Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Time to pull the plug?

news.ycombinator.com

11–18 of 18 posts

Re: Ask HN: Time to pull the plug?

#11
post #5
post #2

why do you want to deadpool it?

Main reason is the money. I'm not a programmer, so fixing bugs, update scrappers, server, etc. cost money.

I decide whether to continue on a project based on opportunity cost. Do I have ideas to try out? Do I feel optimistic they'll teach me something? Do I think the project has a chance of eventual success? When I run out of ideas I stop working on a project. Usually I'm working on something else by then.

Re: Ask HN: Time to pull the plug?

#12
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I like the idea, but think I'd need more users before I could attract the attention of senators/aides/other. Congress members have their websites, email list of their supporters, would need to offer something they didn't have.

Just an idea, but you could whitebox the software and sell it to congresspeople to use on their websites. You are right that without the traction they may not want to affiliate themselves with you, but they still want the functionality. Technically other voting software may fulfill requirements but people always like specialized and you are already in this space and would be considered an "authority".

Agreed, thats what i was thinking as well.

Re: Ask HN: Time to pull the plug?

#13
An excellent idea! The public needs effective ways of making their voices heard. Your site just needs heaps more exposure to gain more traction.

You don't mention what your motivations for setting up the site are. Since there appears to be no way to monetize it, there might be some other agenda?

Went off and took a look at govit.com site. A few comments:

The name "govit" just doesn't jell for me. I think you need something trendier, click2vote, SamClick ...

"Beta" suggests that the site isn't complete. Any progressive web site remains as work-in-progress as it adapts to the demands of the marketplace.

The concept appears to be sound. Needs heaps more marketing, PR, exposure, get talked about, get journalists quote your stats, etc. Yeah! lots of chicken or egg problems. But you have enough to build up momentum.

Re: Ask HN: Time to pull the plug?

#14

An excellent idea! The public needs effective ways of making their voices heard. Your site just needs heaps more exposure to gain more traction. You don't mention what your motivations for setting up the site are. Since there appears to be no way to monetize it, there might be some other agenda? Went off and took a look at govit.com site. A few comments: The name "govit" just doesn't jell for me. I think you need som…

Thanks, glad you like.

My motivations were fairly pure, wanted to build a platform that gave citizens more power. Also thought there could be a way to monetize (ethically) with traction.

Got some press in the early days, and believe the problem is other than exposure. The site just isn't filling a need. Need to come up with something people really want.

Re: Ask HN: Time to pull the plug?

#15
post #14

An excellent idea! The public needs effective ways of making their voices heard. Your site just needs heaps more exposure to gain more traction. You don't mention what your motivations for setting up the site are. Since there appears to be no way to monetize it, there might be some other agenda? Went off and took a look at govit.com site. A few comments: The name "govit" just doesn't jell for me. I think you need som…

Thanks, glad you like. My motivations were fairly pure, wanted to build a platform that gave citizens more power. Also thought there could be a way to monetize (ethically) with traction. Got some press in the early days, and believe the problem is other than exposure. The site just isn't filling a need. Need to come up with something people really want.

I like the idea very much, and have a suggestion for you, if you are trying to be non-partisan, as indicated by your comment. I think you should change some of the colour scheme on the website, especially on the won/lost bar, because using red to denote loss, and blue to denote winning makes it seem like you are 'siding' with the democratic party. You might also want to change the colour of the banner, and possibly hide the number of votes for each side on incomplete polls, so as not to make users feel like part of a small minority who participates (which would be discouraging), unless there are a large number of voters.

Disclosure: I am a Canadian with no interest in US internal politics, and would just like to see this kind of site succeed.

Post reply on HN