Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

news.ycombinator.com

121–130 of 155 posts

Re: Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

#121

45 minutes of sustained aerobic exercise at least 3 times a week or every day ideally if you can fit it in. The method of action is probably neurogenesis in the hippocampus which is the brain region responsible for forming new memories but may also play a dominant role in associating information that the brain is already storing with new information aka problem solving. https://scholar.google.ca/scholar?q=aerobic+exe…

Other than running any ideas on what aerobic exercise I should do? Cycling and swimming are the only ones that come to mind.

Anything that will get your heartrate into zone 2 and keep it there for the duration of the exercise. It really depends on what you prefer to do since being consistent with it is the most important thing. If you're unsure, you could always join a gym with a decent selection of equipment and try each of the machines for a week and see which one you feel like sticking with. If you don't want to go to a gym then your options are more limited, pretty much just the ones you listed.

If you don't really do any exercise at all at the moment I'd recommend starting with just walking for 45 minutes, you'll need to do that or some other low intensity exercise for a while to build up to being able to doing 45 minutes of fairly intense cardio. Do a search on YouTube for "how to start running" and you'll find a lot of good plans that you can use and they generalize pretty well to other types of cardio.

Re: Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

#122

45 minutes of sustained aerobic exercise at least 3 times a week or every day ideally if you can fit it in. The method of action is probably neurogenesis in the hippocampus which is the brain region responsible for forming new memories but may also play a dominant role in associating information that the brain is already storing with new information aka problem solving. https://scholar.google.ca/scholar?q=aerobic+exe…

Other than running any ideas on what aerobic exercise I should do? Cycling and swimming are the only ones that come to mind.

Sports should count towards aerobic right? It is hard to find partners and teammates as we age. So individual sports like tennis, squash, etc. Seen plenty of older folks playing those also.

I think forms of martial arts are also fun and sustainable long term. Cycling as a group also good fun.

Re: Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

#123
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm pretty sure the FDA has never denied a drug use application because it's not patentable and that's just a conspiracy theory used by people pushing bogus treatments. If there's peer-reviewed research that it works, it would be prescribed without doctor shopping.

>I'm pretty sure the FDA has never denied a drug use application because it's not patentable and that's just a conspiracy theory used by people pushing bogus treatments. No, that's not it, that's a very uncharitable interpretation and is unnecessarily dismissive . The real issue is that no one wants to pay for studies to turn off-label uses to on-label uses if there isn't money in it because the process is expensive,…

Apologies for the wrong interpretation, but I'm still skeptical. The generic drug market is huge, this drug in particular is already approved and in wide use for fertility treatment meaning that it's already passed safety trials. Getting approval for a secondary usage would be less costly than starting from scratch and there would likely be a huge market for this. There is absolutely money to be made from anyone who wants to get in this market.

Re: Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

#124
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

+1. For people without kids yet, pay close attention to this comment. If you have big dreams, better get on them now. For OP's #3 question: Reducing inputs has helped me tremendously. You don't need to pay attention to everything. You don't need to stay abreast of everything.

The capacity nosedive from having kids goes away as they grow up and become independent. And the coping skills you learned to deal with having less energy become almost super powers once your energy comes back. Likewise, the skill of having dealt with children through all ages and stages makes it easier to relate to difficult co-workers. I'm not saying work is easier once your kids are older... but your capacity to m…

Thanks for posting this. My kids are getting to their teens and the fog is lifting somewhat.

I couldn't think of an elegant way to mention that and suggest that OP should still attempt to maintain their mental faculties (nutrition, sleep, reading, learning within capabilities), so they aren't caught with their proverbial pants down when the kids get older.

Re: Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

#125
It's hard to stay motivated/sharp if you feel sick, fatigued, achey, etc. So I recommend taking a close look at your health... more specifically how you actually physically feel day to day, alongside looking for potential causes. Keep a health journal if you have to. Believe it or not, most people don't realize how some things subtly affect them.

Take this for example. Every couple of weeks or so, I noticed my stomach would ache, and bowel movements would burn. Wasn't sure why, but it turns out, it entirely coincided with me chewing gum or lying down after a large meal. Ceasing to do these things removed these acid reflux symptoms I'd occasionally get. Now I don't have this problem anymore.

Another example. I use to get migraines with aura almost every weekend. Again, wasn't sure why until I figured out it was due to my caffeine consumption. I use to drink coffee during weekdays at work, but would avoid caffeine otherwise. This meant I would undergo a caffeine withdrawal every weekend, and it in turn would trigger my migraines. So I cut out all caffeine from my diet (including chocolate) 2 years ago, and I haven't had a migraine since. I now sleep easier, focus better, and my mood is more stable.

Both of these changes have improved how I feel, which in turn have improved my stress tolerance and motivation for things, which I think has helped me on cognitive tasks. Maybe there are similar changes you can find and make.

Re: Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

#126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for posting this - I'm having this problem, but I've put it down to having small children, the chronic lack of sleep and the rarely having more than 1 hour time in a week where it's quiet and I can focus. That combined with being totally out of shape (covid + terrible two's).

I would recommend trying to work on diet/exercise before I would go down the TRT path. If you get those squared away and stress at home is reduced and you still are having the same issues then it maybe something to look into.

That's the plan - I was lifting before we had our youngest (2.5) and fairly fit (dad bod but I was working on it). Last 2.5 years ruined that. Will be happy when I can get back to regular training but for that to happen we need to be over this current period.

Re: Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

#128
My problem solving skillset is different.

I'm slower dealing with large volumes of detail or tasks, typing, reading, etc.

I'm better at deeper work involving higher level concepts and how it connects to lower ones, inter-related domains, reducing the solution space while covering the problem space etc.

I find the best way for me to improve is avoid being clever for its own sake. Instead tackle each problem and produce the simplest thing that does what you need it to do. This doesn't mean the easiest way to get the result making additive spaghetti, I mean the most compact representation that covers all cases old, current, and immediately foreseeable. You'll know that you've done it well when someone sees the whole thing and goes 'meh'. Or when they ask what about A, or what about B, and you have a quick way to describe how each fits in that might not have been immediately apparent to the asker.

The great advantage of working this way is that when you do actually need a big solution, it will be solving a huge problem because the big problems were solved with small solutions.

Re: Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

#129
Psychiatry observes that in the 20s, most people cannot see their own failures, but in their 30s, most people can.

Think about someone you know who is around your age, and who you knew in your and their early 20s. Now, imagine them creating something that's fit to their personality. Programming, cooking, writing, whatever. Assume that what they created is pretty good for them, and fairly good for everyone. My personal experience with people suggests that the 20s version will be exaggeratedly proud, whereas the 30s person will be asking contemporaries for advice on how to improve.

My personal belief is that this is driven by the 20 year old thinking the work is genuinely great, and the 30 year old thinking "geez, I could do better than this, have I been wasting my talent?"

I would wager that it's likely that you're simply becoming more discerning. It's unsettling, but positive, in the net.

Genuine cognitive decline is currently believed by medical science to kick in in the late 40s or early 50s for most people.

Another significant possibility is sleep quality, which for some people declines drastically in the 30s (often tied to weight.) Sleep quality has a huge amount to do with cognitive performance. Do you wake up tired a lot? Do you snore? Have you ever been checked for sleep apnea, which a little over a third of humanity has? My getting a CPAP really deeply changed my mental state. My doctor said that they thought I hadn't had a genuinely good sleep in more than a decade. It takes about a month to start feeling okay again.

It is genuinely worth talking to a good doctor about this. They will be much better than the wisdom of the crowds.

Re: Ask HN: Have you experienced decline in problem-solving skills? How to improve?

#130
post #5

Just wait until you have kids. Your mental capacity will nosedive and you have no time to worry about it. Just hope that no one notices!

I am this stage currently. Amazon recruiter has been asking me to take a technical assessment for weeks. I have no will power at all. Frankly, I am at a point where I won't study leetcode at all. I'm willing to make a move but will not grind. Working on CRUD doesn't help the situation but at least I can do it with my tired and fried brain.

If it helps, I did like 2 easy leetcode exercises and still got into Amazon lol. I've done nothing but business applications for my entire career, so I don't know jack about data-structures nor algorithms. Most of the interview is about your work history and "leadership" questions.

EDIT: btw Amazon is NOT a good place for busy parents IMO. The on-call rotation can be brutal. YMMV based on where you land in the company, but if they will try to sell you hard on the positive aspects of the company and downplay the negatives, so beware.

Post reply on HN