Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why Bing (and others) is so behind Google in features?

news.ycombinator.com

11–16 of 16 posts

Re: Ask HN: Why Bing (and others) is so behind Google in features?

#11
Look, I’m not a fan of Google but to me and everyone I’ve met outside of HN, it is vastly superior to Bing.

There is an anti-Google agenda on HN, possibly rightfully so, but still. Claiming that Bing is better than Google doesn’t magically make it so.

Re: Ask HN: Why Bing (and others) is so behind Google in features?

#12

No, I liked Google's results better 10 years ago. They are trying too hard to guess what I am asking for, and sometimes I find it difficult to look for a variety of answers because I get the one "right" answer, posted on a couple dozen pages. Some searches turn up so many of their new widgets that I don't even feel like I get a page of results... just canned questions and answers and widgets. Other searches give me 2…

> They are trying too hard to guess what I am asking for,

If you’ve ever watched a non tech person use a search engine, you’ll realize why they’re probably doing that. Most people I’ve seen type their question into Google, rather than “search terms”. I imagine this is the norm since the whole concept of a keyword search requires some understanding of how the first search engines worked.

Re: Ask HN: Why Bing (and others) is so behind Google in features?

#13
post #12

No, I liked Google's results better 10 years ago. They are trying too hard to guess what I am asking for, and sometimes I find it difficult to look for a variety of answers because I get the one "right" answer, posted on a couple dozen pages. Some searches turn up so many of their new widgets that I don't even feel like I get a page of results... just canned questions and answers and widgets. Other searches give me 2…

> They are trying too hard to guess what I am asking for, If you’ve ever watched a non tech person use a search engine, you’ll realize why they’re probably doing that. Most people I’ve seen type their question into Google, rather than “search terms”. I imagine this is the norm since the whole concept of a keyword search requires some understanding of how the first search engines worked.

This is the real answer. I don’t remember what show it was (some stupid big brother reality show), but many years ago I saw a girl search on Google for “if you kiss a dead wet fish on a beach with your lips can you get a disease?” Or something just as asinine and I realized at that moment that search was doomed.

Re: Ask HN: Why Bing (and others) is so behind Google in features?

#15
Here is why I've been using BING since starting, 1. Comparing Search Results: 99% same in both on my needs 2. UI. I like Bing interface - quick leads to images and videos and the UI in all categories. 3. Content presentation - MS being top Developer friendly content portal, they apply a lot in Bing navigation. 4. No Old Cached results: Bing doesn't have much of before Bing results like google has that breaks. 5. User engagement Home Page: Treating you to learn, developing curiosity, with Informative Pictures, News scroll, Bing rewards questions - a quick brain training session, I've learned a lot (honestly) 6. No annoying Personalization .

Google advantages over Bing: 1. Map: I some times switch to google map 2. Old Cached data (Before Bing) - thought it breaks, some times it helps weather the data / site is active or not.

Post reply on HN