Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

news.ycombinator.com

101–110 of 325 posts

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#101
post #68

You haven’t said what you do for money. Is that all sorted out? Or, are you wealthy enough that you don't have to work? It is very important to truly know yourself and design your life based on that. I was born into enough wealth that I did not have to think about food, clothes, treatment, housing, etc. -the very basics. But, by no way were we rich. So, I knew I had to work. What work? After some disillusionment, a l…

I second this.

In order to become an appreciated and appreciative generalist one also has to go deep down (at least one) rabbit hole of "specialized" knowledge.

The Dunning-Kruger effect is quite powerful and not only on a small scale of a couple of months but a couple of years, too. I must admit that I experienced the imposter syndrome quite intensely relatively late in my life only after really digging into a particular field (on/off >5 years): the amount of things "known" is truly and shockingly (infinitesimally) small like looking into a void after all that acquired knowledge and skill.

This (humbling) experience makes you a better rounded generalist i.e. team player in being able to connect with the sensitive issue of "horror vacuui" specialists see themselves inevitably confronted at times: What do I know.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#102
Is there room for advice on what happens if you have this affliction in the programming language space?

I did the guru thing, and then went on a journey of polyglotism for the last 10 years. And hanging out on HN doesn’t help! Should I Rust? Or Zig? Or React? Or … the list just goes on … and FOMO kicks in.

But I find on the rare occasion when I check linked in, there’s lots of offers for one specific language or the other. Im not sure what the market for polyglots (or scanners as mentioned above) is anymore.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#103
> I won't be able to handle the demands of formal schooling

There are evening universities, certificates, part-time masters degrees (e.g. see The Open University), all meant for people who don't study full-time.

Degrees help in signaling that you're more than just a dilettante, which matters to get the corresponding opportunities. There's no way for somebody who doesn't know you to assess how deep you actually go when you switch from one topic to another, unless they are themselves experts in these topics. And indeed, it's easy to be stuck with a shallow understanding of a whole field if nobody ever questions it (compare reading a pop-science book and sitting an exam). I feel it's especially true with the fields you've mentioned where any ground truth is more subtle to discern than in e.g. mathematics.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry to burst your bubble but marriage regret is the norm past age 35. One of the canned responses to going your own way is always "who hurt you".

Most marriages that are first marriages for both partners end in death. Doesn't sound like there's a lot of regret there. People want to stay married. Otherwise they wouldn't.

Sure I read a statistic that roughly half of "happy", long term marriages are, in fact, unhappy and unfulfilled. If true then about 20-25% of first time marriages do not have happy endings.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#105
basically you're hitting the wall that Aristotle was talking about- only aristocratic people can pursue knowledge, because the other people are busy working (to sustain the aristocrats)

you're to low-born to lead a satisfying intellectual life, sorry :/ I'm like you

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#106
post #101
post #68

You haven’t said what you do for money. Is that all sorted out? Or, are you wealthy enough that you don't have to work? It is very important to truly know yourself and design your life based on that. I was born into enough wealth that I did not have to think about food, clothes, treatment, housing, etc. -the very basics. But, by no way were we rich. So, I knew I had to work. What work? After some disillusionment, a l…

I second this. In order to become an appreciated and appreciative generalist one also has to go deep down (at least one) rabbit hole of "specialized" knowledge. The Dunning-Kruger effect is quite powerful and not only on a small scale of a couple of months but a couple of years, too. I must admit that I experienced the imposter syndrome quite intensely relatively late in my life only after really digging into a parti…

Exactly.

A scanner knows enough vocabulary to fool non-experts and thus is susceptible to developing DK. This definitely enforces DK as one of many factors.

I have met several such people. I have expertise in multiple narrow areas, and they couldn’t fool me.

This has, in turn, made me skeptic in all other areas where I do not have expertise. I always have my guards up when I hear someone talk about anything.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#107
No one can set a goal for you. You have to find your own goals within yourself.

If your goal is to enrich knowledge and educate yourself, you can just continue reading and learning.

If your goal is to become famous, you can start a blog, write articles, write a book, start a YouTube channel.

If your goal is to make money you can research some corporations, NGOs or think tanks that will pay you for producing materials that support their goals.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#108
post #2

I was going to suggest writing, and I'll go one further: Do write a blog, but don't just write a blog. Write a blog, and then create a video for each blog post, and upload it to YouTube (where the eyeballs willing to consume intellectual material are). Also do livestreams. Start interviewing anyone who will take you seriously. Set a goal for who your dream interviewee is. Do this for a couple years, putting out conte…

> YouTube (where the eyeballs willing to consume intellectual material are). Whyyyyyyyyy?! Seriously I'm curious, what happened? Do intellectuals (whatever that means) really not prefer reading any more? A desire for Podcasts/audiobooks I can understand, as someone who occasionally has to drive places, but video?

I feel that you can assign a separate IQ-like score to many different components of human intelligence. I score badly on book comprehension relative to other components.

I find it easier to concentrate for an hour or two on a video than a book. I'm probably slightly dyslexic or something. At university I made sure I never missed a lecture but hardly ever read a book. I did above averagely well.

This is a disadvantage though. I have friends who can read books in a couple of hours and absorb the content. I'd have to sit through more hours of video to get the same content, even watching the videos at 2x speed.

Wild speculation: being intellectual used to require being good at book comprehension. Maybe only 10% of the population are good at that. Maybe some of the remaining 90% are still clever. If so, video content could allow those book-comprehension-limited people to become intellectual. That'd be nice.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#109
Seems like most advice here is to secure some kind of financial future for yourself first to be able to follow your passion.

But I think many here will never find the fulfillment you feel when you study new topics.

I think cultivating that passion should come first.

Re: Ask HN: I'm interested in so many disciplines, but what can I do with that?

#110
(i can relate), you sound younger than me, so here is my life-hack tutorial I wish I could send to myself:

welcome to the life of the autodidact, sounds like you are well on the path towards being a polymath in a plurality of subjects. without formal degrees in subject matters people will NOT take you seriously, so it's best if you can connect with other people who are credentialed - there are several ways to do this, best case see if you can get your name on a few papers in the field(s) you are interested in. there might be conferences, reddits, or discords on subject matters that interest you - look for those to network. you will need to continue feeding your curiosity or you will probably become depressed. having a wife and kids, try to always put them first to be a good father! (note: i wasn't, and that scar doesn't fade - so kids are the priority once you've got them and you'll probably need to wait until they're off to college before you really get any free time to pursue your own interests).

someday, it's possible (although semi-unlikely) perhaps you might find or discover something that nobody else has figured out or bothered to do yet - but don't try create and do anything that requires a seed capital because few will understand wtf you are talking about most of the time and with no degree nobody will take you seriously making fund-raising an exercise in futility unless you literally get a patent - if you can build/demonstrate a prototype/mvp then it might be a different tune -- if you can sell/license something you make in the field, then you can pay yourself to pursue your passions and that's "living your best life" (where I am now) but until then you're probably going to be living a lonely life of solitude with regard to your academic pursuits. cheers.

Post reply on HN