Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Does anyone else feel like staying off HN for a bit?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 43 posts

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone else feel like staying off HN for a bit?

#11

One of the saddest things on here in my opinion is how vehemently people hate China. No critical thinking ability at all.

What part of “violation of human rights” or “concentration camps” or “disappearing business people” requires more critical thinking? Nazi Germany did amazing things in many fields (just skipped to the end here).

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone else feel like staying off HN for a bit?

#12

If anyone did, you probably won't be able to reach them this way. They wouldn't be here.

Not necessarily, I frequently feel like quitting soda, yet come lunch time the fridge door opens and the Coke goes into my stomach.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone else feel like staying off HN for a bit?

#13
HN has always had rather poor quality of discussion around politics (though of course it's still way better than Facebook or Twitter, not to mention Parler!). It's not really about Trump or about what has transpired during the past week; that's just the symptom.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone else feel like staying off HN for a bit?

#14
post #3

Seems you always hated this place: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25044791

If always is 2 months, you comment only confirms the curtness that has increased. I agree with OP that the quality on HN has decreased recently, both stories and comments. This has been a progression over several years from my perspective.

OP’s account is 3 months old.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone else feel like staying off HN for a bit?

#15

If anyone did, you probably won't be able to reach them this way. They wouldn't be here.

Not necessarily, I frequently feel like quitting soda, yet come lunch time the fridge door opens and the Coke goes into my stomach.

Ok, I guess I should have clarified I was only referring to the ones that were serious about it.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone else feel like staying off HN for a bit?

#16
post #7

This whole thing reminds of the 4 stages of change: - denial: our capitalistic democratic ways work: we're not China! - resistance: oh no, FAANG control our lives, we must fight back! - exploration: what if mastodon blockchain webRTC could save us? - acceptance: something must be done, X is something, therefore it must be done! We're currently on the third step. I'd love for there to be a rational, coherent solution…

> - acceptance: something must be done, X is something, therefore it must be done!

That's not acceptance. That's the politician's syllogism, and it's a logical fallacy. Acceptance is "This is the way it is, and I/we can't change it."

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone else feel like staying off HN for a bit?

#18

One of the saddest things on here in my opinion is how vehemently people hate China. No critical thinking ability at all.

Have you heard of Tiananmen square? That government is getting rich while the western world is collapsing on itself.

China has 600mln people living with under 140$ per month and 1% controlling 70% of the wealth.

It is certainly a cause of concern, it's the closest thing as a Star Wars' Galactic Empire I can think of.

Re: Ask HN: Does anyone else feel like staying off HN for a bit?

#20
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If always is 2 months, you comment only confirms the curtness that has increased. I agree with OP that the quality on HN has decreased recently, both stories and comments. This has been a progression over several years from my perspective.

OP’s account is 3 months old.

yes, and i think the first post is criticizing HN content.
Post reply on HN