Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

news.ycombinator.com

101–110 of 154 posts

Re: Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

#101

I use umami. Its lightweight and doesnt have too many dependencies. https://umami.is/docs/features There is also goatcounter with a slightly uglier UI but it does its job well and consumes even less RAM than umami

i've tried this for a high volume site, but since all events are stored in normal RDBMS, it gets slower [1][2]. it works well for low-traffic site though.

[1] https://github.com/mikecao/umami/issues/592

[2] https://github.com/mikecao/umami/discussions/909

Re: Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

#102
post #61

PostHog: https://github.com/PostHog/posthog if you want to deploy it yourself and https://posthog.com if you want the SaaS. I was using Avodocs ( https://www.avodocs.com ) to produce a privacy policy for our MLOps platform, https://iko.ai , but they didn't have PostHog in the list for the "Analytics" section, and they assumed that doing analytics implied sending user data to a third party site or something. I tweeted…

Side question. Posthog describes an event pipeline. Is there a saas/open source server with event pipelines where you can do add logic to do things, like: send email, notifications, send api call, maybe add custom logic etc. Ive seen things like segment.io, but didn't find a straightforward solution. Example: - if a user finished three workouts, send this notification. - if a user hasn't done a workout in a week remi…

If you write your data into a data warehouse or clickhouse you could use something like https://hightouch.io/

Re: Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

#103
post #30
post #8

I use plausible for my very low traffic side project, mostly because it's easy to host yourself and free if you do so. https://github.com/plausible/analytics

I also like plausible - low cost for a low traffic site, but without all the more intrusive tracking/features that google has. I use it on about a dozen sites I develop/maintain. Also has a self-hosted option which is 'free', but you need to pay to host it someplace. I just pay them instead.

+1 on that.

We are using it on sites that generate between 15 and 100k monthly views [1], and it works flawlessly!

Also has a super easy API to add custom events (gone is the nightmare of configuring it in GTM)

[1] https://devitjobs.us and others

Re: Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

#104
post #8

I use plausible for my very low traffic side project, mostly because it's easy to host yourself and free if you do so. https://github.com/plausible/analytics

I use it on https://allaboutberlin.com, which has medium traffic.

Plausible is enough for most, but it doesn't track as much as Google Analytics. It's enough to know which content works, but not enough to understand your users' behaviour.

However removing the cookie banner is a great UX improvement, and respecting your users' privacy is what you ought to do.

I'd also add that the maintainers were nothing short of excellent, and took care of two tickets I opened before.

Re: Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

#105
post #14

I wrote two articles about this for LWN last year. Several of them are self-hostable. Summary: https://lwn.net/Articles/822568/ : lightweight options: GoatCounter and Plausible (open source), Simple Analytics and Fathom (closed) https://lwn.net/Articles/824294/ : more alternatives: Matomo and Open Web Analytics (fairly heavyweight but both open source), Countly (open core), Snowplow Analytics (open source but enterpr…

> Matomo Google may sometimes disable AdWords campaigns on sites that use Matomo. They "fix" it every once in a while when Matomo devs reach out to them, but the problem returns after a few months each time. https://forum.matomo.org/t/adwords-campaign-rejected-for-goo...

> Google may sometimes disable AdWords campaigns on sites that use Matomo.

I first used Matomo to monitor users webapp experience, it was amazingly simple to set up, good privacy protection/anonymisation, and perfect for insights on workflow patterns.

Re: Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

#106

The standard recommendation is https://matomo.org/ . I’ve used it in production once (when it was called Piwik) and it seemed reasonable, but I’m not sure how it stacks up right now.

Currently using a single instance of Matomo for all of my sites, it's pretty good!

Doesn't take too much resources, the UI is pleasant, the functionality is everything that i'd expect from a lightweight analytics solution like Plausible plus bunches of additional stuff in regards to enriching the data (e.g. events, information about devices and software, even performance data in the latest releases).

My only concerns so far are that if i try to open the aggregate view of all of my website data in the past month (Apart from that nitpick, it's also pretty reasonable as far as GDPR goes (there's a whole section of tools for it) - currently i don't even use cookies for tracking (a global toggle in the options is available, as well as config for individual sites), anonymize the IP addresses but have a GeoIP database set up (for free) that let's me figure out the approximate location and still get the device info which is enough to give me insights into who uses my sites and what screen resolutions etc. i should target.

Overall, i'm really pleased with my choice of Matomo!

Now, on the other end of things, i also think that most projects out there should have an APM solution of sorts, for which i use another piece of free software, Apache Skywalking, which is a bit more cumbersome, but still powerful and also Zabbix for server/VPS monitoring overall. It's really nice that we can set something like that up entirely for free (hosting costs aside).

Re: Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

#107

https://www.goatcounter.com/

Huh, the UI seems refreshingly lightweight and boring! Feels very much like the first time i saw Kanboard and was surprised at how minimalistic and snappy it felt in comparison to something like Jira: https://kanboard.org/

(well, most software probably feels more snappy than Jira, but Kanboard was also amazing)

Re: Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

#108
I have an indie project called Fugu (https://fugu.lol). Fugu is an open-source (https://github.com/shafy/fugu) and privacy-friendly product analytics. If you're looking strictly for web analytics, it might not be a good fit.

It's still an early version, but basic things like tracking events with properties, and analzying those, work very well. I'm currently working on adding conversion funnels. It's free to self-host, and I provide a managed version for $9/month flat.

I've started Fugu because I wanted a product analytics software that is privacy-first (e.g., no possibility of tracking unique users), open-source and simple. I liked using PostHog but it got too fancy, complex and convoluted for my taste - a common theme among analytics software in my experience.

If you're looking for a pure web analytics solution, I can absolutely recommend Plausible (https://plausible.io). I also use it for my static page at Fugu.

Edit: Added GitHub repo link.

Re: Ask HN: Good open source alternatives to Google Analytics?

#110

Why are most tools for analytics so expensive? Compared to other saas products I find them to be at least. Is there a significant amount of traffic that is the reason? I was thinking about implementing something myself once, but was worried about the cost of receiving all the event traffic.

Because their customers understand the value of the data and are willing to pay for it.

So are you saying that their profit is high or that the cost for running such saas is high?
Post reply on HN