Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 50 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

#11
Yes. I don't live in the states. I travel nearly non-stop. I was sick to handle literally dozens of SIM cards and go through the possibly painful registration process in many countries abroad. Cheaper Google Project FI Phones were sold out. So I coughed up nearly 1k for a Pixel One 64 GB google project fi phone.

Otherwise a 200 Dollar phone is likely more than enough. Actually, since I buy laptops used, my phone nearly costs three times as much as my refurbished dell XPS 14"

Re: Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

#12
Do you rally need a $1000: -pair of shoes? -pants? -tshirt? -jacket? -pen? -?

No you definitely don't need. You want!

Now then.. how come you/I/anyone ends up wanting a $1000 phone? Marketing? Vanity? Riches beyng sense? Need for portable computing power? Need to constantly have with you 5000 photos, 5000 songs, 50 movies?

Re: Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

#13
Android in particular really benefits from the faster hardware in my experience. I fly frequently so I get a lot out of more storage and better displays as well. Battery life is a big deal. That added up to me getting a Note 9. The main thing I use the pen for is just taking screenshots.

Really for me it's just a nice to have though. A few years ago I got by with a Lumia 520, I'm sure I could live with a $100 Android phone if the cost were an issue. But I use my phone a lot so it's worth it for me.

Re: Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

#14

I don't even spend $1k on my cars. While I'd love to have a new, secure, iPhone I can't justify that level of expense. Regardless, what other people do with their money isn't your problem.

You don't even spend $1,000 on your car? Sheesh, are you like 17?

Re: Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

#15
NO! Not at all. Jesus Apple. Give me a break. I like the privacy, I am invested in the ecosystem, and I can afford it, but a phone isn't worth $1000 dollars to me. It isn't a computer, it can never replace my macbook, and it will never be anywhere near a third as valuable to me.

Re: Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

#17
I am a pretty consumerist person. If I had a choice between working-little-and-having-little, and working-a-lot-and-having-a-lot, I'd choose the latter.

I didn't choose the above attitude consciously per se, but thinking about it in retrospect, I'm comfortable with it. I have a lot of product-category-choices that make little sense to someone unwilling to spend $1000 on a phone: wool underwear, an Onyx Boox Max 2 (wonderful device), an Urbit star. I don't spend money pragmatically.

Re: Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

#18

"Need" is too of a strong word. People doesn't need a $80,000 car that can go from 0-60 miles per hour in 1.9 seconds in a country whose max highway speed is around 75mph but they buy it anyway when they can afford it.

Highway traffic speed on a clear day not during rush hour = speed limit + speeding amount required to get a misdemeanor - 1-2mph.

Consequently there's lots of semi-limited access state highways that have the occasional stop light and 45-55mph speed limits giving you plenty of opportunities to enjoy fast 0-60 acceleration. Also, the ability to just move left and almost instantly be going 30+mph faster is great when the person in front of you insists on merging at 35mph (you can go around them WITHOUT cutting someone else off). Or if you are that 35mph merger you can take your sweet ass time finding the perfect spot and then just step on it and merge without the guy you merged in front of (who's probably going 70+mph) having to tap their brakes.

Yes, it's a luxury but the capability is more useful day to day than most people think.

Re: Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

#19
Most (non-tech) people I know are interested in the camera. People are change-adverse (so those with an Apple device want to stay on iOS) and want the latest photo taking capabilities.

Especially for friends who rely on photos for their jobs / side projects, it is a huge difference comparing pictures from a Google Pixel / iPhone X and phone models from a few years ago.

Re: Ask HN: Do you really need a $1000 phone?

#20
When I heard what they were charging for the iPhone X I thought it was a joke. but I know several people who now have them, and they all say it was worth it. And they can't explain why. I suspect they're all deluding themselves, like people who have watched 9 seasons of a terrible TV show and try to convince you it was worth the time and you should watch all 9 seasons too. I can't understand it. I wouldn't even spend that much on a full laptop. I stay 2-3 years behind the curve. I can buy a phone that was state of the art in 2015 for <300 and do everything the guy with the iPhone X can do.
Post reply on HN