Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 45 posts

Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

#1
I've noticed a trend in technical material being authored on Medium behind a registration wall. Are people really generating enough revenue to warrant publishing tech articles on Medium to offset the greater good of making the material broadly available?

Gist offers public visibility and commenting without the requisite barrier to entry.

Thoughts?

Re: Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

#2
I don't have a Medium account and I don't like running into paywalls but monetization could potentially have very little to do with the motivation to use a publishing platform like Medium over what is essentially an orphaned single public commit.

Re: Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

#4
post #3

I like gists and I have used them for years for my (non-medium) blog. I usually break down whatever I am explaining piece by piece and then include a link to a gist with the complete code for the reader.

Interesting. So how do you decide what to publish on Medium? Is it simply a distinction between `blog` content vs. technical docs, or something else?

Re: Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

#5
post #2

I don't have a Medium account and I don't like running into paywalls but monetization could potentially have very little to do with the motivation to use a publishing platform like Medium over what is essentially an orphaned single public commit.

I'm not sure I agree that Gists are `orphaned single public commits` as they have a number of features which encourage collaboration (commenting/stars/history/forking). My concern is that most tech articles represent a perspective at a point-in-time and that the broader community would benefit from a living document. YMMV ;-)

Re: Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

#6
post #3

I like gists and I have used them for years for my (non-medium) blog. I usually break down whatever I am explaining piece by piece and then include a link to a gist with the complete code for the reader.

Interesting. So how do you decide what to publish on Medium? Is it simply a distinction between `blog` content vs. technical docs, or something else?

I don't use medium. My blog is self hosted and if I am breaking down some code I usually include a gist with the complete code.

Re: Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

#7
I was asking a similar question for numerous use cases (e.g. code snippets, book reviews, notes). Gists are so broadly useful, but relatively few developers actually use them. Personally, I found that incorporating gists into my daily workflow just wasn’t very convenient, and so I ended up creating a VS Code extension that allowed me to create, edit, and comment on gists within the editor: https://aka.ms/gistpad.

I’m not sure if ease-of-use is a reason for others to not use gists more frequently, but I’ve definitely become a bit of a gists “advocate”, after appreciating just how useful/flexible it is as a “developer cloud storage” solution.

Re: Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

#8

I was asking a similar question for numerous use cases (e.g. code snippets, book reviews, notes). Gists are so broadly useful, but relatively few developers actually use them. Personally, I found that incorporating gists into my daily workflow just wasn’t very convenient, and so I ended up creating a VS Code extension that allowed me to create, edit, and comment on gists within the editor: https://aka.ms/gistpad . I’…

I use Obsidian and want to incorporate it in with my Gist usage. Found this which might be helpful: https://github.com/defunkt/gist

P.S. My biggest peeve with Gist is the missing dark mode :(. Otherwise, I find that the ability to use Markdown and embedded images in my gist's actually covers most of my documenting/blogging use case. Obsidian will hopefully address the dark mode issue.

Re: Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

#9
If the goal of a blog is to get people to know you better, not just share knowledge, then gist isn’t a great platform for that. People would rather have a blog with clearer branding and personality, that promises more polish, and an offers to give you many ways to get to know the blogger.

I use gist for informal things I don’t have time to turn into a great blog article yet. Or half constructed notes that can live in a pastebin.

I guess I’m curious why medium is the only alternate you list to gist as opposed to creating your own blog outside of medium?

Re: Ask HN: Why are people publishing FAQs/articles on Medium instead of Gist?

#10
You can open an article for no paywall on Medium, but they purposely make it difficult by requiring you to sign up for their partner program (and provide all your taxpayer / payment information) to do so.

So I think it's a split between people who want to try and generate some revenue, and those that don't want to sign up for that program and are too used to Medium to switch away.

Post reply on HN