Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is there any way to fix online dating?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 21 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is there any way to fix online dating?

#11

You can't really fix online dating because you can't really change human nature. Men want what they want and women want what they want and nothing changes that. You can of course meet somebody decent online with enough persistence, especially in a big city with a constant pool of new people, but the way things work online is bad for almost everybody except the very best looking men, who are able to use these apps to…

"Men want what they want and women want what they want and nothing changes that."

Well, societal/cultural pressures and customs highly shape this. One could use this knowledge to select candidates from specific bagrounds that are likely to share values.

Re: Ask HN: Is there any way to fix online dating?

#14
post #12

"Is there any way to fix online dating?" What specifically do you think is broken about it?

My guess is that there's waaaay more men on online dating platforms than women

The numbers I saw for tinder are about 2:1 men:women. But how is this manifest as a problem? Men are typically the ones initiating advances regardless of online or offline, so I would expect to see higher participation rates in both spaces with relatively lower success rates compared to women.

To "fix" this, is something requiring gender parity in selection agency/opportunity. This is far beyond an online dating thing and requires deep societal changes. Even though Bumble has taken some steps to change the initiation process and still have a similar ratio.

Re: Ask HN: Is there any way to fix online dating?

#15
post #5
post #3

I think it might be worth specifying what you feel needs to be fixed exactly. I can think of many problems with both online and offline dating, but I guess you have something specific in mind? I met my boyfriend of 4 years through an app, and in general it was a pretty smooth process in my admittedly limited experience.

> my boyfriend Would it be safe to assume you are either a woman, or a gay man? I am in my late 30s, of average attractiveness, and below-average suaveness. If I open Grindr in a large city and create a profile with one of my cuter selfies, I get so many messages I literally would not be able to reply to all of them. From what I've pieced together, that is not what would happen to the heterosexual version of me. Many…

Yes, a woman.

I see what you mean. I tried out a few dating apps and it was surprising how many messages were coming in from different directions. I just didn't have the time or energy to talk to all these people at once. I wasn't swiping on many people at the same time in the first place, but even juggling 2 or 3 conversations would be too much sometimes (especially if I was already having one really interesting chat with someone else, that kind of got all my attention). This resulted in some contacts being ignored, especially if all I got from them was a "Hey" or something, which unfortunately only contributes to the demoralizing aspect of not being replied to.

One app where I didn't feel that pressure was Bumble. At least at the time the rule was that on Bumble, women had to message first (not sure if it still works like that?) I liked that because it created a slower pace - I was able to swipe on people whose profiles I liked, but then take more time to initiate the conversation once matches came in. That also made me more selective about who I matched with; knowing I'd have to approach them, I'd look for profiles that had some especially interesting or unique information for me to use for an opener (because I didn't want to be one of those people just sending "hey").

So that "I message first" aspect was what made me prefer Bumble specifically. Less potential bombardment seemed to create a more slow-paced, thoughtful, selective experience.

I ended up only going on 4 dates from my dating app experimentation, one of whom became my current boyfriend. By "smooth process" in my previous reply I suppose I was mostly thinking about this part. I went into it because I hadn't really dated before. I mostly just wanted to meet interesting people and see what it's like to actually go on a date, not so much for a relationship. There are so many horror stories related to safety, meeting jerks, meeting people who didn't look like their profiles, etc. Everyone I met was luckily a really decent guy and I had no bad dates, even if it didn't go anywhere.

Re: Ask HN: Is there any way to fix online dating?

#17
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> my boyfriend Would it be safe to assume you are either a woman, or a gay man? I am in my late 30s, of average attractiveness, and below-average suaveness. If I open Grindr in a large city and create a profile with one of my cuter selfies, I get so many messages I literally would not be able to reply to all of them. From what I've pieced together, that is not what would happen to the heterosexual version of me. Many…

Yes, a woman. I see what you mean. I tried out a few dating apps and it was surprising how many messages were coming in from different directions. I just didn't have the time or energy to talk to all these people at once. I wasn't swiping on many people at the same time in the first place, but even juggling 2 or 3 conversations would be too much sometimes (especially if I was already having one really interesting cha…

I think the stark contrast of a guys matches/inbox to a girls matches/inbox is whats demoralising to most guys. I once read an apt expression for this where the men are thirsty in a desert and the women are thirsty in an ocean. I have all but given up on online dating and simply socialize in person. If I meet someone I like, I would just ask them out. If it works out great. if not hopefully I made the other person feel better about themselves.

Re: Ask HN: Is there any way to fix online dating?

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, a woman. I see what you mean. I tried out a few dating apps and it was surprising how many messages were coming in from different directions. I just didn't have the time or energy to talk to all these people at once. I wasn't swiping on many people at the same time in the first place, but even juggling 2 or 3 conversations would be too much sometimes (especially if I was already having one really interesting cha…

I think the stark contrast of a guys matches/inbox to a girls matches/inbox is whats demoralising to most guys. I once read an apt expression for this where the men are thirsty in a desert and the women are thirsty in an ocean. I have all but given up on online dating and simply socialize in person. If I meet someone I like, I would just ask them out. If it works out great. if not hopefully I made the other person fe…

Heh, I'm guessing the expression used a large body of water that isn't actually drinkable on purpose? That does indeed sound apt from both sides!

I think asking people out in person sounds like the ideal approach honestly.

Post reply on HN