Earlier quoted context omitted.
This still asserts that solving the problems of a poor person is worth less than solving the problems of a rich person. Also, getting paid by the government to do something is decisively a non-market solution, given that the government gets its money through taxes.
Your first statement seems to imply that the market is flawed (because, obviously, the willingness to pay for something is going to be higher for someone with lots of money than someone with little), the second seems to imply that there is something inherently beneficial in focusing on 'market solutions' as you define them. These views are rather at odds with each other. But, I'm not trying to comment on either of th…
Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
111–120 of 441 posts
Re: Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
#112You might as well have asked who among us won the lottery. I've been struggling with this for years now; after 4 boring jobs I finally gave up even the expectation that what I'll be asked to do will be even remotely interesting (or socially useful). The chance of landing an interesting job is absolutely minuscule - the market rewards whatever it rewards at the moment, and that's where jobs flock. These days, one of t…
Re: Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
#113Re: Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
#114If you want consistently interesting work you need to be proficient in two different disciplines. Computer Science isn’t enough. Interesting work is the product of being an interesting person. If you are a computer scientist and say, a marine geologist , there is some work that only you would be able to do, and some innovations that only you can see, that plain CS guys knee deep in the CRUD cannot.
I wish I'd know that 11 years ago. I'd go to study aeronautical engineering or biology instead of CS. Now, I play the catch-up game, trying to learn a completely different field, just to have something interesting to apply all my programming knowledge and experience to.
Re: Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
#115You might as well have asked who among us won the lottery. I've been struggling with this for years now; after 4 boring jobs I finally gave up even the expectation that what I'll be asked to do will be even remotely interesting (or socially useful). The chance of landing an interesting job is absolutely minuscule - the market rewards whatever it rewards at the moment, and that's where jobs flock. These days, one of t…
While I don't agree with Marx, your sense of ennui seems to reasonably represent what I understand to have been his concepts of reification and alienation. One might ask: what does the alternative look like? From what I can tell Marx is a bit wishy-washy on that point. Hayek more helpfully explained that the market provides a mechanism for determining value, not virtue . That it works, but doesn't uplift. And that tr…
Re: Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
#116You might as well have asked who among us won the lottery. I've been struggling with this for years now; after 4 boring jobs I finally gave up even the expectation that what I'll be asked to do will be even remotely interesting (or socially useful). The chance of landing an interesting job is absolutely minuscule - the market rewards whatever it rewards at the moment, and that's where jobs flock. These days, one of t…
As a Mechanical Engineer with solid math and physics background, using Machine Learning and Numeric Methods to substantially engage and improve product performance, I really feel like I won the lottery.
I handicapped myself by going into CS instead of graduating some hard engineering degree (or biology). See also matte_black's comment elsewhere in this discussion. Programming alone is a tool in search of problems to solve, and the interesting problems are elsewhere.
Re: Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
#117I work in a different corner of the development biz doing computer vision, graphics and new products for companies. This week I’m working on “reading” test strips for a new medical device. Last month I was working on the graphics for a landing radar.
At the risk of of telling you to “eat what I do and you’ll be as tall as I am”, I think you might find more developer happiness if you can get off the rails of business/web development and instead, work for small companies on desktop and/or embedded products. I think the key is working for small or tiny companies. Heck, maybe working just for a tiny company might make using your skills fun again. In a tiny company you get to wear a lot of hats so you learn things and use new technologies.
Re: Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
#118Earlier quoted context omitted.
While I don't agree with Marx, your sense of ennui seems to reasonably represent what I understand to have been his concepts of reification and alienation. One might ask: what does the alternative look like? From what I can tell Marx is a bit wishy-washy on that point. Hayek more helpfully explained that the market provides a mechanism for determining value, not virtue . That it works, but doesn't uplift. And that tr…
> the market provides a mechanism for determining value The market's notion of value is weighted by wealth: making coffee for the rich is "valuable", meeting the basic needs of the poor is not "valuable." This makes the market notion of "value" very different from just about any other notion of value in the world. If you muddy the distinction, or let someone else muddy the distinction, markets become almost tautologi…
There's a lot of privilege talking about what is and is not valuable, but its worth pointing out that its only a very recent, probably very temporary, phenomena that coffee is all about rich people massively overpaying in public as an act of conspicuous consumption at Starbucks, for some decades previous McDonalds and other fast food sellers made more total money selling coffee than hipster coffee shops.
There are some market bifurcation events going on, as relates to income inequality only increasing over time. For example the number of independent bicycle shops has been dropping for decades while average revenue and profit increase... thats because the market for $2000 adult bikes is extremely high social status but also very small, leading to the inaccurate observation that "there's no money selling bikes to poor people". However, sales and revenue for poor people bikes at department stores, walmart, etc, are really pretty good, its just that you can't buy a poor person bike at a cool trendy rich hipster independent bicycle store, only from extremely uncool mass retailers. There are absolute tons and boatloads of money in selling bicycles to poor people; the money is inaccessible to the "cool kids" is the only problem.
Food deserts are a similar thing; the point of talking about food deserts is to point out the individual noticing them is a really cool person.
Perhaps a HN car analogy where nothing could be cooler on social media and more valuable than bragging about selling Tesla cars to very rich people, but you won't make even a tiny fraction as much total revenue as the incredibly uncool act of selling commuter SUVs to suburbanites.
Being cool and trendy on twitter is important, but you can make many times as much money by being very uncool. To some extent the whole meta overall topic is conspicuous consumption at its finest, along the lines of I'm rich enough and privileged enough to pretend deeply uncool (as defined on social media) market opportunities literally don't exist.
Re: Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
#119Earlier quoted context omitted.
While I don't agree with Marx, your sense of ennui seems to reasonably represent what I understand to have been his concepts of reification and alienation. One might ask: what does the alternative look like? From what I can tell Marx is a bit wishy-washy on that point. Hayek more helpfully explained that the market provides a mechanism for determining value, not virtue . That it works, but doesn't uplift. And that tr…
Marx is vague and rightly so. I think the situationists took a similar approach, which is also their main criticism. They do not describe what the utopia would be not really the steps, they instead say that it's a state that occurs when people live according to their desires. That to me sounds like "do what thou wilt" where the task is to find out what our desire, our will is.
Re: Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
#120I feel so sorry for you. Life is so very brief to be working on something you don’t like. I look forward to going to work every (week) day. I work in a different corner of the development biz doing computer vision, graphics and new products for companies. This week I’m working on “reading” test strips for a new medical device. Last month I was working on the graphics for a landing radar. At the risk of of telling you…