing compared to a sexual assault that I suffered at the hands of a nurse.

I won't go into the details; except to say that is was so traumatic I was blind to the scar that she left on my penis (my first real GF asked me how I got it at when I was 18, and even though it was plain as day I never noticed it!). I had no memory of her attack until about 40 years later, and I suffered severe headaches and bloody nightmares those for 40 years.

The day I remembered her attack the nightmares ended and I virtually never get any headaches--and when I do, half an aspirin cure's them; they are not the debilitating monsters that formerly haunted me. I know I have PTSD but its not easy to deal with my past... I get nauseous thinking about it (here it comes now in fact) but I'm better than I was before so, we'll keep chipping away at it for now. I have told one doc about this in detail a few years ago and an online chat buddy who was assaulted when she was a girl is a huge help in this.

Re: Ask HN: How is your mental health?

#160

Therapy is more effective than it has any business being. If you can make it happen, try it. I’m going to start by saying I have a mood disorder, and I don’t understand anxiety disorders because they’re part of a completely different world from mine. Conversations I’ve had with people that have anxiety disorders have reinforced this idea that I really don’t understand anxiety disorders or relate to them. The worst pa…

I wonder if you've ever tried remote therapy video apps or phone calls, or if you do exclusively 1-on-1 in-person sessions? I don't really have any particular acute problem to go to a therapist with, but am more curious just to have someone to talk to about some things I noticed in my personality which may or may not be normal (and I want to know if they are!). Since and the remote sessions are much more affordable than in-person sessions here when it comes to something recurring, I wonder if this is a reasonable solution, or if something remote is less likely to be useful.
Post reply on HN