Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 36 posts

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#11
Against the grain here: Yes, you will.

You should try to understand what it is useful for and what it isn't. You don't need to vibe code at all; in fact, it's the exact opposite. You should read the code and be able to figure out what LLMs are bad at and how they make inhuman mistakes.

I personally like the prompt completion of functions. The act of manually writing out in detail what needs to happen and how help me think about what I want to have done.

Anyway, the main argument I have that you should be using it is that the first and experience of using it will teach you about what to look for in broken LLM code and also help you guide others into producing less broken LLM code.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#12

You don't _NEED_ to know it, but it's probably good for your career to have some exposure in 2025 to LLMs. Download ollama and mess with a model locally, implement your own RAG system so you get a feel for what that entails and what good and bad use cases look like. I use LLMs every day for random stuff, but not really because I need the output, more because I need to know and understand where it's strengths and weak…

The op's not talking about running a local AI.

That's pretty much a complete waste of time as the op is not a developer.

The op's talking about using AI in their normal work workflows.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#13
I think there is something happening here and whats needed is your own independent opinions of the technology. I think a lot of people dont like the idiots hyping the tech up and the incessant nonsense. Thats what turns them away from AI. But its a very useful bit of technology and your relationship to it should be direct with no middlemen.

So if you want to work and adopt AI, make your own workflows. Interact directly with ChatGPT or even the API as opposed to learning cursor shortcuts or Lovable prompts.

I use AI very frequently and I love to spell out my thinking and even have AI critique it. Once done, I generate code in phases to save typing. I dont think anything will replace software engineers but engineers with more knowledge will replace those with less. You have to snatch that knowledge. Moronic VCs and tool vendors wont help, direct involvement will.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#14

Against the grain here: Yes, you will. You should try to understand what it is useful for and what it isn't. You don't need to vibe code at all; in fact, it's the exact opposite. You should read the code and be able to figure out what LLMs are bad at and how they make inhuman mistakes. I personally like the prompt completion of functions. The act of manually writing out in detail what needs to happen and how help me…

They're not a developer.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#15

Against the grain here: Yes, you will. You should try to understand what it is useful for and what it isn't. You don't need to vibe code at all; in fact, it's the exact opposite. You should read the code and be able to figure out what LLMs are bad at and how they make inhuman mistakes. I personally like the prompt completion of functions. The act of manually writing out in detail what needs to happen and how help me…

They're not a developer.

Somehow, I completely missed that...

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#16
Yes, you should.

As you're not a developer, but haven't told us your field, here are some general reasons why.

My non-devwloper friends (we're in our 40s) are using it to improve their productivity. They have already realized that the AI is bad at some tasks but great at others. For example, a person in PR now no longer writes the 'day to day' PR releases. It's a complete waste of their time, they're really just a formality anyway, and an AI can do it. But they still do all the important ones.

It can release you from routine tasks, or make them trivial.

I've also heard of someone who's using it to find jobs to tender for that they previously didn't have time to figure out. Filter + summarize. So tasks and opportunities that were too time consuming are now viable.

People are making their own mini apps for personal use that are specific for their field.

You don't necessarily have to have the ideas, but you do need to talk to people in your field and find out what they're doing.

MCP/Agents/etc. are pretty cutting edge, but you will start hearing non-techies using them soon.

Agents/MCP means the LLM can do things. You can ask it to make a plan of action, and then DO the actions. It's still a bit ropey.

But soon you might be able to ask your AI to go into HubSpot, find 10 leads that look like they've gone stale and send them a special offer. (It's not quite there yet, and a bit unreliable on something as high level as that, code is less fuzzy and so it performs better).

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#17
If you’re not a developer you might as well use AI to become one?

Back in my day we used learn x in y minutes to get up to speed on a new language and then a week to get comfortable.

Now I can do that for anything in like 15 minutes.

Of course, coding is the easy part and anyone can do it.

Software engineering (key word: engineering) is the hard part and requires that you understand the computer, design patterns, and how to build robust systems.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#18
I'm not sure if that's an answer to your question, but there are at least companies today that do no allow their programmers to use GenAI e.g. OpenAI, including tools running locally.

You could (for now) work for such a company.

That doesn't mean they'll be around in the future, maybe they will get left behind. But the future is difficult to predict, and it's at least the case that such companies exist today.

Then again it might be difficult to identify such companies. I tried to find any public information that the company I'm thinking of doesn't use AI (large US company, 10k+ employees) and I couldn't. So you probably wouldn't know, before working there, that they don't allow AI usage. So maybe this advice isn't as actionable as I'd hoped.

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#19
I'm an engineer and my general attitude is that when major new developments enter the space, it's worthwhile to understand how they work, why they were created, and what they could potentially be good for, and what they potentially won't be good for, and why.

I applied this methodology to mobile, cryptocurrencies, Web3, VR, and AI. I ended up being bearish about cryptocurrencies and Web3 and bullish about mobile, VR and AI. VR is having a fair amount of trouble taking off, but I think AI is not facing the same challenges. As such, I'm betting very strongly that it's going to be part of our future, and that means now is a good time to start understanding how it works and what people are saying about it and what might come next. I do this by putting my hands on the technology and running lots of different models locally and also experimenting with cloud models, as well as exploring what tools companies are building with these technologies. Simply reading doesn't quite do it for me.

I don't do this because I'm worried about being left behind, nearly as much as I want to be able to deploy these tools effectively in the future to solve problems. It's also fun!

Re: Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

#20
If someone never moved into web development and still coding C++ on Windows, do they survive? Maybe they did, having some job somewhere in a legacy company, or maybe they are doing some real cool stuff at Google etc. But for the majority of the people web is the default now. IMO, it will be the same for AI. You can probably survive and hold some legacy jobs in some legacy companies but majority of the people would have moved to AI (and it will be faster than desktop -> web migration). But why even worry about he hype. Leave the hype aside (stop browsing LinkedIn if that helps) and start learning a little bit every day/week.
Post reply on HN