Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do I need T&C for side projects

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do I need T&C for side projects

#11

Post by pmjordan »

kevTheDev wrote: post #9
fendale wrote: post #7

I have been thinking about this very problem myself recently. To add to this question, would it make sense to setup a limited liability company to release a side project under? If something really goes wrong, and some big company or rich individual decides to sue you (for whatever reason), you probably don't want your personal assets to be up for grabs. As I understand it, if you are operating as a limited liability…

I thought about this myself too. But, if this is the case, releasing these side projects suddenly becomes a whole lot less fun (never mind desirable). It even costs more. If there were some kind of trustworthy company, that could act as an umbrella for side projects - i.e. standard T&C / privacy policy let the developer maintain some kind of ownership rights etc. does this sound ridiculous?

Sourceforge? Google code?

Re: Ask HN: Do I need T&C for side projects

#12

Post by kevTheDev »

pmjordan wrote: post #11
kevTheDev wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I thought about this myself too. But, if this is the case, releasing these side projects suddenly becomes a whole lot less fun (never mind desirable). It even costs more. If there were some kind of trustworthy company, that could act as an umbrella for side projects - i.e. standard T&C / privacy policy let the developer maintain some kind of ownership rights etc. does this sound ridiculous?

Sourceforge? Google code?

that's a good point that I had not thought of. But are these not just for open source stuff?

What if I don't want to go the open source route?

Re: Ask HN: Do I need T&C for side projects

#13

Post by Bluem00 »

fendale wrote: post #7

I have been thinking about this very problem myself recently. To add to this question, would it make sense to setup a limited liability company to release a side project under? If something really goes wrong, and some big company or rich individual decides to sue you (for whatever reason), you probably don't want your personal assets to be up for grabs. As I understand it, if you are operating as a limited liability…

You could create an LLC once, and use that for all of your side projects. I did this myself, and it's even kinda fun; my state has good reference material, and the applicable laws are available online.

In Virginia, the requirements boiled down to (1) pick a name that isn't taken, (2) fill out and mail a particular form with a $100 check, (3) keep some paperwork that tracks shareholders - in your case there's just one - and assets.

You probably won't do as good a job as if you were a lawyer, so deciding to do it yourself depends on how seriously you think you need protection.

Re: Ask HN: Do I need T&C for side projects

#14

Post by fendale »

kevTheDev wrote: post #9
fendale wrote: post #7

I have been thinking about this very problem myself recently. To add to this question, would it make sense to setup a limited liability company to release a side project under? If something really goes wrong, and some big company or rich individual decides to sue you (for whatever reason), you probably don't want your personal assets to be up for grabs. As I understand it, if you are operating as a limited liability…

I thought about this myself too. But, if this is the case, releasing these side projects suddenly becomes a whole lot less fun (never mind desirable). It even costs more. If there were some kind of trustworthy company, that could act as an umbrella for side projects - i.e. standard T&C / privacy policy let the developer maintain some kind of ownership rights etc. does this sound ridiculous?

It doesn't sound ridiculous to me, but then I no little of the legalities behind it.

I am in the UK, and as I understand it, its only costs a few £100 to setup a PLC (private limited company) - the main overhead is that you have to post you accounts each year to companies house (which probably means you have to pay an accountant to help you).

It certainly is some hassle, but there are companies that will set it all up for you I believe. If you own a house or have significant savings I would certainly want them protected from some chancer who has decided you have infringed some patent or lost his data to hackers or stolen his idea etc. Defending something like this could be very expensive, so it may be easier to just close up shop and keep your day job!

Re: Ask HN: Do I need T&C for side projects

#15

Post by cchooper »

fendale wrote: post #14
kevTheDev wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I thought about this myself too. But, if this is the case, releasing these side projects suddenly becomes a whole lot less fun (never mind desirable). It even costs more. If there were some kind of trustworthy company, that could act as an umbrella for side projects - i.e. standard T&C / privacy policy let the developer maintain some kind of ownership rights etc. does this sound ridiculous?

It doesn't sound ridiculous to me, but then I no little of the legalities behind it. I am in the UK, and as I understand it, its only costs a few £100 to setup a PLC (private limited company) - the main overhead is that you have to post you accounts each year to companies house (which probably means you have to pay an accountant to help you). It certainly is some hassle, but there are companies that will set it all u…

You mean a private limited company, not a public one (which requires £50,000 capital). The accounts are not difficult if your company doesn't do much, and you can incorporate for under £100.

Re: Ask HN: Do I need T&C for side projects

#17

Post by biohacker42 »

zacharydanger wrote: post #3

WordPress released theirs under creative commons and encourages others to use it. I'd recommend borrowing theirs.

Yep.

However, it is worth thinking about these moments that come ever so often when there's a new and popular platform and a fart app can make you rich.

As soon as people find that out, it is no longer true as there will be thousands if not millions of fart apps.

But how to recognize the moment when fart apps can make you rich, or more aptly the moment just before that?

Re: Ask HN: Do I need T&C for side projects

#19

Post by fendale »

cchooper wrote: post #15
fendale wrote: post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't sound ridiculous to me, but then I no little of the legalities behind it. I am in the UK, and as I understand it, its only costs a few £100 to setup a PLC (private limited company) - the main overhead is that you have to post you accounts each year to companies house (which probably means you have to pay an accountant to help you). It certainly is some hassle, but there are companies that will set it all u…

You mean a private limited company, not a public one (which requires £50,000 capital). The accounts are not difficult if your company doesn't do much, and you can incorporate for under £100.

You are correct - that was a typo. I edited above to correct it. If I ever get my side project moving toward completion, I intend to look into this side of things in the new year.

Re: Ask HN: Do I need T&C for side projects

#20

Post by bobz44 »

jonursenbach wrote: post #8
axod wrote: post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

White snow effect..... on a white background. Genius.

Was thinking the same thing. Tells a lot about the kind of minds that are at Automattic.

Meh... I kinda like it. The white background mutes the effect, makes it subtle and nice.

Or maybe that just condemns me to the same designer hell.

Post reply on HN