It seems like a lot of the blight of data centers is the energy to remove the heat. By distributing them into cool basements and even connecting them into the home heating system we could reduce that making them more efficient.
Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
1–10 of 69 posts
Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
#2Not really the only issue actually, the electricity bill would be astronomical for a household and also have you heard the noise from them ?
Issues with them being distributed range from Data protection to Insurance against damage, connectivity issues. Noble maybe, but it's widely unrealistic.
Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
#3Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
#4Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
#5> It seems like a lot of the blight of data centers is the energy to remove the heat. Not really the only issue actually, the electricity bill would be astronomical for a household and also have you heard the noise from them ? Issues with them being distributed range from Data protection to Insurance against damage, connectivity issues. Noble maybe, but it's widely unrealistic.
Data protection is an issue, but maybe this is something that SGX and family can provide eventually.
A scheme like this makes a lot of sense for distributed redundant backups.
The real problem is bandwidth. Most home users still don’t have decent symmetrical bandwidth. If you could solve this, then home servers could provide a handful of edge services to others in the area. I’m not sure where this makes sense versus local colo though.
Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
#6Why don't we all have small farms on our properties, turning lawns into vegetable producing land for each household?
Why don't we have small datacenters on the property of each business, so the business users and IT folks can keep track of their own servers and data and applications?
Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
#7> It seems like a lot of the blight of data centers is the energy to remove the heat. Not really the only issue actually, the electricity bill would be astronomical for a household and also have you heard the noise from them ? Issues with them being distributed range from Data protection to Insurance against damage, connectivity issues. Noble maybe, but it's widely unrealistic.
A half rack server in a basement isn’t going to consume a lot of power or generate that much noise. I have home servers and they are fine. Data protection is an issue, but maybe this is something that SGX and family can provide eventually. A scheme like this makes a lot of sense for distributed redundant backups. The real problem is bandwidth. Most home users still don’t have decent symmetrical bandwidth. If you coul…
I have home servers, designed for home and they are not too bad, and I can turn them off when sleeping for example.. It's very different with a 20U server running and spinning non stop. Not many people will have the soundproofing to simply not hear it at night.
I don't know, I wouldn't see it working, but I'm just one.
Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
#8You would have issues with providing the reliability levels (read: SLA) that we come to expect from data centers. But, if there are enough services that we don't care about if they go down for a few hours, this could be doable. It still relies on the assumption that we got enough services to justify the effort though. It is way more realistic if you set up your own homelab and provide services to your family, under t…
Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
#9Without a truly zero-trust compute platform its going to be difficult to get anyone to trust their workloads to a random compute resource that isn't carefully guarded.
Re: Ask HN: Distributed data centers in our basements
#10https://news.infomaniak.com/en/infomaniak-inaugurates-a-revo...