Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What device do you use to read academic papers with?

news.ycombinator.com

111–120 of 147 posts

Re: Ask HN: What device do you use to read academic papers with?

#111
Notes & tracking: emacs + org-mode. Not ideal, but I can have it and it does 60% of the job out of the box.

Storing: filesystem (notes include where I stored it).

Reading: E-ink.

I started with Pocketbook 622 (a 6", 800x600 display). Worked very well. Can open many formats _natively_ (doc, rtf, djvu etc, check specs for full list). One of the first docs was anatomy atlas from 19century via archive. Rendered only decently, required huge magnification/landscape mode/margin cutting to be of any use. I had varying experience with other pdf/djvu documents - depending how they were created. Some djvus rendered excellently on 6", despite being meant for bigger (close to a4) page size. No problem with rtf/epub and other such formats. Magazines in pdf (a4) very hard to read, not worth it really. Arxiv's pdfs looked good/very good, sometimes they could be reflowed or put into column view, which helped a lot but with reflow I learned math not always shows up properly. Old computer manuals (my hobby, they are just scaned typewritten books) - not good enough.

Next model was Inkpad 840 (a 8", 1600x1200 display). What looks good on Pb622, looks good too on Ip840. Magazines look better, but they require a good light for really comfortably reading. Otherwise, I can go with dim night light. This model has backlight, but I don't like the idea of shining into my eyes.

Huge plus: sd card slot. I go on for months airgapped. Huge minus: maybe it is just me, but reading html docs almost always sucks one way or another. What to look for: external hard case so I don't have to be oh so wary. It was a PITA trying to find case for Ip840 thanks to its nonstandard dimensions. I settled down with some oversized tablet case. Ip840 feels a bit slow and awkward (compared to Pb622) but I got used to it. If I had to buy again, I would have had a closer look on Kobo models too. Kindle does not cut it for me - requires too big commitment.

All of this just MHO, of course.

Re: Ask HN: What device do you use to read academic papers with?

#113

Device is a MacBook Pro running Papers [1] to organize and read references. Works well with over 18,000 references and their pdfs in my database. [1] http://papersapp.com/mac/

Me too, but god the UI is buggy! Shamefully so for the price.

Re: Ask HN: What device do you use to read academic papers with?

#115
post #83

To organise/track papers: I’m currently using Mendeley[1]. Previously, I used Papers[2]. Unfortunately, the latest version of Papers (3.x) is terrible compared to how slick the old version (2.x) was. I’ve tried ReadCube[3], but somehow I find Mendeley easier to work with. I used EndNote[4] before I discovered Papers, and wouldn’t recommend it. I keep all my .pdf files in Dropbox. Discussions/recommendations for paper…

I'll second Mendeley. I've used several other options, but Mendeley has a Chrome plug-in that will download the PDF as well as try to read author and other bibliographical info. The desktop app helps in searching for key words within all documents as well as individual documents.

Combining the mendeley plugin with the automatic .bib generator and LyX means I can cite stuff pretty much as quickly as looking at the page.

Re: Ask HN: What device do you use to read academic papers with?

#116
post #63

I find it much more difficult to read long sections of academic text on a computer or tablet than on paper. When I need to read a paper thoroughly, I print it out. For storage I use Papers ( http://papersapp.com/ ). Highly recommended if a little pricey.

I've been using Papers on the Mac and on iOS since they came out, I second the recommendation. I, too, will print out a paper if I really want to go over it thoroughly.

Re: Ask HN: What device do you use to read academic papers with?

#118

Device is a MacBook Pro running Papers [1] to organize and read references. Works well with over 18,000 references and their pdfs in my database. [1] http://papersapp.com/mac/

How did you get to 18000 references? What field are you in?

Re: Ask HN: What device do you use to read academic papers with?

#119
post #67
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

$400USD is with 40% off too! and it's really low ppi, not even up to my personal minimum of 350ppi which really makes for decent, clear reading.

PPI really depends on the viewing distance. You're usually very close to a phone but much further away from a 27" monitor and further away still from a 65" TV. I'd say for a large 13-inch ebook reader, a 167ppi grayscale display (for anti-aliasing) is pretty good. Until very recently all ebook readers were around 167ppi (most of them 6 inches diagonally) and most people were OK with it. The high prices are due to the…

I agree on distance but there is a massive difference between an 8" device with 300+ PPI and one that's 224~ PPI, and if I'm getting a slightly larger device I'm going to want it as sharp as possible, it's a bit like having a 27" monitor - they look dreadful at 1080P, and I think they're only just good enough at 2160p which is generally 163 PPI - now you can really see the difference between that and a 27" 5K display at 218 PPI which lots a lot clearer.

Re: Ask HN: What device do you use to read academic papers with?

#120

My laptop, I use SumatraPDF with bookview (Ctrl+8). Seeing two pages side by side, like a book, even on small screens makes a huge difference for me. Also the ability to switch between documents easily (ctrl+tab and ctrl+shift+tab) is really handy, when I am researching a topic. I haven't figured out the annotation and highlighting part yet. I just copy and paste important parts into an Emacs org-mode document and su…

I have some code for extracting PDF annotations into markdown or org-mode: https://github.com/malb/emacs.d/blob/master/malb.org#pdf-vie...
Post reply on HN