Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Great Firewall in Iran?

news.ycombinator.com

11–18 of 18 posts

Re: Ask HN: Great Firewall in Iran?

#11
post #10
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess that could be the basis for a vacation, but I doubt the OP is going to move that needle with a burner phone and a VPN.

It speaks volumes that simply circumventing a firewall is "fucking with" a regime. I'm guessing Iran is similar to China (restrictions on GPS software etc). They may be simply trying to efficiently vacation. Having a way to get information out if mistreated can make mistreatment simply not happen. The Persian people are very friendly, but they're held hostage by a lunatic fringe. When you blame the user for circumven…

[dead]

Re: Ask HN: Great Firewall in Iran?

#12
post #10
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess that could be the basis for a vacation, but I doubt the OP is going to move that needle with a burner phone and a VPN.

It speaks volumes that simply circumventing a firewall is "fucking with" a regime. I'm guessing Iran is similar to China (restrictions on GPS software etc). They may be simply trying to efficiently vacation. Having a way to get information out if mistreated can make mistreatment simply not happen. The Persian people are very friendly, but they're held hostage by a lunatic fringe. When you blame the user for circumven…

efficiently vacation

That’s an oxymoron.

Re: Ask HN: Great Firewall in Iran?

#13
bro, just get a good tour guide, bring a camera and forget about twitter for a few weeks, whats the problem with that?

locals use VPNs, sometimes they work, sometimes they dont... gov has on/off switch so you are at their mercy, but honestly do you need access to US social media when on a vacation in a desert?

Re: Ask HN: Great Firewall in Iran?

#14
Censorship may not be as severe as China but the Iranian government is very paranoid these days due to security breaches in the recent war. Some of those breaches were hilarious Tbh and reflected badly on the regime. Its best not to be caught with your pants down while using a VPN illegally. There is not telling what they are up to in their extreme paranoia.

Re: Ask HN: Great Firewall in Iran?

#15

bro, just get a good tour guide, bring a camera and forget about twitter for a few weeks, whats the problem with that? locals use VPNs, sometimes they work, sometimes they dont... gov has on/off switch so you are at their mercy, but honestly do you need access to US social media when on a vacation in a desert?

No, I don't do SNS. I created it to show it to the police. Looks like "I don't have any social media" is considered to be suspicious and you are "hiding" something. At least that's true in the US. I don't know about Iran though.

Re: Ask HN: Great Firewall in Iran?

#16
post #14

Censorship may not be as severe as China but the Iranian government is very paranoid these days due to security breaches in the recent war. Some of those breaches were hilarious Tbh and reflected badly on the regime. Its best not to be caught with your pants down while using a VPN illegally. There is not telling what they are up to in their extreme paranoia.

How is censorship related to security? And why there should be more censorship during a war?

Re: Ask HN: Great Firewall in Iran?

#17
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It speaks volumes that simply circumventing a firewall is "fucking with" a regime. I'm guessing Iran is similar to China (restrictions on GPS software etc). They may be simply trying to efficiently vacation. Having a way to get information out if mistreated can make mistreatment simply not happen. The Persian people are very friendly, but they're held hostage by a lunatic fringe. When you blame the user for circumven…

efficiently vacation That’s an oxymoron.

Try taking a vacation using only paper maps -- no looking up cool restaurants, no directions etc.

You get a lot more done if you can use a smart device.

Re: Ask HN: Great Firewall in Iran?

#18

bro, just get a good tour guide, bring a camera and forget about twitter for a few weeks, whats the problem with that? locals use VPNs, sometimes they work, sometimes they dont... gov has on/off switch so you are at their mercy, but honestly do you need access to US social media when on a vacation in a desert?

No, I don't do SNS. I created it to show it to the police. Looks like "I don't have any social media" is considered to be suspicious and you are "hiding" something. At least that's true in the US. I don't know about Iran though.

Noone ever checked my phone in Iran, there is no reason. But unless you travel to meet family or friends, you need certified tour guide for the stay afaik.
Post reply on HN