Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why are students taking handwritten notes? Typing is much more efficient

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 20 posts

Re: Ask HN: Why are students taking handwritten notes? Typing is much more efficient

#11

It depends on the topic. Math notation is a 2D horrible domain specific mess, and it's much faster to draw it in 2D than forcing it into a 1D symbol chain. (Bonus point for Greek letters or $\weird$ symbols.)

I remember doing a page of notes involving nu, and then v got involved! I put little tails on the nus after that.

Re: Ask HN: Why are students taking handwritten notes? Typing is much more efficient

#13
Efficient for what, though? It's certainly faster for rote recording of information, but I learn complex information in less time when I hand-write it out. Also, you have to be really well-practiced in LaTeX math packages to type arbitrary math well. Hand-writing math is much more straightforward with limited learning time.

Re: Ask HN: Why are students taking handwritten notes? Typing is much more efficient

#14
post #12

Why at all? If you want to record the lecture, use photo, video, audio recording.

- Spending 15 minutes to read your notes takes less time than re-watching 1+ hours of lectures - Writing things down in your own words makes concepts easier to understand - Not everything is in the textbook, sometimes lecturers provide key insights that will be lost if not written down

Re: Ask HN: Why are students taking handwritten notes? Typing is much more efficient

#18

I disagree and am not sure what you mean by "efficient". I have never liked typing notes, be it in school or at work. Handwriting flows much better for me and I also find reading through notes, or just finding them, on paper easier. I still usually show up at meetings with only a notebook and a pen... (added bonus: no-one asks me to connect to Teams/whatnot because they have a problem)

I think by ""efficiency" OP means that WPM is typically faster when typing vs. handwriting. That's certainly true for me.

Re: Ask HN: Why are students taking handwritten notes? Typing is much more efficient

#20

It depends on the topic. Math notation is a 2D horrible domain specific mess, and it's much faster to draw it in 2D than forcing it into a 1D symbol chain. (Bonus point for Greek letters or $\weird$ symbols.)

I remember doing a page of notes involving nu, and then v got involved! I put little tails on the nus after that.

When I have to write "U" and "V" by hand in a math text, my "V" looks almost like a "Y".
Post reply on HN