Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Are you more likely to use something because it is open source?

news.ycombinator.com

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: Ask HN: Are you more likely to use something because it is open source?

#11

Yes, but only if there is an executable or installer I can save in my downloads folder and use again in a few years. I got burned by WikidPad, an open source personal wiki, which I've been using for a decade or more. The 2012 windows installer still works great, but the source code on Linux is effectively worthless because of breaking changes in the WxPython library[1] it depends on. Initially it seems fine, but only…

Wouldn't NixOS be able to run this, albiet with a steep learning curve?

Re: Ask HN: Are you more likely to use something because it is open source?

#12
Developer tools --- Yes

Business solutions --- No

A few examples --- US payroll. There is no competent open source solution that I am aware of.

Bill payment/money transfer --- Any mistake can be time consuming and costly to correct.

A spreadsheet is not the only tool most businesses need. There is lots of business software and services where open source is unavailable or does not present a practical, trustworthy solution IMO. A common thread that seems to run through a lot of these cases is liability.

Re: Ask HN: Are you more likely to use something because it is open source?

#13
post #11

Yes, but only if there is an executable or installer I can save in my downloads folder and use again in a few years. I got burned by WikidPad, an open source personal wiki, which I've been using for a decade or more. The 2012 windows installer still works great, but the source code on Linux is effectively worthless because of breaking changes in the WxPython library[1] it depends on. Initially it seems fine, but only…

Wouldn't NixOS be able to run this, albiet with a steep learning curve?

I don't think NixOSs library goes backwards to 2012, so its unlikely.

However, that does look like a way to fix the problem with other projects.

Re: Ask HN: Are you more likely to use something because it is open source?

#19
Proprietary software is inherently more favorable for the developer and less favorable for the user. Any way that you look at it, being closed source is an anti-feature that detracts from the utility of the program. So, I never want to use closed source software unless I absolutely have to.
Post reply on HN