Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: My company is forcing 1 week sprints. What should I do?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 46 posts

Re: Ask HN: My company is forcing 1 week sprints. What should I do?

#11

Honestly, quit. Anyone still sticking to Scrum is already behind the times on creating an enjoyable work environment. If they are pushing for shorter sprints, they are doubling down on what makes it bad, not what makes it good. I'm all for trying to make a place better before giving up, but this is one of the few leadership decisions that are an exception to my ideals. I would just walk out the door, no hesitation.

What are the alternatives? I would love to hear what works well so I know what to look for.

Re: Ask HN: My company is forcing 1 week sprints. What should I do?

#12
post #5

for me the problem here is an org that debates sprint length for months

Exactly that being a problem within itself. It feels so counter to the philosophy of Agile being “people over process”. If the people are saying they need more prep time why aren’t they listening?

Re: Ask HN: My company is forcing 1 week sprints. What should I do?

#13

Break every story into an obscenely large number of subtasks or tickets and bury the backlog. Make it so large that the amount of time sorting and planning will take most of the week. Stick to the work in each ticket and don't work on the next ones until the sprint is closed.

Agile is extremely gamable.

That said.. just break the tasks down to as small and granular as possible and take on fewer.

Re: Ask HN: My company is forcing 1 week sprints. What should I do?

#15

Realize that when a company is doing Agile at you that everything is made up and the points don't matter. Make your t-shirts smaller and do whatever you were going to do anyway.

They are also forcing time based pointing onto the teams too. 1 point per engineer day. There are other issues with the leadership expecting each engineer to be able to support 5-6 “points” a week but that’s another story.

Re: Ask HN: My company is forcing 1 week sprints. What should I do?

#16
post #15

Realize that when a company is doing Agile at you that everything is made up and the points don't matter. Make your t-shirts smaller and do whatever you were going to do anyway.

They are also forcing time based pointing onto the teams too. 1 point per engineer day. There are other issues with the leadership expecting each engineer to be able to support 5-6 “points” a week but that’s another story.

Still doesn't matter. Make Jira say whatever they want. Or you could enjoy applying endlessly in the currently completely hosed job market.

Re: Ask HN: My company is forcing 1 week sprints. What should I do?

#20
I find 1 week ideal without the overhead.

Remove unnecessary demos or retros. You need the feedback cycle but often 1-3 months is fine, and 2 weeks is only useful for a beginner team.

You do need planning, context, and meetings to discuss the context. We moved these to two days a week where anyone is free to interrupt anyone else and call for a call right now. Nobody expects to be in flow on these days. But as we got better at teamwork, we only needed 0 or 1 days.

We do have 1 week sprints but it's about 90 minutes of sprint related meetings/week on average and that includes stand ups, retros and demos.

Work estimation into the schedule. They're called spikes. Time box them. No commitment is made without the confidence of the spikes. If you don't have confidence by the end of the spike, then something is wrong - the requirements is unclear, code is too opaque, you don't have the data, someone isn't cooperating, etc. These are all very valid outcomes of a spike. Maybe you need to call someone. Maybe you need to refactor.

Post reply on HN