Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 136 posts

Re: Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

#11
I think this is a perception issue on your part. You’ve got what appears to be a misguided idea of what a “correct” programmer is.

There’s a ton of programmers that don’t tinker on their own time. Especially in university. Socializing and being a healthy, well-rounded human is probably a more valuable use of his time.

Re: Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

#12
I’m a college CS teacher. I would say if he were not doing well in his classes, then it might be a red flag. If it’s not an academic interest, a talent, nor a hobby, then it’s not a good fit. But since he is doing well, let him be, unless you talk to him and find out he’s doing it for the wrong reasons.

Re: Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

#13
Software development is just one discipline in CS. This is probably an indication that he doesn’t enjoy writing software, which is fine. What does he like in CS? Which courses did he enjoy? Maybe he can get an internship, take courses, or go to grad school, to develop that interest.

Re: Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

#14
> my thought is for him to change majors if tinkering doesn't come naturally

I wouldn't worry about that. Not everyone that studies CS loves programming, a lot do it because it's a way to have a good career, and that's fine.

> He had a few classes in js and C++ and did very well, but its not something he continues to do on his own.

You have to give a bit more details about how much he writes code and his general situation (which year, classes, etc.).

One thing that is a guarantee, is that people that do their own projects on top of school and get internships will be light-years ahead of someone that does neither, in terms of skills.

From my personal experience, I did a class with people in their last semesters that were literally unable to write any code beyond the basic exercices they had seen in class. They had basically never written and ran an actual project, and it was obvious that they wouldn't have a good time getting a job.

Re: Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

#16
Having a CS degree, doesn't mean you have to code. Some of the best product managers or designers I've worked with have a CS background.

Also change to what? Granted I went to a top school, but I remember people with engineering or CS degrees even getting finance jobs, etc... over other majors.

Re: Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

#17

College is the best time in his life to socialize and build relationships that last a lifetime. Let him do his thing. If his grades are fine why are you worried? For a fresh out of college grad new hire/interview they're going to care much more about grades and school prestige than hobbies or side projects. At least for the major FAANG companies. Something like "deans list BS computer science from Berkeley" or "maste…

> For a fresh out of college grad new hire/interview they're going to care much more about grades and school prestige than hobbies or side projects.

In my experience it is exactly opposite of that. Especially for FAANG companies.

Re: Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

#18
If he’s happy and successful, I think he’s fine. In fact, perhaps better then fine.

Plenty of new CS grads go straight into Product/Program Management, and there are plenty of other roles such as consulting and sales that really value being able to combine people skills with technical skills. Having been in that world, the right combo of people skills and technical knowledge is both hard to find and remunerative.

Re: Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

#19
There's a lot here to unpack, but I don't believe this is a red flag. CS is not a "gimme" major. If he's continuing to pursue it and the college isn't weeding him out, then he's clearly doing alright and has enough enthusiasm for the major. Let him continue.

On a more personal note, I don't believe this is any of your business. Your son is a grown adult. Perhaps he's getting a degree on your dime, but he needs to make his own choices in his education, and you aren't living his experience. You're very focused on "tinkering" as a tell for whether he's in the right degree, but only he can know if he's happy in his major.

My wife had a father who was very involved in her choice of majors, and it left her with anxiety and a sense that her college years were wasted. She was left feeling like getting his approval was more important than reasoning through her own decisions. The best thing you can probably do for him long term is let him make decisions, even if you think they're wrong.

Re: Ask HN: Son is major in CS, but doesn't code. Red flag?

#20
I started college more than 20 years ago. I had an internship during school and I've been a professional software engineer since I graduated. I get nothing but great performance reviews and I've naturally risen to leadership/mentoring position in every job I've ever had.

I've never "tinkered" or written code outside school or work. Ever. Not before college, nor after.

It's also incredibly weird you're complaining your son is socializing. Socializing is normal and healthy, spending all your free time working is not.

Post reply on HN