Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: If you're in a 100% remote role, should you turn your camera on?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 38 posts

Re: Ask HN: If you're in a 100% remote role, should you turn your camera on?

#11
Personally, for weekly all-hands meetings, I turn camera on. It's my own way of "being there" or being "visually present" at least once each week.

For most other chats, or daily stand ups, camera off. But, on that matter, I would encourage you to have a decent photo in lieu of the default user avatar.

Re: Ask HN: If you're in a 100% remote role, should you turn your camera on?

#12
I feel it is something that people need to decide for themselves, and everyone else should respect their decision. There are non-verbal cues that can be gained from cameras if you are in a small group. But there is no point on large groups. And we rarely turned them on for one-on-one calls.

The best approach is just to talk about it with your team, and choose your own culture.

Re: Ask HN: If you're in a 100% remote role, should you turn your camera on?

#13
My team, and myself, turn it on for conversations where everyone is participating. So a small team huddle (3-5 people) has cameras on. Bunch of slides and a bigger audience? Cameras off. In reality, it is dictated by your team or organization culture.

Re: Ask HN: If you're in a 100% remote role, should you turn your camera on?

#15
post #9

Much of communication is non-verbal. Why not increase the bandwidth of person-to-person communication?

This is commonly cited, but I wonder if anybody has studied how much communication happens by voice and screenshare, and whether there's a net loss compared to face-to-face.

I get all my work communication done through voice and shared files. Am I missing information that would otherwise be encoded in implicit facial expressions? Or in the absence of faces, is that being conveyed to me anyway, through voice and explicit verbal means?

Re: Ask HN: If you're in a 100% remote role, should you turn your camera on?

#16

I don't like being on camera and I'd wager many (if not most) people don't. We do it because we have to, not because we want to. And I don't have to because I don't work with clients or take roles in which me being on camera for more than 5 minutes during the entire duration of the role is a requirement. Between voice and screen sharing, we can handle all business without monitoring each other's 2-dimensional faces.

Perhaps I'm vain, but I like to be on the camera during meetings. It's that one little extra iota of personalization. So I'm speaking to my team's faces, and vice versa, instead of just speaking to coloured circles with letters in them.

I don't begrudge others to have their cameras on, but if someone else has it on, I'll turn mine on.

Re: Ask HN: If you're in a 100% remote role, should you turn your camera on?

#17
I go along with what the other people are doing. If most of them have cameras on, that's what I do to - if they're off, I'm off too. I'm non-judgmental about anyone's preferences one way or the other and accept people for who they are. Times that I tend to turn my camera on, regardless of what anyone else is doing is when I meet a person for the first time or need to interact with customers or other organizations outside of where I'm working.

Re: Ask HN: If you're in a 100% remote role, should you turn your camera on?

#19
It can help with creating the “I’m a person not an entity on a computer” perception. I went remote only with Covid and I occasionally turn my camera on but I’m well familiar with my team, we meet up and have lunch occasionally, so they know me well. If you’re a newer addition I’d say it’s a good idea but you don’t really need to feel compelled after that point unless you want to.

Re: Ask HN: If you're in a 100% remote role, should you turn your camera on?

#20
I like being on camera in fact I run it often when I am at the office alone to use as a mirror because otherwise my hair might be poofed up with static electricity and then I go out and scare people without trying.

My trouble is that webcams don’t last long for me, my laptops have defective USB 3.0 ports. I think someday I want to set up a mini tv studio at home but never get around to it.

Post reply on HN