Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 80 posts

Re: Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

#11
I've been using AWS for years, but the recent downtime for GCE got me to take a look at what Google was offering. (Makes no sense right? All publicity is good publicity?)

I was blown away by the UX of both the console and the instances themselves. Example: when you add a new user/public key in the console, it propagates to instances automatically. Sure, you could do that yourself, but the default features are just really nice to have.

Re: Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

#12

I think it's a complex question. AWS is far ahead in terms of maturity of the service, breadth of services, ecosystem support. On the other hand, Google Compute Platform is "up and coming", and in general it is trying to attract customers by offering lower-than-AWS prices on most comparable services. AWS is also a safer bet. At the same time, Google is big enough that betting on it is not as risky as betting on anoth…

GCE is pretty much based on Google internal technologies and infrastructure. They had a low profile on GCE, they services are more hand picked, but it's a mature and complete service offering.

Re: Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

#13
post #10

Are they even comparable? AWS offers full virtual machines. I was under the impression that GCE offers a more high level platform where you run your code in their proprietery environment? If I am not mistaken, using GCE means you are locked in and cannot migrate away easily. That's why I never looked into it closely. I don't want to be at the mercy of a provider.

GCE ~= EC2

GAE ~= Elastic Beanstalk

Re: Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

#14
post #10

Are they even comparable? AWS offers full virtual machines. I was under the impression that GCE offers a more high level platform where you run your code in their proprietery environment? If I am not mistaken, using GCE means you are locked in and cannot migrate away easily. That's why I never looked into it closely. I don't want to be at the mercy of a provider.

GCE is just VMs

Re: Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

#15
post #10

Are they even comparable? AWS offers full virtual machines. I was under the impression that GCE offers a more high level platform where you run your code in their proprietery environment? If I am not mistaken, using GCE means you are locked in and cannot migrate away easily. That's why I never looked into it closely. I don't want to be at the mercy of a provider.

Google Compute Engine offers virtual machines, Google App Engine is the special app platform where you have no control over the individual instances that your app runs on.

Re: Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

#16
post #2

AWS, hands down. They're years ahead, and the support is just as lousy.

Serious question, when would you need to use support? I always wonder that when people say Microsoft is better than Linux because it has support, but actually I've never had a time when I needed Linux support.....

Re: Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

#17
post #2

AWS, hands down. They're years ahead, and the support is just as lousy.

Serious question, when would you need to use support? I always wonder that when people say Microsoft is better than Linux because it has support, but actually I've never had a time when I needed Linux support.....

I've had to use their support many times for many complex problems around things like networking, outages, feature requests, and so on. It is truly a mixed bag. They have highly competent people working there. The problem is, they have layered in an intentionally incompetent tier of people in front of them. That's support.

Re: Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

#18

How do HN commenters rank Azure amongst the three? I like the UI/portals quite a bit, but haven't explored any of the 3 major cloud providers in great detail.

Serious question: have you had to _use_ the Azure portal for anything?

Like much enterprise software, the new side-scrolling mess which hides necessary information has the distinct smell of something that was built to sell on golf courses to clueless middle and upper management, and not for people who actually need to do the work. The load times are horrible because of the number of HTTP requests and the weight of their payloads, making it practically unusable on, say, plane wifi or tethering outside of LTE service.

Practically this might not be the worst thing ever, because it might encourage people to describe their infrastructure as code instead of a pointy-clicky mess, but sadly this still appears to be outside the Microsoft-blessed way to do things - so most never will.

Re: Ask HN: Which cloud provider to use in 2016? AWS or GCE?

#19
post #10

Are they even comparable? AWS offers full virtual machines. I was under the impression that GCE offers a more high level platform where you run your code in their proprietery environment? If I am not mistaken, using GCE means you are locked in and cannot migrate away easily. That's why I never looked into it closely. I don't want to be at the mercy of a provider.

My guess is OP meant to say AWS vs GCP (Google Cloud Platform) instead of GCE (Google Compute Engine).
Post reply on HN