Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Please stop "This."

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 80 posts

Ask HN: Please stop "This."

#1
Can we discuss "This."?

Maybe it's a very silly thing to be bothered by, but I can't be the only one agitated when I read a response to anything that begins simply with "This."

It's my personal feeling is that "This." is a sign of the decline of intelligent discourse on HN. I feel like "This." is usually karma fishing, and that their comment more than likely adds nothing to the discourse, and is often a predictor of immaturity.

I'd like to know what everyone else thinks.

Re: Ask HN: Please stop "This."

#6
The problems are that upvotes are invisible and anonymous. The website has no built-in mechanism to tell other people that they should pay attention to a given post.

Re: Ask HN: Please stop "This."

#8
post #6

The problems are that upvotes are invisible and anonymous. The website has no built-in mechanism to tell other people that they should pay attention to a given post.

IIRC the individual posts are sorted by votes so upvoting should be sufficient

Re: Ask HN: Please stop "This."

#10
I think it was popularised on vBulletin/phpBB style forums where people quote another post (using BBCode) and add nothing but "This." below, as if to say "This is what I'd have said if I got here first".

    +------------------------------+
    | xXMasterChiefXx              |
    |------------------------------|
    |                              |
    |   +----------------------+   |
    |   | ShadowKiller2K said: |   |
    |   |----------------------|   |
    |   |                      |   |
    |   | Xbawks > PS3         |   |
    |   |                      |   |
    |   +----------------------+   |
    |                              |
    |   This.                      |
    |                              |
    +------------------------------+ 
(I'm amused that these made-up usernames have tons of results in Google!)

I remember a specific user on a forum I used to participate in that did the quote+this thing constantly, as if they were trying to build up a reputation of being a sage individual without having to do a lick of original thinking.

Post reply on HN