Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 95 posts

Re: Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

#11
something in the middle i think.

Like every skill, it depends on what you do with it.

LLMs are controlled by language already, thus far i figured out that you best let the machine define the query and refine it.

My personal take is that AI is not at a point yet where it will take over jobs in tech, but we are already at a point where someone with LLM skills is more efficient that someone who is not.

Re: Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

#13
Lot's of cynical answers.

I do think prompt engineering is a new industry, and your experience (if you actually good) will translate will into future jobs.

In my opinion it has to be combined with engineering to be competitive in a commercial sense.

Re: Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

#14
You'll be fine as long as it isn't your main skill. It should be just one of many things in a toolbelt. This is because as LLMs get more accessible, the importance of prompt engineering should fade away into just another chore.

Re: Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

#15
Being able to break down exploratory questions or define work to be done and communicating that clearly is 80% of general consulting.

Sure, you're aligning your approach to a machine, but it's not completely dissimilar.

I struggle with delegation in general, even taking the time to delegate to LLMs, mostly because I work faster intuitively and expressing myself clearly just takes longer. With the benefits of semi-repeatable results, personally, I've found the most benefit working with GPT3 & 4 over the last 6 months has been getting better and more conscious in describing what I'm after.

Re: Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

#16
I think one can do an analogy with search engines.

I noticed that a lot of people are terrible with search engines. They would carefully try to craft a combination of keywords that they hope will answer their problem.

I have pretty much always been able to find the answers I need quickly, by using a few ideas I see not that many around me use, such as trying to imagine in what context the answer might be answered (what would be the title of a blog or forum post about it, etc), as well as searching for the exact error message if I got one etc.

Now, search engines have gotten a lot better over the last say 5-10 years, so this skill isn't as important anymore, but I remember how the ability to find things quickly was a real productivity booster.

I think something similar might happen with LLMs.

You will have a (probably much bigger) productivity boost by being great at leveraging them.

With time, the user interfacing tooling and general knowledge of them will get much better, so the relative benefit you have will grow smaller, but it will for sure always be useful to know how to use them well.

My 5c.

Re: Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

#17
post #5

Isn’t prompt engineering basically writing tests around a prompt and fiddling with it till you have as many passing tests as possible? It’s basically software engineering around a black box.

Yes, but over time you begin to intuitively understand how the box thinks/works. It's like being a psychologist? Something like that.

Re: Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

#18
Generally speaking, knowledge is never useless. The nature of its use changes over time

I think this is similar to the "skill" of "googling" that became important about 2 decades ago. You learn how to search effectively and it improved your programming skills. This was primitive prompt engineering. If LLMs and the chat style interfaces last, this will continue to be useful.

Re: Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

#19
What is there to it other than knowing how to write and ask questions? I also get the desired results out of LLM models but I would hardly call it a skill (well, maybe on par with knowing how to "Google" stuff). Are there people who actually struggle with this?

Re: Ask HN: I learned useless skill of prompt engineering, how relevant will it be?

#20
On this I agree w/ David Foster Wallace - see https://machines.kfitz.info/dfwwiki/index.php%3Ftitle=Anothe...

TL;DR: by the time your skill isn’t useful, the whole landscape of modern will be changing so much that it’s kinda a moot point. Like losing your job during an apocalypse

Post reply on HN