Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 22 posts

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#11

Post by trcollinson »

jhamar wrote: post #8
trcollinson wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How did you come up with a $1MM valuation? Do you have users? If so, how many? What is your path to profitability? That's a 5% stake which might be ok. It really depends on a number of factors. My guess is that in the iOS app market for a chat app in 2015. I think that might be high. But you might also surprise me.

Well we have been unofficially launched for two months and just passed 1,000 MAU'S. We have a couple of high profile users (NBA ALL STAR) and we are going to launched again on Product Hunt next week by a well known influencer . . . . The market is growing and we are solving a problem that many others have abandoned. It's just about growing this thing. We need 50k for the next year to focus on growth and increasing th…

I'll try to tread on this gently. The theme of my comment is "I don't invest in hopes and dreams, I invest to make money."

I know you are saying you are working to solve a problem that no one is looking at but when you say "chat" and "ios" I can only think of saturated markets. You have all sorts of chat solutions for all sorts of needs. What makes you different? What will get you millions of users? Saying you have influencers and NBA Stars brings to mind, well, twitter. And honestly that doesn't help. You have an up Hill battle to convince me as an investor. If you can, I'll invest.

Second, your valuation is way off. Within the last 18 months we have a really successful sale of a venture backed chat application, whatsapp. They got $42.20 per user valuation. That would place you at a $42,200 total valuation. Of course, that's just a fake valuation, you aren't there. The only reason whatsapp got that much was because of the volume of non-US users they had. You have no volume. You are trying to sell me that you are work $1,000 per user. That's an up Hill battle as well. Unless you have a massive market differentiator, it's a tough sell.

I'm not saying it will be impossible. But you need to show me how I am going to turn my $50,000 into a lot more. If you can pay me back within a year, I'll take $75,000 total. If you need it for 10 years, I better see a 1000% return. Remember, many other people have startups which will give me that type of return. You have to show me why you're better than them.

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#12

Post by MalcolmDiggs »

They may be right. But the good news is: You don't need investors (plural)... you don't need all the Angels in Silicon Valley to fawn over you. If all you need is 50k, then you just need one good relationship with one good Angel. What the masses of investors think about you doesn't really matter, just try and find the one who's the best fit.

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#13

Post by pavornyoh »

SEJeff wrote: post #9
jhamar wrote: post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, my team & I can live off of 12 months and work on Blastchat 24/7!

Where are you living to be able to live off of that with a team for a year?

I am curious to see the answer to the question @SEJeff asked. How big is your team for you guys to survive on $50k for an entire year?

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#14

Post by Zergy »

pavornyoh wrote: post #13
SEJeff wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where are you living to be able to live off of that with a team for a year?

I am curious to see the answer to the question @SEJeff asked. How big is your team for you guys to survive on $50k for an entire year?

I believe it was a poor attempt at sarcasm.

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#15

Post by pavornyoh »

Zergy wrote: post #14
pavornyoh wrote: post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am curious to see the answer to the question @SEJeff asked. How big is your team for you guys to survive on $50k for an entire year?

I believe it was a poor attempt at sarcasm.

@Zergy.. I hope so. I have tried thinking where in the U.S can you achieve this you know.. :)

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#16

Post by argonaut »

patio11 wrote: post #10

"People" are right, if you're talking about angel investors who are professional and subscribe to, say, Valley-or-equivalent norms. Why? 1) Your investors will model $50k as being gone in an eyeblink. In the Valley, that's ~3 engineer-months. Angels will want your round to last about 12~18 months. 2) All entrepreneurs raising their first round are inexperienced in some way, but for better or worse, the combination of…

Right on. One thing to note is that I have definitely seen angel investors invest <= 50k into companies, but it's always been on top of (following) a larger angel/VC leading the round. E.g. one person contributes 500k-1M, a bunch of angels contribute <=50k. But that's not the OP's case.

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#17

Post by argonaut »

trcollinson wrote: post #11
jhamar wrote: post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well we have been unofficially launched for two months and just passed 1,000 MAU'S. We have a couple of high profile users (NBA ALL STAR) and we are going to launched again on Product Hunt next week by a well known influencer . . . . The market is growing and we are solving a problem that many others have abandoned. It's just about growing this thing. We need 50k for the next year to focus on growth and increasing th…

I'll try to tread on this gently. The theme of my comment is "I don't invest in hopes and dreams, I invest to make money." I know you are saying you are working to solve a problem that no one is looking at but when you say "chat" and "ios" I can only think of saturated markets. You have all sorts of chat solutions for all sorts of needs. What makes you different? What will get you millions of users? Saying you have i…

This is really inaccurate. These sort of metrics have very little relevance in seed investing. For better or worse (and some of the savviest seed investors have done ludicrously well this way), seed investing is not about your numbers; it's about the team, the market, and the idea. No reputable seed investor in Silicon Valley calculates seed valuations this way (a scaled function of Whatsapp's valuation and the startup's own user numbers).

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#18

Post by rajacombinator »

trcollinson wrote: post #11
jhamar wrote: post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well we have been unofficially launched for two months and just passed 1,000 MAU'S. We have a couple of high profile users (NBA ALL STAR) and we are going to launched again on Product Hunt next week by a well known influencer . . . . The market is growing and we are solving a problem that many others have abandoned. It's just about growing this thing. We need 50k for the next year to focus on growth and increasing th…

I'll try to tread on this gently. The theme of my comment is "I don't invest in hopes and dreams, I invest to make money." I know you are saying you are working to solve a problem that no one is looking at but when you say "chat" and "ios" I can only think of saturated markets. You have all sorts of chat solutions for all sorts of needs. What makes you different? What will get you millions of users? Saying you have i…

You clearly don't invest in early stage startups. Alternately, one can read this as "unsophisticated non-SV investor's perspective."

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#19

Post by trcollinson »

argonaut wrote: post #17
trcollinson wrote: post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'll try to tread on this gently. The theme of my comment is "I don't invest in hopes and dreams, I invest to make money." I know you are saying you are working to solve a problem that no one is looking at but when you say "chat" and "ios" I can only think of saturated markets. You have all sorts of chat solutions for all sorts of needs. What makes you different? What will get you millions of users? Saying you have i…

This is really inaccurate. These sort of metrics have very little relevance in seed investing. For better or worse (and some of the savviest seed investors have done ludicrously well this way), seed investing is not about your numbers; it's about the team, the market, and the idea. No reputable seed investor in Silicon Valley calculates seed valuations this way (a scaled function of Whatsapp's valuation and the start…

I appreciate your dissenting view. I don't mean to say this is the only metric by which a seed fund will evaluate a business. If it was likely that there was any market for ephemeral twitter, then the per user valuation would be totally meaningless, you're right. But after looking at blast chat these would be my questions. How do you grow from 1000 users to something higher? How do you turn a profit for me? Of course if the team were amazing and the product had any hope of being pivoted into something lucrative, I would be interested. But, from the looks of it, to me, it's not.

A few other thoughts. Nothing about this post says that this group is in the valley. Not all seed investors are in the valley. Not all companies are in the valley. It's a poor assumption to think they are.

Seed investors want a very healthy return on their investment and they want it relatively quickly. You may invest $5,000,000 or $50,000,000 or whatever amount you'd like blindly in whatever increment makes you feel good. But if you don't evaluate the investments you are making, you won't he investing for long. The "Savy Silicon Valley investors" don't invest blindly.

I've been told many times when rejecting a company that I have made a poor choice because of x, y, or z. My reply I'd always the same, "feel free to pull out your own $50,000 and invest. I have plenty of opportunities." I don't mean it to sound snarky. It's just reality. Investors always have processes. This is mine.

Re: Ask HN: 50k round not taken seriously by angels?

#20

Post by jhamar »

SEJeff wrote: post #9
jhamar wrote: post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, my team & I can live off of 12 months and work on Blastchat 24/7!

Where are you living to be able to live off of that with a team for a year?

NJ - 15 minutes from NYC - 50k will be used for some growth hacks and living expenses at my dad's house . . . . just hustling man!
Post reply on HN