Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do you manage your personal finances?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 48 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your personal finances?

#11
I use Lunchmoney (https://lunchmoney.app/) and have enjoyed it for the past year. It takes a rules based approach to transaction management and features your usual budget and net worth tracking. It also has a pretty good API you can use to further integrate transactions with other systems (I’ve done some work to forward some transactions to a Notion Database).

If you want a referral link: https://lunchmoney.app/?refer=3xlamc3c

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your personal finances?

#14

I use Copilot ( https://copilot.money ) easily the best in the game. Great UX, native app on IOS and Mac and can connect from mmy credit cards to my stocks (e.g. robinhood) and even crypto

I tried this recently after years of using YNAB. The UX is truly great, but it really doesn’t function as a budgeting app in the way that YNAB does. It’s closer to Mint and I ended up canceling after a week of the trial. A shame because it is very cool looking.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your personal finances?

#15
I’m a huge fan of Lunch Money. It’s made by a small team that truly understands the feature-set needed for a full personal finance app. I’ve been on it for 4 years and couldn’t imagine using anything else.

Here’s my referral code if you’re interested: https://lunchmoney.app/?refer=igqb31gn

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your personal finances?

#16
I use moneydance and log all transactions. I can report on anything, my data file is perpetual, and there’s no monthly fee.

I used to use YNAB and tried Mint, but I don’t want to pay a monthly fee. YNAB is cheap ($5/month) but it was just a spreadsheet with categories and I expect I’ll need this info forever so $60/year x 50 years adds up.

I have 13 years of data and it’s useful for taxes, business disputes, planning, long term budgeting, and backup/restore.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your personal finances?

#17
Disclaimer: I used to work here.

I'm from India and I use Fold¹ for this. They make money tracking easier using the account aggregator framework², which is provided by an RBI³ regulated entity. They are currently in invite-only for both iOS (beta) and Android (alpha).

They are very feature-rich and implement those with utmost care to design, UX and engineering. The team is small and everyone is committed to the goal of making finance easier and seen. All amazing people!

Highly recommended for people in India.

1: https://fold.money

2. https://sahamati.org.in/what-is-account-aggregator/

3: Reserve Bank of India

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your personal finances?

#18
For anyone who likes spreadsheets but wishes the boring data input bits were a little more automated, check out: https://www.tillerhq.com

Imagine a Google sheet where 1 tab pulls in all your transactions from each of your banks / credit cards / investment accounts and the other tabs are... Whatever you can imagine.

I am a huge fan, after I graduated from mint.com I've never looked back after finding Tiller.

You can customize to your hearts content (it's Google Sheets, after all), plus they have handy template sheets to get started with.

I personally have sheets to track my monthly spending (by category), my networth, my checking account balance vs sum of all credit card bills, my progress on credit card signup bonus minimum spend challenges are more.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your personal finances?

#19
I don't. I tried YNAB for a long time, but it just got too stressful.

I have been thinking, if I were to create a budget tracker, my hot take would be to make an imperfect one, aimed at people who don't need to budget "to survive" and so can make a mistake, overspend and then reign it in next month.

This software would just track the major source of discretionary spend: your credit card, and auto allocate to buckets using AI mostly, and maybe email you an alert if overspending (like the battery alerts from Ring!).

Any non credit-card account tends to be used for essentials like bills, mortgage and so on. Since I am not going to not pay those, it doesn't matter.

The idea is to say "can spend $10,000/m on credit card" or whatever, and go from there.

MVP: download credit card CSV, run some local python code to auto allocate and fire off email if there is an issue (there was an API to email thing posted on HN a while back).

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your personal finances?

#20

I don't. I tried YNAB for a long time, but it just got too stressful. I have been thinking, if I were to create a budget tracker, my hot take would be to make an imperfect one, aimed at people who don't need to budget "to survive" and so can make a mistake, overspend and then reign it in next month. This software would just track the major source of discretionary spend: your credit card, and auto allocate to buckets…

i like this idea. I would use something like this but it would need to present me with a way to sort into two buckets: personal spend and LLC spend. I would instantly stop paying quickbooks the $15/mo for that app.

I feel there are many use cases for an app that can just regularly pull financial transactions, perform a function on them and spit out an email on a regular basis or on some kind of a trigger.

I wrote a SaaS tool for letting me know when a stock sale would trigger a wash sale event for tax purposes. I host it at https://washsaleadvisor.com. It uses plaid to pull the trade transactions from most bank APIs and sends me a daily email with useful info. The last feature I added was refactoring the wash sale functionality into WASM functions and then put a code editor in the dashboard. Anyone who signs up could theoretically turn "wash sale advisor" into basically any operation that iterates through transactions and renders an email and sends via sendgrid.

Post reply on HN