Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 47 posts

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#11
Everyone I know who uses Jira hates it. I don’t think there’s a lack of people ready to point out the things they hate about it.

I have one:

I hate that browsers (except Firefox) won’t let me copy a column of data from a table on a webpage. It’s 2025, most tables are going to be data these days, not layout.

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#12
post #4

MacOS

Related. Apple is turning into Sony with their naming of stuff.

In my house I have Apple branded hardware running:

Mac OS

Mac OS X Server

Mac OS X

OS X

macOS

iOS

iPad OS

tvOS

watchOS

homeOS

audioOS

And now I’ll have the strange honor of having two Macs, one running Mac OS X Server 1.23 and one running macOS 26.

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#13
post #8
post #4

MacOS

Big one, but I've had a few people who admit that it's shit. It's shit but it's just enough to get the job done/get out of your way, As long as you play by its rules

It’s probably the best at that on a fresh stock/retail install on supported hardware of Windows/macOS/Linux (Ubuntu).

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#14
post #12
post #4

MacOS

Related. Apple is turning into Sony with their naming of stuff. In my house I have Apple branded hardware running: Mac OS Mac OS X Server Mac OS X OS X macOS iOS iPad OS tvOS watchOS homeOS audioOS And now I’ll have the strange honor of having two Macs, one running Mac OS X Server 1.23 and one running macOS 26.

Why is naming an OS differently when it is actually a different OS with shared features?

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#15
post #7

Git. Most people have no need for 95 percent of its features and don't have a good mental model of how it works. Just copy and paste commands to get it to work, more or less.

A lot of people have taken on git too, but at this point it’s so entrenched I’m not sure it’s going away anytime soon.

Maybe we’ll have more agentic SCM that auto solves merges and all that fun stuff in the future. But for now we are stuck with a pretty challenging piece of software

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#16
post #12
post #4

MacOS

Related. Apple is turning into Sony with their naming of stuff. In my house I have Apple branded hardware running: Mac OS Mac OS X Server Mac OS X OS X macOS iOS iPad OS tvOS watchOS homeOS audioOS And now I’ll have the strange honor of having two Macs, one running Mac OS X Server 1.23 and one running macOS 26.

What, no A/UX or Mach?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A/UX

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mach_(kernel)

Hey, you should pick up some carrier-grade Cisco routers and switches, and run IOS to tie 'em all together!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cisco_IOS

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#17

JIRA gets a lot of deserved hate but I think nearly all software work tracking systems suffer from the same issue: marketing over promises about velocity and predictions about project delivery timelines. Have we as an industry gotten any better at delivering projects on time? If you have a lot of dysfunction in your organization no software is going to fix that. Or to put it another way, you can’t solve people proble…

Jira is also just terribly built

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#18
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Related. Apple is turning into Sony with their naming of stuff. In my house I have Apple branded hardware running: Mac OS Mac OS X Server Mac OS X OS X macOS iOS iPad OS tvOS watchOS homeOS audioOS And now I’ll have the strange honor of having two Macs, one running Mac OS X Server 1.23 and one running macOS 26.

Why is naming an OS differently when it is actually a different OS with shared features?

What are the differences between OS X El Capitan and macOS Sierra?

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#19

JIRA gets a lot of deserved hate but I think nearly all software work tracking systems suffer from the same issue: marketing over promises about velocity and predictions about project delivery timelines. Have we as an industry gotten any better at delivering projects on time? If you have a lot of dysfunction in your organization no software is going to fix that. Or to put it another way, you can’t solve people proble…

The whole story point thing seems like a scam where some invented currency is used to trick people into not seeing reality.

I’ve never worked on a team where any nontrivial task could be done by any two people in roughly the same amount of time.

Experience, skill, subject area familiarity — everyone is different.

It is utter madness to estimate sprints before assigning the work!

Re: Ask HN: What's the most overengineered tool everyone uses but won't admit sucks?

#20
post #7

Git. Most people have no need for 95 percent of its features and don't have a good mental model of how it works. Just copy and paste commands to get it to work, more or less.

Nobody knows how it works, but we have a good mental model of the high level behavior, and we understand the features we actually use.
Post reply on HN