Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Best resources to gain math intuition?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 92 posts

Re: Ask HN: Best resources to gain math intuition?

#11
Learn linear algebra properly. Like many folks on HN, I really enjoyed Axler's Linear Algebra Done Right, but ymmv. I got a ton out of going through each of the proofs + practice problems and really taking the time to work through the solutions. It wasn't enough for me to just read the text.

There's a linear algebra lurking everywhere in the realm of applied math (some people like to joke that machine learning is really just linear algebra) so it really is worth your time to have a firm understanding of it.

Re: Ask HN: Best resources to gain math intuition?

#13
post #9

If you mean "gaps in my education" or "basic things that I don't quite understand", you could try studying some high-quality texts. Look for books written by extremely smart people who are trying to explain the ideas rather than taking you through the standard topics. Hamming's books on probability and signal processing and Strang's books on linear algebra and applied math come to mind. Alternatively if you're really…

Are the Math olympiads similar to competitive coding?

Re: Ask HN: Best resources to gain math intuition?

#14
I used to love the abstract symbolic manipulation of pure math, but have not worked with it in many years and find it unintuitive now. I have a harder time trusting the abstractions. I wonder how to get my old sense back - it never, ever came from practice problems for example in the past. I miss proofs

Re: Ask HN: Best resources to gain math intuition?

#15
It's probably too hard to answer the general question about "how to gain math intuition". Mathematics is just too vast.

However, you have written

> I think when I took physics it really brought out these flaws and lack of intuition

which suggests you have some good practical experience with physics problem solving which has precipitated a certain feeling that you need to learn more about some kind of math. I would advise that you try to exploit this. In the same breath I want to recognize (as someone who did their BS and MS in physics) that physicists are not always so careful or explicit in how they are doing their mathematics. So learning means eventually going beyond physics sources and into a much wider world of mathematical thought. The particular things that mathematicians care about may or may not be relevant to the problem you are trying to solve in physics, and a good part of developing that intuition is to figure out which particular caveats that a mathematician expounds upon (more often than not, some esoterica about the space(s) that they are working in or the class of isomorphisms under which their results are invariant) matter physically. As you develop and intuition about these things a bonus is that you will be able to skim through mathematics resources much faster.

Re: Ask HN: Best resources to gain math intuition?

#17
My suggestion would be this. Assume that you have your intuition, already, and it is good.

May be it is distinct from others, may be you will not be 'narrowing' to the right answer within seconds -- like many folks who do Olympiads...

Just do basic things, but every other day. Get books/materials that have solutions (not just problems). use those, compare your results, and then try again.

If you feel like you do not understand 'why', you will need a particular subject area. Switch to read about applications of that area, how historically it came about and so.

And then back to problem solving, proofs, and reading other people's papers (when you can..).

It is hard work, but over time you will build up your version of the so called intuition, it will be powerful, you will be able to apply it all over the place.

Also there are a number of math forums where you can reach out, if you are really stuck and cannot figure out how a particular proof, or solution was obtained.

Re: Ask HN: Best resources to gain math intuition?

#18
A lot of intuition in math is from geometry. High school plane geometry is a good start, but high school solid geometry, where get good tools and intuition for seeing things in 3D instead of just the 2D of plane geometry, is quite a bit better.

Another part of intuition is from Max Zorn (from Zorn's lemma statement of the axiom of choice):

"Be wise, generalize."

E.g., for the set of real numbers R and a positive integer n, a lot that goes on in the n-dimensional vector space R^n is a generalization of what can see in 3D, e.g., from solid geometry.

E.g., in both cases, a biggie is a perpendicular (orthogonal) projection and, again, the Pythagorean theorem. E.g., regression in statistics is a perpendicular projection.

Perpendicular (orthogonality) is a biggie and is a major part of, say, Fourier series. I.e., each of the sine/cosine waves used is an orthogonal axis, and to find the corresponding Fourier series coefficient just project onto that axis. The projection is an integral of a product, and that is commonly an inner product which close to just a cosine of an angle as in plane and solid geometry and a perpendicular projection and close to correlation in statistics, etc.

E.g., a huge fraction of applied math is from analysis in pure math, and from G. F. Simmons the two pillars of analysis are "continuity and linearity". Linearity generalizes enormously: The quantum mechanics super position is essentially linearity. Under meager assumptions, differentiation and integration in calculus are linear operators. In probability theory, expectation is a linear operator. The wave equation is a linear partial differential equation. Linear programming works on linear equations. Of course, in linear algebra, matrix multiplication is a linear operator. When something is not linear, it may be locally linear which can be enough to get useful results.

For more, a good lesson is to approximate: Commonly we can't get just what we want in just one step but can iterate and approximate as closely as we please. So, can use simple things, sine waves, polynomials, continuous functions, and more, as means of approximation. Such approximation gets us close to more in continuity and, in particular, completeness -- the real numbers are complete and the rational numbers are not but via iteration can approximate the reals as closely as we please. Then this generalizes: The big point about Hilbert space (as mathematicians but not always physicists define it) is completeness. A joke, partly correct, is that "calculus is the elementary consequences of the completeness property of the real number system". E.g., the integral in calculus (and its better version in measure theory) is defined in terms of an iterative approximation. So, if you are good with sine waves, polynomials, continuous functions, wavelets, and more, then you can iterate and approximate a lot, in many cases, everything there is in that case.

Re: Ask HN: Best resources to gain math intuition?

#19
post #9

If you mean "gaps in my education" or "basic things that I don't quite understand", you could try studying some high-quality texts. Look for books written by extremely smart people who are trying to explain the ideas rather than taking you through the standard topics. Hamming's books on probability and signal processing and Strang's books on linear algebra and applied math come to mind. Alternatively if you're really…

Are the Math olympiads similar to competitive coding?

Yeah.

At the high school and college level, the Olympiads for math and CS are pretty analogous. But there's really popular semi-formal coding contests which exist outside academia which don't really have a math equivalent.

I'd say math contests are more popular among high schoolers, and semi-formal coding contests more popular among college students.

Art of Problem Solving (AoPS) [https://artofproblemsolving.com/] is a really good resource, and there's a very healthy online community.

They're also similar in how olympiads are different from the "real thing" (TM).

Academia.SE discussion about this [https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86451/does-the-...]

As someone who did math olympiads in high school, my 2 cents is that they're a fantastic way to learn how to solve and approach problems and gain intuition. And I'd say intuition mainly comes from solving problems.

Re: Ask HN: Best resources to gain math intuition?

#20
I'm going to answer this assuming you mean gaining number sense, which is something I didn't realize I was missing until I gained it.

I got my undergrad in math and physics. I was good at math. It wasn't until I had been teaching high school for 3-4 years when some gave me a copy of Shortcut Math by Gerard Kelly. After reading it and practicing the techniques, arithmetic made so much sense. I was able to easily add, subtract, and multiply larger numbers in my head.

Interestingly enough, many of the techniques taught in this book are also part of the common core math curriculum. It's a way to help students gain number sense.

Post reply on HN