Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Minimalistic web design works?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 31 posts

Re: Ask HN: Minimalistic web design works?

#11
http://www.anncoulter.com/

Despite her craziness, Ann Coulter has a fairly nice minimalist website (well, it looks minimalist). Although that quotations thing off to the side kinda ruins it, AFAIK it was recently added (I don't remember seeing it during to school year, when I last visited), so you might check the wayback machine.

Re: Ask HN: Minimalistic web design works?

#12
post #11

http://www.anncoulter.com/ Despite her craziness, Ann Coulter has a fairly nice minimalist website (well, it looks minimalist). Although that quotations thing off to the side kinda ruins it, AFAIK it was recently added (I don't remember seeing it during to school year, when I last visited), so you might check the wayback machine.

Hrm not sure I agree, to my understsanding minimalism is all about making sure the main thing that draws your eyes is the content, here all of the stuff on the right is completely distracting from the content.

Re: Ask HN: Minimalistic web design works?

#13
This would be a fine design for a personal blog, but no, it's not something that should be presented to a client.

Most design clients want art. They want something that is uniquely theirs; they want a combination of colors and patterns and graphics that are unmistakably unique. The designer's job is to reconcile art with function. What you built is all function, and no art.

(But I like it.)

Re: Ask HN: Minimalistic web design works?

#15

I don't mind the look too much but I do hate the all ajax navigation that gratuitously breaks the back button. I also don't like the fake scrollbar and the arbitrarily small content window that wastes half of my window height--I've got a large screen, I shouldn't have to look at your content through a peephole. I personally like the muted colors and lack of gradient/round corners/drop shadows everywhere but I can see…

i second the ajax hating. the site also doesnt degrade gracefully when javascript is turned off.

Re: Ask HN: Minimalistic web design works?

#17
It works to a certain extent in real life, but it won't work in BITS Pilani, until you find the right person or word it in the right way.

I am saying this because I actually over heard the management say that it isn't good for "business" if people thought x about the institute at the conference my mother forced me to attended, which is just... sad.

It isn't that their education quality is less (same texts; good enough teachers will give you the required amount of education. The rest is up to you). It's just that it is less likely to find free thinkers over there who are willing to speak out. If there are smart people on the faculty (there must be) they choose their battles carefully and in this case they would tow the managements line. If this was TIFR or IISc (I say this out of first hand experience) then it would have been fine, because they encourage such stuff and they would be delighted to find someone on the tail end of the curve.

Should I give you some advice as someone who has been through this?

Give them what they want.

Your professors are wise and follow their lead over here. Building a website is something trivial in the longer run and you have to pick your battles wisely. Spend the same energy in mastering this as it's obvious that you have a talent at work over here. Remember fighting with idiots tends to make you an idiot.

So, tread softly because you tread on your dreams.

Anyway, take care.

Re: Ask HN: Minimalistic web design works?

#18
Jason Fried had a quote recently about proportion in design and the space between elements of the design. Although you have a minimal number of elements in your design, their arrangement isn't in the right proportion. It's not harmonious.

http://37signals.com/svn/posts/2531-great-proportions-melt-a...

There are a few other basic things that could be changed to make the site much more usable. As someone else said, don't break the back button. Ditch the scrolly boxes. You don't need them and they're unintuitive. Differentiate the links on the page from the rest of the text. Right now the navigation links are the same grey as the rest of the content. You have some red text mixed in there and it looks clickable, but it isn't.

You're off to a good start, it just needs some refinement.

Re: Ask HN: Minimalistic web design works?

#19
post #10
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If I'm honest the "restraint of colour" is really a lack of colour. It needs colour - I fall foul of this all the time as I don't mind grey-scale colour schemes but it really needs at least 1, preferably two colours.

Restrained greyscale (maybe 2-3 values plus black) and a strong accent color is the "little black dress" of web design, and an easy way for non-designers to produce designs that, while probably unspectacular, will at least look competant.

I second that. I tried to put colours on my web site[1], and failed miserably. Any colour scheme I could come up with was ugly. I finally gave up and settled on the more manageable grey scale.

[1]: http://www.loup-vaillant.fr

Re: Ask HN: Minimalistic web design works?

#20
For minimalism to work you need strong content. This website doesn't have that. Even with strong content this design still has plenty of problems. That link hover effect is awful. It feels like I'm playing whack-a-mole. You also limited the content to a fixed height container. That would come back to bite you if page content increases significantly or average screen resolution increases. The website is also very forgettable. It has no real identity of it's own. The name isn't even in the overall template.
Post reply on HN