Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: GPT4 Broke Me

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 183 posts

Re: Ask HN: GPT4 Broke Me

#11

Don't wanna make you feel worse but a friend of mine and nearly 20% of the company got fired a few days ago. CEO's justification? "We don't need you anymore, we will compensate your loss with chat-gpt & co. It's nothing personal, just business". To this day I can't tell whenever CEO's reasons were just outright lies, or if he genuinely thinks he can replace a fifth of his workplace just like that.

Most likely outright lies. Lots of companies are laying people off to maintain profitability, this particular CEO probably doesn't want to admit that the company would have financial problems otherwise.

Re: Ask HN: GPT4 Broke Me

#12
I have been already working nearly at a burn-out level for many years to reach this comp.

If you have the willpower to do that I wouldn't worry that much. Maybe use the extra productivity ChatGPT gives you to learn some skills that LLM-AIs will take a long, long time to learn if ever: specialization. Industrial programming, scientific programming, etc. One of the reasons I'm not worried about AI is that I work with machines so specialized there's maybe half a dozen people on the planet with my skillset and almost none of it exists on the internet at all.

Re: Ask HN: GPT4 Broke Me

#13
The more I use GPT, the less I'm worried. It is a tool, and a good one, but not a replacement for the thought required to design an app that will function, scale, and have good UX to result in a marketable product. So use it and enjoy its benefits while letting it help you perform even better.

As far as everything else you've said... oof, you need a break. You seem focused on money and ego. Maybe it is time to simplify a bit, explore what else the world has to offer. Worry less about whether anyone else can do your job and more about whether or not you are enjoying your life. Make changes, have some fun. If you don't want a mortgage but have multiples of the deposit needed, buy a smaller, simpler place with cash. Then you don't have rent or a mortgage.

Re: Ask HN: GPT4 Broke Me

#14
If you're in top 5% of TC, you're not in danger for the foreseeable future, GPT-4 will make expertise more valuable, not less. And it's the middle brackets that will have to fight to keep their jobs against the low-skilled workers that have now been elevated to average

Re: Ask HN: GPT4 Broke Me

#17
post #6

Your fears will manifest in reality. Just stop being afraid.

Your statement can have multiple interpretations. I assume you mean this one: Your fear will be a self-fulfilling prophecy; to prevent that, stop being afraid?

Of course that's like telling someone who is depressed, to "just be happy".

Re: Ask HN: GPT4 Broke Me

#18
You're among the first people I've encountered with both experience in writing your own software and prompting an LLM to do it. I have a few questions for you (maybe the answers will make you feel better, or maybe they'll make you feel worse)

- when the code the model spat out was wrong, how did you fix it? Did you identify it was wrong before you ran it?

- what level of complexity was there in the code, in terms of "business logic" or complexity of the requirements you fed into it?

I ask these two questions because I am not sure an AI will get to the level of experience you have in the near future in _generating_ complex applications, let alone being able to reflect on why its own creations are wrong, fixing them, deploying some output, and then explaining the changes?

A human is going to be in the loop in these cases for a long time, and I'm assuming part or all of your decades of experience has been spent understanding quite how poor people are at explaining their requirements. What if you thought of generative AI as a tool you can learn to utilise to do your job more effectively?

Re: Ask HN: GPT4 Broke Me

#20
My dad ran a local dental lab for 30+ years, making crowns and bridges for local dentists.

Over the course of a few years, dentists began using 3D scanners to digitally scan patient impressions, which allowed them to email the scans to my dad's dental lab (previously he'd have to drive to each dentist and pick it up in person).

Then, 1-2 years later, they started emailing the 3D scan to a company in China who would do the same work as my dad, and then mail back the finished product directly to the dentist from China. And of course the Chinese dental labs did this at half the price my dad was charging.

He went out of business and ended up retiring early at 55. The "retiring early" explanation was a great one, but the real reason he retired was innovation hit his industry and made it easy for dentists to outsource crown/bridge manufacturing to China. He works for a property maintenance company now for $20/hr, mostly as a way to fill his time (he's doing fine financially).

Most of the comments here are telling you that you'll be ok, and I hope you will be. But the reality is innovation causes disruption in many fields/industries. If you're in the path of disruption, you have to be willing to quickly adapt and learn to live alongside it rather than fight it.

Also remember you're not alone. Technology has been displacing jobs for decades. Life is about learning and adapting. As long as you commit to adapting quickly, learning new skills as necessary and being open to different types of jobs, you should be fine.

Post reply on HN