Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do solo devs get feedback on their code?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 29 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do solo devs get feedback on their code?

#11
I have been in this position a few times and I recommend using static analysis and linters e.g FindBugs for Java, CppCheck for C++.

Personally I only use a debugger when there are bugs, but I know some people who debug the code when they are developing to check that it is doing what they want.

Re: Ask HN: How do solo devs get feedback on their code?

#12
post #7

By running the code. Let's say the code is bad. The software will let you know if there's a logical error. The software will be hard to maintain when you want to update it, The software will be hard to use when users try it. There's no feedback like the one the software gives. The proof is in the pudding. If you're new to software and a junior developer, then outside feedback is much needed, but once you're experienc…

Not by a long shot! How is this going to teach you new patterns and practices, better ways of coding and structuring your code? At best this will find you easy to detect bugs.

Re: Ask HN: How do solo devs get feedback on their code?

#13
post #7

By running the code. Let's say the code is bad. The software will let you know if there's a logical error. The software will be hard to maintain when you want to update it, The software will be hard to use when users try it. There's no feedback like the one the software gives. The proof is in the pudding. If you're new to software and a junior developer, then outside feedback is much needed, but once you're experienc…

The most useful feedback will come from customers. If you have a bug or are missing a feature they will tell you. What is harder is dealing with architectural issues but I'm not convinced they are that easy to avoid in a team environment either.

> If you have a bug or are missing a feature they will tell you

Reporting a bug takes work. Doing it clearly takes more work. Some percentage of people will do work for free. Relying on it is a choice with tradeoffs.

Re: Ask HN: How do solo devs get feedback on their code?

#14
We don't. Unfortunately this is one of my problems for been solo developer. I also don't have anyone to discuss the features and the architect decisions i need to take.

I do have some developer friends to talk to when i need to get it out and once in a while i team up with one of them to create something. That way I learn new things and get some feedback but nothing close to what i had back then when i was working in a company.

Re: Ask HN: How do solo devs get feedback on their code?

#16
I have found that the best way to get feedback on anything code related is to draw it with a diagraming tool with as much detail is possible. Label each part of the diagram in some logical order and then include a brief description of each step. Posting a labeled diagram with a repo gets 10x engagement and feedback compared to just posting a link in my experience. My favorite diagramming tool is diagrams.net

Re: Ask HN: How do solo devs get feedback on their code?

#17
Open-source projects allow you to get feedback and hopefully contributions to a code base. You need to like open-source and have other people want to contribute to your project.

If you don't want to do that, you most likely need to pay consultants to review the code.

Re: Ask HN: How do solo devs get feedback on their code?

#20

Write a blog post about: 1. Your problem 2. The solution you chose 3. Your strong belief your solution is the best, and that no one can possibly find any fault in it. Then post it to HN and wait for people to school you :)

This is the correct answer.

Peoples compulsion to point out other peoples flaws is far greater than their drive to help.

Otherwise post to any forum with a female-sounding name. Works as well.

Post reply on HN