Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 114 posts

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#11
Not yet. Feel like I should, but the pain isn't quite enough yet to make me do it. I like heroku a lot when it's working, nothing else I've compared has the DX features I want (although render is getting close. I wish it had better command line tooling, and ability to run tasks on one-off 'run' machines).

(I develop a pretty small-scale app for a non-profit)

So, no, not yet. But I am worried I may regret it.

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#12
Yes. No new projects there (using Fly.io instead as it provides a similar, simple DX but even better and cheaper too unless you are heavily Elements dependent) but am being somewhat slow to actually move things off.. The stack deprecations will probably push me to do it before long though.

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#13
post #3

3 years ago, I tried Heroku and was quite impressed by it. Although the price is prohibitive for a hobby project that needed resources but wasn't generating any revenue, I had to start seeking other options. Ended up developing my own Heroku but focused on Django deployments. Three years later, it works like a charm and has many happy folks who thank me for making it. Meet Appliku: https://appliku.com

My main issue is the free redis and cheap postgres instances they provide for my low-traffic app.

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#14
We plan to, but not quite yet. The only thing keeping us on Heroku is the "point in time restore" for Postgres, once another platform (such as Render) has that we will probably make the switch.

Having had to use the point in time restore feature before, it's indispensable.

Just taken a look at Appliku as others have mentioned it (we are a Django app), that on DigitalOcean with their managed Postgres could be a strong option.

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#17

Yes. No new projects there (using Fly.io instead as it provides a similar, simple DX but even better and cheaper too unless you are heavily Elements dependent) but am being somewhat slow to actually move things off.. The stack deprecations will probably push me to do it before long though.

Are you Peter Cooper from CooperPress?

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#18
post #13
post #3

3 years ago, I tried Heroku and was quite impressed by it. Although the price is prohibitive for a hobby project that needed resources but wasn't generating any revenue, I had to start seeking other options. Ended up developing my own Heroku but focused on Django deployments. Three years later, it works like a charm and has many happy folks who thank me for making it. Meet Appliku: https://appliku.com

My main issue is the free redis and cheap postgres instances they provide for my low-traffic app.

You can get built databases deployed with Appliku as well. No reason to go broke on a small side project

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#19
All these "big clouds" are a risk when it comes to global outages. Heroku, Cloudflare, AWS... etc. Using indy or smaller developer focussed clouds can mitigate this problem, but those come with other risks for sure. I think every tech decision makers (CTOs, architects, lead engineers...) need to know at least some of these tools and give them a try to keep a list of plan-Bs at hand.

Re: Ask HN: Are you leaving Heroku?

#20
Had a hobby project on heroku that I've moved to render.com pretty painlessly. It's a simple rust (actix + sqlite) project. I now have a go (gin + sqlite) project that is intended to replace the rust project that I also plan to set up on render. Overall it's been incredibly pleasant & I've had no issues.

To be clear though, these are very small/cheap projects between friends so I haven't needed to evaluate costs (beyond a few bucks a month) and I don't have any complex requirements beyond avoiding docker as much as possible.

Post reply on HN