Now, within teams, I can definitely see the use - particularly if it also picked up tasks from bug trackers, tools like Remember the Milk, etc. But maybe as a Rapportive-style dashboard (and at-a-glance team page) rather than a signature - so when I email my colleague, it warns me that he's late on 3 tasks and has a lot of unread email.
Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
11–20 of 84 posts
Re: Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
#12I get the feeling that this is a MVP or feature test for something bigger. Because truth be told, I don't see why people would care about someone's inbox health, especially since people use their Gmail account as a garbage dump+todo list+backup. I've seen inboxes with THOUSANDS of unread email and most people I know don't archive anything at all.
This is me, for years.
Re: Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
#13Re: Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
#14You can probably also safely reduce the number of fonts you're using.
Re: Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
#15Re: Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
#16I get the feeling that this is a MVP or feature test for something bigger. Because truth be told, I don't see why people would care about someone's inbox health, especially since people use their Gmail account as a garbage dump+todo list+backup. I've seen inboxes with THOUSANDS of unread email and most people I know don't archive anything at all.
I've seen inboxes with THOUSANDS of unread email This is me, for years.
Re: Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
#172 Suggestions: 1. A way to control which emails this gets attached to. If I'm emailing a client, I don't want them to ever feel I'm too busy to be contacted. 2. Allow for other measurements. In the same way most phones have a DND button, I would be great to have a manual override for days I'm busy. Also for me it would make more sense to measure how busy my calendar is vs my inbox.
Additional variation: It might be interesting to post an average response time to expect vs ples/tol/unb.
Re: Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
#18I get the feeling that this is a MVP or feature test for something bigger. Because truth be told, I don't see why people would care about someone's inbox health, especially since people use their Gmail account as a garbage dump+todo list+backup. I've seen inboxes with THOUSANDS of unread email and most people I know don't archive anything at all.
I've seen inboxes with THOUSANDS of unread email This is me, for years.
Re: Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
#19I think this is really clever, I love it! 2 Suggestions: 1. A way to control which emails this gets attached to. If I'm emailing a client, I don't want them to ever feel I'm too busy to be contacted. 2. Allow for other measurements. In the same way most phones have a DND button, I would be great to have a manual override for days I'm busy. Also for me it would make more sense to measure how busy my calendar is vs my…
Re: Ask HN: Please review my site "Smoke Signal"
#20The site looks very nice, and the idea looks interesting. Another small typo: "Also until we get create a proper login system". How do you determine what are "healthy" and "unhealthy" amounts of email? If I ignore a bunch of mailing-list type email in my inbox by just glancing at the title, I may have hundreds of "unread" messages but that doesn't mean I'm totally flooded with email. Thoughts?
Great point. In future versions we may only ping your Priority Inbox, instead of everything. Would that be a more accurate reflection of your "busyness"?
Having filters: Most users may use Inbox as the fall through location for emails. But a lot use filters as a way to move stuff out of the inbox to specific folders as a means to prioritize responses.
eg. My wife, business partner etc, might make it to folder important, my 2nd level priority emails go someplace else, mailing lists elsewhere and so on.
Inbox is whats left and is least priority. How do you account for whats important. What if I don't use priority inbox? What happens when I don't read the email in my inbox at all since it isn't critical to my day to day function.
This also doesn't account for a mail client use or mail forwarding from Google. Since Gmail provides a way to use a mail client or forward mail options, it means that I might read mail on my client but not report back to gmail or just read all the mail from another account.
Anyway, some thoughts to ponder over. May not be a mainstream problem since most users might not be doing what I suggested.