Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 63 posts

Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#1
Hey guys,

I'm participating in an hackathon and had this idea: users of open source github repos can contribute $X for every commit the developer contributes, with a monthly cap. It's a recurring donation based on development activity.

Give some love to open source devs.

What do you guys think?

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#6
I like the idea of using Patreon for Open Source, but I dislike the idea of tying it to the number of commits, because it creates the wrong incentives.

I've also got the impression that most patrons rather prefer a predictable, monthly amount over a varied amount, even if it comes with a cap.

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#8
I'm using Patreon for Cachet[0] and it works well enough that people can donate, but discovery lacks for projects which aren't media based. Also, I can't setup another Patreon page under the same account, so what about filling in the voids there?

The idea works, the implementation could be improved.

[0] https://patreon.com/jbrooksuk

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#9
post #6

I like the idea of using Patreon for Open Source, but I dislike the idea of tying it to the number of commits, because it creates the wrong incentives. I've also got the impression that most patrons rather prefer a predictable, monthly amount over a varied amount, even if it comes with a cap.

That's why I like Flattr's model - my monthly budget is consistent, even if I occasionally tip projects outside of my regular contributions.

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#10

I'm using Patreon for Cachet[0] and it works well enough that people can donate, but discovery lacks for projects which aren't media based. Also, I can't setup another Patreon page under the same account, so what about filling in the voids there? The idea works, the implementation could be improved. [0] https://patreon.com/jbrooksuk

You could bring your work over to Baqqer. You can create multiple projects and have each one funded individually. Also trying to make discovery and community more robust is part of our core values. Hit me up if you decide to check it out, I'd appreciate your feedback.
Post reply on HN